This is a list I harvested from various threads, IAFD and my own investigations. 5 or more scenes I don't list but you can search at IAFD. I didn't include web only.
Abbey Brooks Big Wet Butts 5 (Brazzers) a2m; Busty Anal Beauties (Evil Angel) a2m
Aiden Aspen Gangland 80 (Devil's) IR; Hot Anal Auditions (Evil Angel); Teacher's Pet 2 (Evil Angel)
Alanah Rae Busty Anal Beauties (Evil Angel) a2m; Lex the Impaler 7 (Jules Jordan) a2m, IR
Alexa Nicole Hot Anal Auditions (Evil Angel) a2m
Alison Tyler Amateur Anal Attempts 25 (Xplor); Big Anal Booties (Evil Angel); In the Butt 7 (Naughty America)
Allison Moore MILF Soup 15 (Bang); Rectal Fuckfest (Evil Angel)
Ally Kay Big Wet Asses 19 (Elegant Angel)
Alyiah Stone Hot Anal Auditions (Evil Angel)
Amber Amateur Anal Attempts 26 (Xplor) creampie
Angel Vain Ass Worship 12 (Jules Jordan)
Angelina Black Gangland 77 (Devil's) IR; Pure 18 no. 19 (Pulse)
Angelina Valentine 5+
Angelina Valentino Monsters of Cock 27 (Bang) IR
Ashley Fires Anal Intensity (Evil Angel); Burning Embers (Evil Angel) DP, a2m
Ashley Winters Evil Cuckhold 2 (Evil Angel IR; Interracial Swingers 2 (Devil's) IR; Mom's Anal Gape Factory (West Coast) IR, creampie
Ashlynn Leigh 11+; 1 DP
Ava Addams Big West Asses 19 (Evil Angel) a2m; Deep Anal Drilling 3 (Jules Jordan) a2m; Hot Anal Auditions (Evil Angel) a2m; Mommy Got Boobs 12 (Brazzers) a2m
BabyXXX Amateur Anal Attempts 26 (Xplor)
Bella Moretti Black Anal Love (West Coast) a2m, creampie; Phat Black Juicy Anal Booty (West Coast)
Bethany Benz Big Black Wet Tits 3 (Elegant Angel); Busty Anal Beauties (Evil Angel) a2m, IR
Bobbi Brixton Don't Tell My Wife I Assfucked the Babysitter 5 (Devil's) a2m; Facial Fest 12 (Bang)
Brandy Aniston Anal Casting Calls (Evil Angel); Evil Anal 14 (Evil Angel)
Briella Bounce 7+
Candy Manson Anal Pornsluts (Evil Angel) a2m; Rectal Fuckfest (Evil Angel) a2m
Casey Cumz 5+; 2 DP
Cassandra Nix Anal Intensity (Evil Angel)
Chanel White My Hot Stepsister 2 (Combat Zone) a2m
Charity Bangs Amateur Anal Attempts 25 (Xplor); Every Last Drop 17 (Bang); My First Gangbang (3rd Degree) DP, IR
Cherry Torn Gangland 79 (Devil's) DP, IR; Hot For Teacher (Burning Angel)
Chloe Reece Ryder Big Tit Cream Pie 12 (Bang) creampie; Buttsex Nymphos (Evil Angel) a2m
Clarabelle Amateur Anal Attemps 27 (Xplor)
Coffee Brown Up That Black Ass 8 (Elegant Angel)
Ferrara Gomez Angel Perverse 20 (Evil Angel) a2m; Angel Perverse 21 (Evil Angel) a2m; Russian Institute: Lesson 16: The Lolitas (Marc Dorcel) DP; Teen Rebel (Harmony) a2m
Gia DiMarco 9+
Gracie Glam Big Wet Asses 20 (Elegant Angel) a2m; Gracie Glam: Lust (Elegant Angel) a2m
Grazi Moreno Latin Booty (Elegant Angel) IR
Hayley Amateur Anal Attempts 26 (Xplor)
Holly Michaels 8+
Jade Nacole 5+
Jazlyn Dimez Anal Casting Calls (Evil Angel)
Jessi Palmer Baby Sitters Gang (West Coast) IR; Elvis XXX: a Porn Parody (Vivid); Gangland 78 (West Coast) IR; This Ain't Dracula XXX (Hustler)
Jessica Dawn Super Anal Black Cougars (West Coast)
Jessica Grabbit Big Black Wet Tits 3 (Elegant Angel); Super Anal Black Cougars (West Coast)
Jessy Amateur Anal Attempts 29 (Xplor) a2m
Joan Amateur Anal Attempts 29 (Xplor)
Juelz Ventura Anal Intensity (Evil Angel) a2m; Big Wet Asses 20 (Elegant Angel)
Julie Cash Massive Anal Booty (Elegant Angel) IR
Juliette Amateur Anal Attempts 30 (Xplor)
Kagney Linn Karter All About Kagney Linn Carter (3rd Degree) a2m, IR; Big Wet Asses 19; (Elegant Angel) a2m; Relentless (Elegant Angel) DP, DPP, DAP, a2m, IR
Kara Price Anal Casting Calls (Evil Angel); Nacho vs. Franceska Jaimes (Evil Angel)
Karina O'Reilly 5+
Kaylee Hilton 7+; 1 DP
Kelly Amateur Anal Attempts 30 (Xplor)
Kelly Klass 5+
Kendra Lee Phat Black Anal Orgy (West Coast)
Kitty Jane Angel Perverse 20 (Evil Angel)
Kodi Gamble Don't Tell My Wife I Assfucked the Babysitter 7 (Devil's) a2m; Internal Injections 4 (Devil's) a2m
Kristine Chrystalis Angel Perverse 20 (Evil Angel) DP; Nightmare Of (Private) DP; Rocco: Puppet Master 10 (Evil Angel) a2m
Layla Amateur Anal Attempts 30 (Xplor)
Leilani Leanne 9+/1 DP
Lily Carter Best New Starlets 2012 (Elegant Angel); Slut Puppies 5 (Jules Jordan) a2m, IR; Trained Teens (Jules Jordan) a2m
Lisa Williams Amateur Anal Attempts 27 (Xplor) a2m; creampie
London Keyes 8+
Lucky Starr Asian Booty 2 (Elegant Angel) IR
Lylith Lavey Big Tit Fanatic (Elegant Angel) a2m, IR; Busty Anal Beauties (Evil Angel) a2m
Madison Scott Big Tits in Uniform 3 (Brazzers); Big Wet Butts 4 (Brazzers) a2m, creampie
Madlen Amateur Anal Attempts 28 (Xplor)
Mahina Zaltana Anal Inferno (Evil Angel); Big Tit Cream Pie 11 (Brazzers)
Megan Foxx Don't Tell My Wife I Assfucked the Babysitter 6 (Devil's) a2m
Melissa Ria 5+; 2 DP
Mika Kim Anal Delights (Jules Jordan) a2m, creampie; Trained Teens 4 (Jules Jordan) DP; a2m
Mishka Anal Intensity (Evil Angel)
Myeshia Nicole Black Anal Beauties 3 (Evil Angel) IR
Nataly Von Mission Asspossible (Private); Teen Rebel (Harmony) DP; Young Harlots: Dirty Business (Harmony) DP
Nevaeh Keyz Up That Black Ass 8 (Elegant Angel) a2m
Nicki Blue 6+
Niki Sweet (Czech) Angel Perverse 20 (Evil Angel) a2m; Christoph Meets the Angels (Evil Angel); Slutty Girls Love Rocco 2 (Evil Angel) a2m
Nikki Fairchild Black Booty (Elegant Angel)
Pamela (Latin) MILF Soup 15 (Bang)
Samantha Bee Scale Bustin' Babes 38 (Rodney Moore) NO IAFD or Review
Sasha Sweet 6+
Sea J Raw Anal Acrobats 6 (Evil Angel); Buttsex Nymphos (Evil Angel) a2m
Shay Golden Anal Prom Queens (3rd Degree); Friends and Family 2 (Smash); Rectal Fuckfest (Evil Angel) a2m; Teachers Fucking Students (3rd Degree) a2m
Shay Ryan POV Punx 5 (Burning Angel)
Sienna West 6+
Soleil Amateur Anal Attempts 29 (Xplor)
Summer Daniels Gangland 80 (Devil's) DP, IR
Sunny Leone Goddess
Sydney Every Last Drop 17 (Bang)
Tacori Blu Big Tit Cream Pie 13 (Bang); Buttsex Nymphos (Evil Angel) a2m; Mommy X-Perience 4 (Evil Angel)
Tanner Mayes Squirtamania (Immoral) creampie
Tasha Monroe Innocent Until Proven Filthy 8 (Jules Jordan) a2m
Tay Dash Azz and Mo Ass 13 (West Coast) creampie; Big Ass Anal Heaven 13 (West Coast) DP; Real Black Housewives of LA (West Coast) DP
Terry Christoph Meets the Angels (Evil Angel)
Tiffany Tyler I Love Anal (SunLust/Vivid)
Vicki Chase Anal Gaping Sluts (Evil Angel) a2m; Latin Booty (Elegant Angel) IR, a2m; This Isn't the Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn part 1 (Hustler) a2m
Whitney Taylor Hot Anal Injection (Jules Jordan)
Willa Amateur Anal Attempts 28 (Xplor) creampie
Zoe Holloway White Mommas 3 (Elegant Angel) IR, a2m