Reviewers Recommend
Forbidden Love (Love Her Films)Forbidden Love (Love Her Films) - review by Captain Jack
Starring: Milan Ponjevic, Melissa Moore [II]. Read review
All Forums > The Porn Pool > The Porn Pool Forum Page 803 > Adult DVD Talk Quote in AVN Ad
AuthorPost
Bill All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member


5334 Posts
6/00
Posted - Jul 28 2002 : 3:58PM
This months AVN has an ad for "Simon Wolf's Naughty Bedtime Stories". At the top of the ad there is a quote:
"SIMON WOLF SETS A NEW STANDARD"
-Adult DVD Talk

This quote was taken from Houston Don's review of Blue Angel.

It's nice to see Adult DVD Talk getting some of the recognition it deserves.


edited for spelling

Edited by - Bill Broderick on Jul 29 2002

BIGmike
B-I-G-m-i-k-e

2335 Posts
3/01
Posted - Jul 28 2002 : 4:34PM
Very cool.

I've had parts of comments written in Elegant Angel's press releases, taken from my reviews. They always list my review name wrong, but at least they give credit to Adult DVD Talk.

BIGmike, over & out!

astroknight All-Star Supporter
Questionable Moderator

Tastes so good...
4187 Posts
11/99
Posted - Jul 28 2002 : 4:51PM
Simon has been really great towards Adult DVD Talk, from what I've seen. There's also a quote from Adult DVD Talk on Blue Angel that I guess comes from me (I think it was taken from my Beauty and the Bitch review but I'm not sure).
bono-ONE All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

SAMCRO
8571 Posts
8/00
Posted - Jul 28 2002 : 6:25PM
That is cool that the site and some of the reviewers are getting quoted by publications, WTG!!!!

HoustonDon
Member

Houston
561 Posts
11/99
Posted - Jul 28 2002 : 8:00PM
I've pointed out that many of the reviewers here have made some extremely quotable comments about movies in the past. From Smartblonde and Dark Mage, to Endorphin and Astroknight (and all those others out there), a lot of companies have missed the boat.

For the record, Astro was the first ADT'er quoted by Simon Wolf Productions on a dvd cover, Blue Angel. It was from his earlier review of another title (B&TB) and read as follows: "Simon Wolf Makes A Fantastic Adult Movie." The cover also quoted a friend of ADT's, Ema from the Erotic Movie Compendium. Big Mike and others are routinely quoted on various websites and advertising as well. I emailed SWO and asked that any quotes be attributed to this website and not me personally which is cool except I'd rather they list it as a link.

PS: The coolest part about it to me is that SWO really do put a lot of effort into a smaller number of movies-and they've proven they can handle everything from couples/features to hardcore splooge-fests. In many ways, they are what JKP originally set out to do but couldn't pull off.

 
Emahevul
Adult Film Central

119 Posts
3/00
Posted - Jul 28 2002 : 9:33PM
Just a quick note, "The Erotic Movie Compendium" no longer exists, but that's not to say that something like couldn't exist in the VERY near future.

By the way...........I'm baaacccckkkk!!

Edited by - Emahevul on Jul 28 2002

rieekan333
Member

388 Posts
3/02
Posted - Jul 28 2002 : 10:20PM
Bjones
Member

Adam & Eve Internet Commerce Group
30 Posts
7/02
Posted - Jul 29 2002 : 9:43AM
To my knowledge, Simon Wolf actually sends the material to the reviewers before it is released or the boxart is done. This allows him to add quotes to his boxes.

But one can always take a generic quote from one release and put it on the box of another as well. It adds validity and credibility to the product just as saying the the product is an award winner of some sort.

dumblonde
Senior Member

2352 Posts
7/00
Posted - Jul 29 2002 : 10:11AM
Woah, wait a minute.
If I understand this correctly, they used a quote from a different movie review and applied it to Blue Angel? What if Blue Angel had sucked?
Then they did it again with HD's review of Blue Angel, applying it to Naughty Bedtime Stories. This is bullshit, or am I missing something here?

By playing fast and loose with review quotes, they could damage someone's credibility for their own glorification, so I commend and agree with HD's suggestion about not crediting the reviewer by name.

Our two most prolific reviewers have credibility in abundance.
HoustonDon, in over 500 reviews has yet to bestow a single 5 star rating, if I'm not mistaken. Astroknight also isn't shy about tearing someone a new one, whether or not it's a screener makes no difference to them, I've noticed. Keep up the good work guys, but I would say something to them about it.

Welcome back, Emahevul. We've missed you.

Dumblonde -
"My reviews suck worse than a gnat on Ron Jeremy's johnson"

astroknight All-Star Supporter
Questionable Moderator

Tastes so good...
4187 Posts
11/99
Posted - Jul 29 2002 : 10:31AM
I don't remember what the actual quote on Blue Angel was, but all of the quotes used said something about Simon Wolf rather than the actual move. I think the one on Blue Angel said "Simon Wolf makes a fantastic adult film", or something like that. Since it's about the person making the movie rather than the movie itself, I guess I don't see much of a problem.
dumblonde
Senior Member

2352 Posts
7/00
Posted - Jul 29 2002 : 4:44PM
Astro, you are usually the first one to get upset about ANY attempt to mislead the consumer, so I'll defer to your take on it, although it still doesn't sit well.

If I were shopping by boxcover as many consumers do, I would assume that quote pertained to that particular movie. Clearly that is the intention.

Dumblonde -
"My reviews suck worse than a gnat on Ron Jeremy's johnson"

Bill All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

5334 Posts
6/00
Posted - Jul 29 2002 : 7:21PM
When I read this particular ad, it never crossed my mind that this quote pertained to a review of "Naughty Bedtime Stories". I immediately assumed that the quote was intended to represent the company as a whole (even though the intital quote WAS specifically for a previous title, not the company as a whole).

Also, from this ad, I can't tell whether the quote will be on the boxcover or not. The quote IS at the top of the artwork and could be part of the boxcover, but the phrase "Simultaneous DVD Twin Set & Video Release Sept 9, 2002" is in a similar location over the bottom of the artwork (I'm assuming that this will not be on the boxcover).

That having been said, I could see how someone could infer that a quote like this was a recommendation for that particular title if the quote were on the boxcover. However, I disagree that this was "clearly the intention" in this case.




Jump To: