I've noticed there isn't much talk about amateur porn on this site. I suppose I'm in the (very small) minority, but I prefer scenes where a curious, often nervous young woman gives it up for the camera over yet another scene where a pro goes through her moves.

Exhibit A: the hottest anal scene I've encountered in months is in Galdavision's Tony's Amateur Tapes Vol. 7. The girl, Sophia, is a cute college-girl type, skinny with small tits. She is shy and visibly nervous during the brief interview. It's hard for her to disrobe. She gives a tentative blowjob. For the first couple minutes she's being fucked, she looks awkwardly at the camera, her face emotionless... and then it happens. Her eyes glaze over a little, she starts getting into it. Her cheeks regain color. She gets into doggy-style and, having never done anal, lets the guy stick it in her ass, slowly, slowly... And then all her reserve falls away. He fucks her faster and she starts grunting. Perhaps that doesn't sound sexy, but it is -it's an animal sound coming out of a girl who was shyly blushing just a few minutes before. He fucks her harder and she starts saying "No, no" but in such a way that she obviously means "yes". When she sits on his dick she fucks herself as hard as she possibly can. And when he comes on her face she smiles, now a little embarassed again...

It's the transformation from sweet and curious girl to heedless animal that does it for me. That's the magic of amateur porn at its infrequent best.