Featured New Release
Box cover for Nana Fucks Best 5
Nana Fucks Best 5
Studio: MYLF
Release date: 7/27/2026


all new releases
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 61 > Are stand alone and computer DVD players the same?
AuthorPost
Linus TR fan
Member


318 Posts
11/03
Posted - Dec 12 2003 : 8:51PM

I have a disc I recently rented, and two other ones that I have barrowed in the past, that have some problems, mainly freezing up in the video, and some accessing menu problems. These problems only happen in my stand alone unit, but the discs play fine in my computer DVD drive.

Am I to assume it is not a disc problem but a problem with my player, or are the computer versus stand alone units different? I have had this problem in 2 mainstream DVD's that I own, but not to as big of extent. If anyone knows something about this, info would be much appreciated.

Bill All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

5334 Posts
6/00
Posted - Dec 12 2003 : 10:51PM
The problem is not necessarily with your stand-alone player. One problem with DVD is that, in order to get the format launched as quickly as possible, when the DVD standard was created, it was not a single set of rules. It contained many many options.

Becasue of all of these options, some DVD players handle certain discs better than others. There are some discs that I have had problems with my PC DVD player and other discs that have had problems in my stand alone player.

IMO, the biggest advantage that PC DVD players have is the ability to update the firmware with a download. This helps the manufacturers eliminate conflicts. The firmware in some stand-alone players is updatable by burning a file to a cd and then inserting the cd into the player. However, not many manufacturers are taking advantage of this capability.

Linus TR fan
Member

318 Posts
11/03
Posted - Dec 12 2003 : 11:34PM
Thanks very much bill. Would I have to contact the DVD player manufacturer to see if it is possible to download an update in firmware? Does this mean though that the disc is fine?
reciprocity
Member

109 Posts
5/03
Posted - Dec 13 2003 : 7:38AM
If you know the site of the manufacturer of your DVD drive, you could go there and see if it's available for download.
Bill All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

5334 Posts
6/00
Posted - Dec 13 2003 : 10:17AM
I know that there are some websites that have this info. I just don't know the URL's (I know, a lot of help that is)
Like before, not necessarily. One of the things that the DVD manufacturers are supposed to do is to try to ensure that their DVD's are compatible with all brands of DVD players (at least the major brands). Some DVD manufacturers have problems with certain brands (IIRC, Evil Angel DVD's once had problems with older RCA players, which they subsequently investigated, and fixed).
Unfortunately, companies like Evil Angel are the exception. If you're unable to update your firmware and your having problems with DVD's from a specific company (that you want to buy more DVD's from), you may want to consider whether it makes sense to upgrade your DVD player. I don't want to spend your money for you, but if your DVD player is a few years old, it might be a good idea. The quality of players has risen greatly in the last few years. While at the same time, prices have plummetted.

It's also not a bad time of year for this. You might want to ask Santa to bring you one in a few weeks .

BTW, the incompatibility problem isn't limited to adult DVD manufacturers. There have been compatibility problems from DVD's produced by MGM and Columbia in the past. Usually it's when the manufacturer tries to do something new and special on a DVD that the incompatibilities occur. However, mainstream companies have more time and resources to devote to ensuring that their multi-million dollar releases have no problems than their adult counterparts do.

 
GaySatyr
Senior Member

Half dirty ol' man; half horny ol' goat!
1684 Posts
10/00
Posted - Dec 13 2003 : 12:23PM
cdfreaks.com maintains a long list of firmware upgrades for CD and DVD drives with links their respective manufacturers' sites. ~ GS
Linus TR fan
Member

318 Posts
11/03
Posted - Dec 13 2003 : 2:34PM
Thanks very much guys. There isnt an update available for my player. I have been thinking of stepping up to a higher end player anyway, so I think I will let you spend my money Bill, and I'll buy a new player for christmas. I appreciate the help, thanks.
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 61Are stand alone and computer DVD players the same?

Previous topic: Full Anal Access 2 Picture Problem
Next topic: problems with P.P.O.V. #6 DVD?



Jump To: