For some reason, a specific scene popped into my head yesterday. It's with Lily Jordan and Cadey Mercury at Daughter Swap. The scene is titled "A Magical Misappropriation." I'm a big fan of DS and this remains one of my favourite scenes on the site. But it got me thinking about Lily Jordan. She was super cute and had a girl-next-door vibe to her. She wasn't super hardcore, and as a fan of hard hardcore, I still chased down as many of her scenes as I could find. For example, over 180+ scenes, she didn't do any anal.
Before anyone asks, "Why wouldn't you mention Cadey too?" The only reason I didn't mention her here is because it's likely that I've already mentioned her in this thread, and if I didn't, then I've still posted a lot about how much I liked her too and miss her.
Now that I think of it, my interest in this scene is that both Lily and Cadey come across as a bit innocent but still a bit adventurous.
Taylor Vixen. She was a stunning young woman who only did girl/girl. It would be nice if she came back and did boy/girl, but any return from retirement would be a delight.
Sasha Grey and Carter Cruise are 2 that have already been mentioned that would be hugely unlikely but would surely break the internet if it ever happened. They both still look incredible and would be million dollar comebacks for sure.
I used to watch porn. I still do but I used to, too. 1517 Posts 8/09
Posted - Dec 31 2025 : 11:46AM
Keri Sable is a great one.
For me, it's still Lexi Belle. I would love to see her go for one more big run, perhaps do that one, ever-elusive DP scene. She does plenty of DP with toys on her OF so who knows? I would honestly settle for a professionally-filmed DP exclusive to her OF.
I think if stunning Erica Campbell had done one boy/girl scene I would declare her one of the greatest porn starlets. It's too bad she avoided B/G scenes.
I personally love her shaved head look. but then again I have a preference for ladies with either supershort hair like riley or superlong hair like for instance Lucy Thai
"Pornography: That which excites, whether from approval or disapproval." ~ Leonard Rossite 2347 Posts 12/17
Posted - Feb 6 2026 : 7:32PM
Scarlett Sage, Jillian Janson, Laney Grey, Serena Blair, Leigh Livingston in her prime because despite her clit being pierced - she still somehow managed to pull off the completely innocent look. Similar story with Nicole Ray and Elena Koshka minus the piercing, she could eat puss and suck a mean cock but you would never know it with her looks and presentation.
Annette Schwarz and Kelly fucking Wells. They would dominate this era so easily with the many alternatives to onlyfans - like fansly/darkfans and whatnot, oh and with LegalPorno studios - they would dominate the mainstream too. They should be in their 40's too, so peak bodies and skills.
Considering I'm not nostalgic by nature and most porn comebacks are underwhelming and far from thrilling I'd generally say that I don't want any pornstars to come back.
I'd make an exception for Lily Carter though because she was something else!!
These two are unmatched, unmatched, both filled with the ability to handle so much, and their names are Carmella Diamond and Leah Jaye wish time could turn back and we could see them as they were in their early days, at the peak of their careers. But alas, that will never happen.
Edited by - satisfyingman_ on 2/15/2026 5:21:41 AM
None of them. Any more than I'd care to see a comeback attempt by Kordell Stewart as quarterback for the Steelers They had their time in the spotlight and that time is over. Of course we fondly remember many of the names mentioned here from their perfectly-preserved performances that will live un-aged forever. But if one of them were to push a shopping cart through an Albertsons TODAY, few heads would turn. However if lost, unreleased footage from their prime years were to surface, that would be great. Or if any of them have DAUGHTERS who just turned 18....
Edited by - Fuzzy Coathanger on 2/25/2026 2:39:49 AM
Edited by - Fuzzy Coathanger on 2/25/2026 11:35:55 PM
Edited by - Fuzzy Coathanger on 2/25/2026 11:37:23 PM
^ I agree with your rationale. There is a slightly different thread here somewhere where the question asked is a bit more vague. It might be the thread on pornstars we miss the most, or something like that. My point is that the other thread is open to a bit of interpretation. Is the question asking if we'd like a model to return now at her current age or do we wish she shot more scenes, or, in a fantasy world, what if she came back as she was. Something like that.
Whatever the thread, I said that I was interpreting it as having new or more scenes with the model when she was at her peak.
I mean no disrespect to stars from the past, but as someone drawn to models between 18 and 25 (with some older outliers) and petite, there are models I'd have no interest in seeing again if they came back today, including my favourites from years ago. Take models like Tammi Ann, who remains one of my all-time favourites. I still watch her scenes, but she's 54 now, and I wouldn't be interested in seeing new scenes with her. Likewise with Gauge, who is 45. Kacey (aka Kacey Cox) is 43.
I disagree. Even among active(ish) pornstars, most of my favorites are in their 30s and 40s: Angela White, Dana DeArmond, Isis Love, Lena Paul, Phoenix Marie, Ryan Keely, etc. Love their content still. I like how they've become more sexually confident with age.
I personally would really like to see the following girls come back to shooting porn-
Courtney Cummz - Incredible hot blonde bombshell who is still looking hot and gorgeous on her social media platforms.
Cameron Canada - Incredibly Beautiful Petite Blonde who was a hot nasty girl in her scenes. She definitely left the industry way too early
Jasmine Byrne - Gorgeous Beautiful Latina who was an amazing Cum Swallowing Queen and a Rimming Queen in the 2000s. Left well before her time.
Kaisey Dean - Beautiful Petite Sexy girl who looked really like Emma Stone. She was an amazing Deepthroat Queen and enthusiastic performer. She only stayed a very short time in the industry.
Teagan Presley - Sensational Beautiful Blonde Bombshell who was the IT girl in Porn. One of the most beautiful gorgeous girls ever in porn and incredible hot nasty scenes. She is still looking really hot and gorgeous at 40 years old on her social media platforms. She has recently started doing conventions and signings again so there is lots of online chatter. Fingers crossed 🤞🤞
^ I agree with your rationale. Interesting take. The problem is that porn performers are not "actresses" who convincingly play different characters as they age. I watched Reese Witherspoon when she was 20, enjoy her current stuff, and will be checking her out when she's 60. But porn performers just don't have the same "arc": You have the amateur/debut scene, first girl-girl, first anal, first interracial, first gang-bang-- all interesting, But by the time we're past all that, my interest fades and am ready for the next barely legal debutante. After all, by now, we've now seen every inch of her, and we've experienced the full range of their personality. Nothing is going to surprise us. Porn strikes me as a very young woman's game. Kids, poundage, serious relationships and so forth all work against a long career and one trip to any bar will prove this point. Who's getting the lions share of the attention-- the 21 year olds or the 35+ women? Sure, plenty of men would take the 35 year old home-- but mostly because they know they wouldn't stand a chance with the college-age hotties. It's just how we're wired!
Not for me, for the same reason I don't buy re-treaded tires. What I'm looking forward to (as I have every year since about 1981) is the Any-High USA Class of 2026. Girls, it's not even March yet! Still plenty of time to rebel against parental authority, make some really questionable choices, flub the SAT's, then realize your never going to make it on Starbucks money. Girls who, between the time the prom dress gets put away and the diploma issued already has an agent and is counting down the days to 18-- if she's not there already. That's what the industry runs on, and since AI is killing off or will kill off every entry-level job that does not involve plumbing or HVAC-- the supply of fresh talent will be on the increase for the foreseeable future. Secretarial, customer service or basic data-entry jobs are all going away-- but PORN will always welcome you with open arms, Sweetie! Now drop those panties and show Daddy some candy...
While our tastes may be different, I agree with you. There are some models in their 30s and 40s I like and follow. But I wouldn't like to see a model who was a fresh teen 30 years ago make a comeback as a woman in her middle age. But I'm willing to make exceptions there too. Inari Vachs was in my Top 3 favourites when she was first in the business. She came back in her 30s and while I didn't collect many of those later scenes, she was still beautiful.
Anal-Loving Babe Gets Her Round Ass Stretched Out - review by Captain Jack
Posted - Nov 5 2025 : 1:13AM
