A) Lots of scenes that first came to mind were not 1 on 1 but BBG or BGG threesomes or more (not great for warming girlfriends up to the idea). B) Most actresses that have 1 scene like what you are describing often have them spanning their entire careers, so pinning down their "best examples" was virtually impossible. C) Lot of these scenes have ATM... which is not exactly optimal for scenes to show your girlfriend in the hopes she will "give anal a go". and D) Porn is mostly "acting" as it is part of the whole "porn deal", therefore what would be considered as "authentic" or "organic" for you might not be for me and vice versa.
So after giving it too much thought, I eventually decided "fuck it"... I'll just give you some examples of scenes where the actress(es) smiles a lot, is encouraging towards the "stunt cock" about the anal penetration aspects pre and during, never seems to struggle or ever be in any pain throughout, and is at least semi-convincing in her performance that it is not all just an act.
I hope that will suffice.
Anissa Kate - Anally Helping the Neighbour in Need (Bang Bros Clips) (2017)
Bella Marie Wolf - Strip Tease Then Fuck 2 --- Although any scene showcases her love of anal. She's a bit crazy (in a good way).
Carter Cruise - Fuck My Ass Harder (Drilled) --- Seems to genuinely enjoy anal (and seemingly cums hard from it) in many of her scenes. Could be an act, but if so she is definitely committed to the performance.
Casey Calvert, Lisa Ann - Anal Pounding a Pro MILF and an Amateur (2013) --- Very likely an act, but they both play it well in this scene.
Courtney Devine - Azz Fest 4 --- Rarely don't see her smiling in anal scenes (or any scenes for that matter).
Eva Angelina - Big Wet Asses 12 (2007) --- She seemed to enjoy it in many scenes. Gives a decent amount of intensity and encouragement.
Gina Valentina - Teens Love Anal (2018) --- She has multiple great scenes that fit your criteria. Seems keen on her co-stars not being gentle with her.
Holly Hendrix - Student Body --- Although with Holly you could pick practically any of her scenes out of a hat. She seems to love anal.
Jaye Summers - Earning Her Allowance --- She smiles in this one and seems into it.
Jayna Oso - Good Whores Take it in the Ass 3 --- Jayna always seemed to reliably love it in all her scenes.
Jenna Haze - Big Wet Asses 12 (2007) --- Although she has many anal scenes where she seems to be genuinely into it. Jenna also does some great "off the cuff" dirty talk improvisation in lots of scenes.
Juelz Ventura - Anal Workout 2 (Scene 3) (2014) --- Lots of smiles and encouragement in this one.
Jynx Maze - Oil Overload 5 (Jynx Gets an Oil Change by Nacho) (2011) --- Intense, with lots of encouragement and oil. Seems to be loving every second. Arguably one of the best anal scenes of all time. But Jynx has many others that qualify for what you are after.
Kaylani Lei - Banging Beauties 2 (2015) --- Interesting case. Worked for years and promised never to do anal. Then did a few kind of luke warm but ok ones. Later disappeared for a while, then came back anally obsessed and armed with a repertoire of arguably one of the best "dirty talk" porn personas I can think of in recent history.
Kinzie Kenner - Big Wet Asses 7 (2005) --- One of my favorite anal scenes of all time. If she is faking enjoyment and enthusiasm, then she deserved performer of 2005 for this one.
Madison Ivy - The Greatest Gift of All --- I never really noticed her all that much until I saw her in this scene. Here her dirty talk is off the charts and she treats her co-star like he is the only thing that is important on this Earth in the moment. Great performance by her and really intense.
Miko Lee - Looking For Love --- Miko likely was just putting on a performance "role play" act in most of her scenes. But I've seen much worse acting for sure. Regardless, anal was never a struggle for her and she is pretty great in this one.
Remy LaCroix - Big Wet Asses 22 --- Seemed generally to be a straight up anal fiend, but she seems particularly happy getting her ass pounded in this scene.
Renae Cruz - Meet the Fuckers 8 --- There is some decent "dirty talk" and "take my ass" encouragement in this one too.
Riley Reid - Anal Playtime With Riley (True Anal) (2018) --- The ever smiling, ever encouraging, ever enthusiastic, foul mouthed Riley is likely an easy "go to" anal actress for the kind of scenes you are looking for.
Roxy Jezel, Jayna Oso - Weapons Of Ass Destruction 3 (2004) --- Another one of my all time favorite anal scenes ever. The enthusiasm of both actresses is off the charts and never stops. But Roxy like Jayna is pretty reliably "keen" taking penises in her butthole across her career generally.
Vanessa Blue - Phat Ass Tits 4 --- While I'm positive she was always acting, in Vanessa's case I was always completely cool with that because she could make it work anyway and her "white boy" dirty talk was reliably boner inducing. I rarely saw her ever struggle in anal scenes and she smiled in scenes often.
Veronica Leal - Sweet Awakening ---- What can I say? This actress seems to only be fully content with a cock in her ass. Constantly jumping between intensity and smiling and absolute bliss in the majority of her scenes. If it is fake... then she probably deserves an award.
Some other actresses that have an body of work worth taking look at because they did genuinely seem to enjoy anal when paired with a decent stunt cock they liked (or at least put on a convincing act of it) but I didn't find any specific scene examples that fit your criteria from my meagre porn collection are...
Aaliyah Hadid, Abbie (Krystal Boyd, Anjelica), Abella Anderson, Adriana Chechik, Aidra Fox, Angel Smalls, Anna Polina, Asa Akira, Bree Olson, Carmel Moore, Cody Lane, Dakota Skye, Dana Vespoli, Gabbie Carter, [redacted by legal demand], Gia Derza, Henessy, Janice Griffith, Jasmine Burne, Jessica Darlin, Koni Demiko, Mari Possa, Monica Mattos, Nikita Denise, Rebeca Linares, Vanessa Sky, Victoria Tiffani (Stephanie), Vixen Vogel.
Edited by - Unbeliever on 8/15/2022 12:48:02 PM
Edited by - Unbeliever on 8/15/2022 1:07:11 PM
[Link]