Creepy scenes:
Any scene where Vince Voyeur expresses his contempt for Max Hardcore. On one occasion Voyeur talks about the size of Mr. Hardcore's endowment during a BTS interview. Not very professional but very weird.
A scene Max Hardcore did with Taylor Rain. It was shot towards the beginning of her illustrious career but I saw it during the twilight of her preeminence. In the scene, Taylor expresses two things you'd never expect from her: fear and the apparent desire not to have something in her ass.
Kelly Wells's scene for Khan Tusion. He has her say something to her dad. For most of the scene, Wells has that eerie glow in her eyes that says what I don't know.
In one of my all time favorite scenes is one of my creepiest moments. The film is Service Animals #9. Bi-sexual Britni, Felix Vicious, and Brandon Iron are having at it. Britni warns Felix "what ever comes out of your mouth belongs to me" as Brandon does what he does best: pillage Felix's throat. Felix proceeds to vomit into Britni's mouth and she swallows it with glee, even sucking up the strand of bile trailing from Felix's mouth. At one point in this scene, Iron and Joey Silvera give each other a look you'd not expect from either.
Oh, yeah. The scene from Inside Seka where Ron Jeremy gives himself a blowjob.
Nici Sterling in Gangbang Girl #15. She dodges a huge glassful of cum at the end of the scene only to be called into Mr. Alexander's office later and get confronted with her poor attempt to argue that the glass slipped. Wouldn't you know it? A bunch of guys are in route right now, Nici, care to reshoot the ending? To this day, I don't know if the whole thing was staged or what but it is creepy.
[Link]