I've seen alot of videos with both Mandingo and John Holmes, and even though Holmes is still referred to as having the biggest penis in porn, i can't understand it, since it looks obvious that Mandingo is the biggest penis in porn ever. Holmes does definitely not measure up to his size. At least to me, there is no doubt who should wear that crown. Mandingo has to be atleast an inch or two bigger.
Exactly who has even mentioned John Holmes's name in the last 20 years? Shane Diesel, Jack Napier, and Mandingo are all bigger than John Holmes was, and there are more. Holmes was something special back in the day, but now?
I don't know about inches, but Holmes never seemed to have good erection in his porn scenes, so it'd be difficult to make comparison. Also the video shooting/editing style is very different. There was more use of super-closeups and slo-mo and looped film segments in the John Holmes days, which also would make comparisons more difficult.
Mandingo is bigger than John Holmes and he gets much harder than Holmes did. Jack Napier has a black version of John Holmes' cock. But I think Darryl Edwards was maybe bigger than Mandingo. And Tony "Mr 18 Inches" Duncan was probably the biggest of all-time.
[Link]
Dragon Sign Deactivated User
3381 Posts 12/13
Posted - Oct 18 2014 : 7:26AM
The biggest Holmes to me always seemed to be the heavyweigh guy Larry, still do.
[Link]
Dragon Sign Deactivated User
3381 Posts 12/13
Posted - Oct 18 2014 : 7:37AM
I must have forgot the dude Steve, if the title was settled between these, I still would have gone for Larry, though. He really stood out hard for so fucking long back in the day. The same can stil be said about the european dude often seen with a wig.
Mandingo is definitely the longest ever but there are quite a few thicker than him. I think to determine the absolute biggest they would have to find out I guess not just length or girth but like the full "square footage" of the dick.
HOLY HELL. How did this guy not pass out during erections? So much blood would have had to flow to his dick.
[Link]
Dragon Sign Deactivated User
3381 Posts 12/13
Posted - Oct 21 2014 : 8:24AM
There's a company called Google out there. Pretty helpful sometimes. A heavyweight champion for over half a decade in the same era as John should not get under the radar. Add Steve Holmes and everything should add up.
He looks like he's passing out right there. But let's be honest, he was not a good porn stud. Can't think of any scene of his back in the day that I thought was good, even paired with a starlet that I liked.
[Link]
Bill66 Deactivated User
56 Posts 10/14
Posted - Oct 23 2014 : 12:19PM
If you watch the scene with Mandingo and Charley Chase on Bang Bros "monster of cock" series, he was measured with a Barbie Doll that is 11.5 inches long (you can find the dimensions online, or even buy the doll). He was about 2" shorter than the doll. Mandingo's real size is somewhere around 9.5". He is not over 10". This makes sense also considering Mandingo did some early scenes with Lexington Steele and Lex has been measured in the movie Lewd Conduct 3 with a tape at slightly over 9 inches. The side measurement is not the proper way of measuring as it always adds length... and his measurement was also taken from his leg, so his real size is around 8.5" or the high 8" range. You can see that Mandingo is an inch or so longer than Lex but there is not much in it. There is other evidence as well. Wesley Pipes has been measured with a remote controller that is 9 inches long by Jessie Volt in the "monsters of cock" series. He was shorter than the controller, he is 8.5" and he did many early scenes with Mandingo. Pipes was within an inch of Mandingo. And Ice Cold is 9" and he is within 0.5" of Mandingo... I know people always think Mandingo is the "king" but there are guys out there are easily within an inch of him. And it's not just black guys either. If you look online there's European white guys like bigdicknickb or Swedish guy called "Pirapus" who are easily Mandingo size and some guy called don8 an Indian who looks the same size as Mandingo but has more girth. But yes Mandingo is bigger than John Holmes. All pornstars exaggerate their real size. Anything over 10" or so wouldn't exist in reality as biologically impossible. The only 14" cocks that exist are those fake prosthetic cocks that squirt fake cum and fill the entire screen lol. I have seen a very rare solo scene of Holmes and he is no longer than 8". Dick Rambone was advertised at 16 inches but he was around 8" as well. And that photograph posted of Tony Duncan is his max erect length hanging down... nowhere near 18" lol that would be biologically impossible. He was the true 10" of porn, bigger than Mandingo. But like others said could not keep an erection. Edited by - bill66 on 10/23/2014 12:22:31 PM
[Link]
Bill66 Deactivated User
56 Posts 10/14
Posted - Oct 23 2014 : 12:38PM
No, he is not the longest ever. Mandingo is short always gives the illusion of looking bigger than it is. Height and bold build come into this also. Look at Ice Cold, Dredd, Mr. Biggz easily all 0.5" or an inch within Mandingo and they are a lot taller than him. Fully erect maybe the same size as him. But look at Criss Strokes, he has been measured at 7 inches but looks huge due to his body (no fatpad) and height etc and he is paired with tiny women. Just shows how it can be done. But the above Tony Duncan was longer than Mandingo and the longest dong in the world belongs to Jonah Falcon, he is easily longer than Mandingo... And if you want guys bigger or same size than Mandingo look online for: Quercusone (measured at 9.5", has done amateur vids) "Monica Erotica" guy (only done one scene, LPSG member) Slim Poke Miro Manning Pirapus (has done solo work, LPSG member) Max Delong (done some solo work) Antonin Devos/Michael Berg Mr Big No Myth Mr_Snufalufagus (LPSG member, has a legit 10 inch measurement) SDP (LPSG member, legit 9" measurement) Don_8 (LPSG member, thicker than Mandingo) That's just a few, there are others. White Pony is also up there, not as long as Mandingo but easily the same size as Jack Napier. It seems many of these guys are hardly known. Edited by - bill66 on 10/23/2014 12:41:19 PM Edited by - bill66 on 10/23/2014 12:44:38 PM
Dawkins didn't have any of his pubes shaven and it still looks bigger than life. I think his peak claim of 13 and a half inches is correct.
[Link]
DAPistheBEST Deactivated User
36 Posts 8/14
Posted - Oct 23 2014 : 6:44PM
He wasn't 18 inches... yes, freakishly big . A lot of the sites promoting gigantic cocks that look over 12 inches use the prosthetic ones; I always laugh when people think they are real.
^I know he wasn't at 18, but I do believe his actual claim of 14 inches.
[Link]
Bill66 Deactivated User
56 Posts 10/14
Posted - Oct 23 2014 : 9:17PM
You are entitled to believe this of course, but it is not true. Firstly Mandingo has been measured by the doll which was 11.5" and we have a rough estimate of his size, he is in the mid or high 9" range and Duncan is only a bit bigger than Mandingo, so he is not 14". Take for example the photograph of Tony Duncan in this thread. He is at his max there erect with his dick hanging straight down, this is a porn trick that has been about for a long time, John Holmes even practiced it, today Danny D and Jack Napier do. That is not his flaccid length. I have only seen one video where Duncan was flaccid and he is nowhere near that size. Nobody on earth has a 14 inch dong. Look on the internet there are only a handful guys in the world who can prove with a legit measurement they are 9.5" - 10" and they are bigger than nearly all the pornstars. There is no real proper measurement photograph in existence of a man being measured over 10 inches. It's not hard to work out why. But if you take out a tape measure and measure the penis (a bone pressed measurement) to the knee cap. This is 14 inches (I'm 6ft tall and dam skinny). How tall was Duncan? Well he wasn't taller than 6ft 2" or so. To his knees would be 15 inches. Looking at the photograph his penis is nowhere near the start of his knees... he around 10" at the most. There's various websites like freaks of cock that have prosthetic dicks that squirt fake cum, they measure them in some of their vids. You can easily find pics and vids of these online. They come to 13 and 14 inches. The big boys of porn like John Holmes, Dick Rambone, Mandingo, Danny D, Ice Cold, White Pony, Rico Strong, Clover, Jack Napier, Lexington Steele, Tony Duncan etc are nowhere near the size of those monster prosthetic dongs. Edited by - bill66 on 10/23/2014 9:18:28 PM Edited by - bill66 on 10/23/2014 9:24:08 PM
^ Mandingo is not over 6 feet tall. He is only about 5'7". I remember he was on some Playboy channel show with Jesse Jane and another porn chick. He wasn't much taller than Jesse Jane even though she had heels on she is really short. I think the fact he is so long and thick and his body frame is small and thin make his cock look much bigger than people think he is.
Dawkins is significantly bigger and thicker than Mandingo. You talk about optical illusions while ignoring Dawkins' unshaven junk which would make it look smaller. He is quite clearly the biggest ever and well over 10 inches, your personal pseudo research that you think is set in stone aside. Don't worry there isn't a scary Dickmonster in the closet at night, guys like this exist. So do tons of other humans with proportional deformities. A guy like Dawkins clearly has a harmless deformity(I think it's harmless anyway) it's why he was not a good performer, his piece was not practical at all due to being oversized.
[Link]
Dragon Sign Deactivated User
3381 Posts 12/13
Posted - Oct 24 2014 : 5:18AM
Must pull my act together sometime and buy that Massacre volume featuring Lia Lor soon, have had it in wishlist for sooo long now and wow that chick also stands out but not that she does so in too many DVDs of mine. I have her going in one memoarable Whale Tail volume and that's about it oddly enogh memoarably speaking I guess. And the only Massacre volume I've got by JJ is the one with Skin Diamond in it. More than one scene at the time is a little too much and over the top so that may have been the reason.
OK, maybe, but I think I really would have noticed if he were so short... 9 inches shorter than me? No way.
[Link]
Bill66 Deactivated User
56 Posts 10/14
Posted - Oct 25 2014 : 9:13AM
I fully agree with you. I have spoken to a number of guys on different forums who are all friendly with Mandingo. They say they have been around him many times and say he is 5ft 7 or 5ft 8 max. If you watch the scene with Mandingo and Gianna Michaels, she is easily taller than him and she is 5ft10 or 5ft 11 and Skin Diamond was nearly the same height as Mandingo and she is 5ft 5 and had high heels on.... Julia Ann looked the same size as Mandingo, so he is not 6ft. But if you get a tall pornstar who is over 6ft like Sean Michaels for example or 6ft 4 or so like Dredd, and put them in the same scene as Mandingo he would be a similar dick size to them. And Lex who is about 6ft 1 or 2 did about four or five early scenes with dingo and he was almost the same dick size as him... and we know his size because he has been measured. So height does come into this. And it is silly Lex still claims to be 11 inches long on his personal twitter, he isn't even 9" based on his measurement fully erect in Lewd Conduct 3. All pornstars lie about their size but it's to the point when it is getting ridiculous., even lying about their height, lol! Edited by - bill66 on 10/25/2014 9:16:11 AM
I just joined so I could bring up a point. First off Mandingo is only probably 9 to 9.5 inches and John Holmes is around the same. Mandingo is 5'7 and John Holmes was 6'2 so Mandingo's dick may look bigger but it isn't. One guy said Shane Diesel is bigger than John Holmes, this actually cracked me up. Shane Diesel's Dildo is 7.5 inches. Which mean he is 7.5 inches. They aren't going to make you dildo bigger than your actual dick. Shane Diesel is a pumper and his dick doesn't reach his navel which means again it is less than 8 inches. Jack Napier was measured at 9 inches from the side which means he is less than 9 measured correctly. Tony Duncan is probably around 9 to 9.5 inches too. People get confused by his dick hanging down and think that he is flaccid. But that is how his dick is. He is also a pumper which is the reason he can't get really hard. Darryl Edwards isn't as big as Mandingo or John Holmes. Quercusone isn't 9.5 inches. That is his cheating measured wrong size. Measured properly he is under 9 inches Pirapus isn't 9 inches. Max Delong is a pumper who can't get a erection Then there is the person who said Sean Micheal is just as long as Mandingo. Not even close. Sean may be 7 or slightly over. You know the pornstar Pinky? She has stated this various times. She has done tons of scenes with numerous guys and says Mandingo is the biggest guy she has worked with in porn and nobody in her personal life were as big. The only people she seen with penises as big was when she was a escort.
[Link]
Canadian_Cindy Deactivated User
1102 Posts 2/15
Posted - Feb 10 2016 : 10:49PM
I think one of the problems with John Holmes is he could rarely get 100% hard and stay 100% hard. No ED meds back then and his lifestyle choices were the type that were not contributing to hard and long lasting erections. There really is no way of knowing how big he actually was. He was big for sure; but hard to know how he compares to Mandingo. And as people have mentioned, the body size of the guy can make him look a lot bigger than he really is. Guys with 6 inchers look a lot bigger in a porn set. And really, 14 inch dicks don't exist in porn.... if a guy is packing 9, he will bill himself as 12 or more inches... that is just the way it is in porn. Anything that is bigger than 12 inches is a fake one. Edited by - Canadian_Cindy on 2/10/2016 10:51:26 PM
John Holmes @ AEBN
Posted - Oct 15 2014 : 8:10PM