This thread is not really a poll, just an in depth comparison, feel free to add thoughts. Jenna and Taylor both exploded on to the scene in the early 2000s. They both were part of the era where porn was marketing teens and more athletic bodies. Both girls were extremely attractive brunettes with slim physiques and incredible sexual appetites. LOOKS- Both girls are extremely pretty. Taylor Rain has been compared to Julia Roberts, she's probably better looking than Jenna to most but Jenna has such a sexual slutty look that I find her more attractive and there has been occasions where Jenna has looked more beautiful than Taylor ever has. So I'd go with JENNA HAZE. BLOWJOB- Jenna gives the best blowjobs in porn history, everyone knows how talented she is but Taylor was a great one. She had a different style, Taylor was more like Belladonna, more of a deep throat girl. Taylor gave great head, depending on your taste you might choose Taylor over Jenna but for me I'd still say- JENNA HAZE BODY- Both girls are skinny but have hot athletic bodies, Taylor I'd say had the edge back in 2003 but Jenna's 2006 physique was incredible as she returned with such a cute solid ass. It's a tough one but Jenna's body does it for me. JENNA HAZE PERFORMANCE- Jenna is a great performer but for as good as she was Taylor was able to handle more dick than Jenna. Taylor also seemed to enjoy DP much more than Jenna. Jenna put on a better show but Taylor was able to withstand the best anal poundings in porn. Jenna to me always enjoyed oral more than actual sex. Taylor Rain's DP from Full Anal Access 2 is the best DP scene I've ever seen. Tough one but I'd say Taylor Rain- PERSONALITY- Jenna Haze wins this by far, not a knock on Taylor it's just that Jenna's charisma is what made her so successful. BEST SCENE- Taylor Rain- Full Anal Access 2 with Steve Holmes and Mike Steffano from Platinum X BEST SCENE- Jenna Haze- Jenna Haze Darkside with Scott Nails
why do you want to compare pornstars? you should enjoy both as well.
[Link]
Blue Agave Deactivated User
108 Posts 3/14
Posted - Jun 14 2014 : 11:35PM
Jenna by a wide margin. Taylor plucked her eyebrows to the point she barely had any and routinely caked on the makeup to hide bad skin. HD would not have been kind to her.
I wouldn't know which scene to choose from Jenna, but I concur on this scene for Taylor Rain. Too bad I tried getting the DVD for that, but got a bootlegged version instead (missing a few minutes here and there for a total of 10 minutes, with an abysmal picture quality...) If I only could get my hands on an original one...
There are two Jenna Haze before and after her Darkside she's always been gorgeous but aside her sparkling beginning for a while she basically did lez and soft porn only when she was with Jill Kelly. Taylor had a much shorter career ,In the years when they were performing both Taylor was better, much less tamed and wilder than Jenna , but adding her second period overall Jenna is just one of the greatest. There's another thread with this very question in the Poll section of this board wher this topic belongs too, in there Taylor Rain herself praised Jenna and voted for her.
Granted Jenna was under contract for about 5 years to Jill Kelly's studio and their brand of porn was tamer than what many studios were putting out at the time but it was by no means soft porn. We are still talking about a very young woman shooting 17 anal scenes and 2 dp's prior to her JK contract and she still did a few more while under contract. The major difference with contract star Jenna is that unlike most contract players. She went back to hardcore porn when it was over and gave us many more years of amazing porn. Taylor on the other hand was extreme porn from the get go and although I appreciated her ability to take dicks. I really wish she would have chosen to do some less intense stuff. Her light shined brighter than most but her career was also much shorter because of it. The two things both women have in common is that they stayed all natural during their career and they gave it their all in each and everyone of their scenes.. P.S: In the end I think most people will agree that these were amazing performers who deserve the title of pornstar.
Jenna clearly wins Tailor wouldn't let a black guy tough her and that severely limits her in depth.. In fairness though, Tailor did drink Max Hardcore's urine (as well as Catalina's) and I can't see Jenna doing anything like that.
^No it doesn't. Taylor has 305 titles listed on IAFD and she must have done more than one scene in some of them so even if some of these are compilations than we can be fairly certain that she shot at least 300 scenes in 5 years. If I break it down evenly across her 5 year career then that means she shot approximately 60 movies per year and/or 5 per month. That's a lot of porn in a very short amount of time. Do you really believe that doing interracial would really have made any difference. I can't remember if she said she wasn't into black performers but she definitely wasn't into girls. She has only 2 lesbian titles to her name and none is a one-on-one. I can appreciate that someone who wanted to see her do interracial would be disappointed but that can't affect the impact she had on the industry. we are after all still talking about her and she has been gone for about 9 years.
Yeah that's one thing about Taylor is that she was not into girls at all, Jenna had to convince her to be in a 3 way Lez scene. Jenna on the other hand loves girls and I actually think she enjoyed girl/girl more than boy/girl depending on who she was working with. Jenna is amazing at eating pussy as well so she should earn points for that. It's a pretty interesting discussion because my vote in 2004 would have easily gone to Taylor Rain but since Jenna Haze came back in 2006 she became an all time favorite.
^ She said more than once her father would have killed her if he ever had seen her fucking a black guy , adding , if you know my father you would know he actually would. Privately she had no problems , actually she was caught while fucking a black rapper hidden at a party until then nobody even thought she might fuck black guys not even off set
To me, Taylor by a lanslide and I love Jenna. Jenna is so hot and one of the best of all time. As hot as she is though, most of the time, to me, she was faking....she was a great performer. Taylor wins for me, for her natural slutiness and the fact that she is so beautiful. Bet both their folks were pissed that they got into porn. Taylor can be both cute and all out slutty. I remember the first scene i saw of Taylor's, I was hooked....Rain Coater's point of view was so hot.....Taylor looked so cute and innocment in it....almost like a young Mary Tyler Moore in it. Others mentioned the Full Anal Access scene....wow what a scene where she was all out sexy and slutty. Yes, to me Taylor wins,
The people have spoken. I'm a nitpicking dick. Woo! 8754 Posts 1/04
Posted - Jun 15 2014 : 2:15PM
Jenna has five letters. Taylor has six letters. Haze has four letters. Rain has four letters. How this was left out of the "In Depth Breakdown" I'll never understand!
Jenna had a tremendous career, an all-time great. She worked hard at giving the porn star performance, sometimes it showed, but why not with so many scenes. Taylor was in a whole different category, she just was, she showed up, got fucked, had a unique vibe, all her own, few were as mesmerizing getting penetrated by dick, she cast a spell. Keri Sable was another. Edited by - deep archer on 6/15/2014 3:31:51 PM Edited by - deep archer on 6/15/2014 3:33:44 PM
To me, it's like comparing the careers of Roger Federer (Jenna) and Rafa Nadal (Taylor) who are both all-time greats. Jenna could do anything (B/G, threesomes, light bondage, IR, scenes with either a light comedic touch or drama) easily much in the way Federer can play on any surface easily. She worked hard and was a very consistent performer. She even did dirty scenes (FH1 and 2, Dark Side) well much in the way Federer broke through once to win the French Open. I absolutely love Taylor Rain and her performances. When she is on top of her game, she is just plain better than Jenna much in the every way (except in movies which required actual acting or a plot). Her specialty was just really nasty scenes (much in the way Nadal's specialty is clay) and Jenna could not even come close to her performances. Also, if you had to hire these two performers at the absolute peak of their game, I think Taylor would beat Jenna much in the same way Rafa beat Roger at Wimbledon 2008. You only have to look at her FH5 or Service Animals scene to see what a natural and automatic performer she was.
[Link]
Blue Agave Deactivated User
108 Posts 3/14
Posted - Jun 15 2014 : 5:12PM
Why did he care so much who she was fucking? That seems more like the kind of thing that a husband/boyfriend would freak out about?