Reviewers Recommend
All For UsAll For Us - review by Captain Jack
Director: KGB
Starring: Richard Mann, Gianna Dior, Kylie Rocket, Dwayne Foxxx. Read review
All Forums > Sex Talk > Sex Talk Forum Page 2 > My sister wants me to lend her porn dvd's
Page 1 of 2 Last
AuthorPost
charmanestar
Member

14 Posts
2/10
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 5:01AM
But she's 12.
My parents don't have internet at home hence why she's not just going online to get it.
I told her i'd think about it. But really I have no idea what to do.
ma meeshka
Iconoclastic Member

3939 Posts
4/06
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 5:22AM
What DVDs?
charmanestar
Member

14 Posts
2/10
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 5:24AM
straight porn, nothing too specific
Bobcat
Senior Member

1490 Posts
2/08
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 7:55AM
What happens if your parents find them? Are they anti porn? Lets say your sister tells them that you gave them to her, what would they do? In theory, you get busted, big style...supplying a minor with harcore porn...does that carry a prison sentence where you live? I'd stay out of it, if she was 15 maybe, but not 12. The only stuff I'd give her would be softcore porn, romantic lovemaking, no penetration/cum shots shown, like what they make for cable tv.
charmanestar
Member

14 Posts
2/10
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 8:39AM
she would not tell even if caught
being arrested and all that is not a possibility.
 
Lethena
Member

45 Posts
5/09
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 9:28AM
Id say, why not? I got interested in sex around that time, also the time I started to explore my own body. To see it this way; it is better you have control in what she watches then she find all kind of strange things out on the net. Id do it if I had a little sis and she asked me to.
I do not think it can hurt anybody, even I knew the difference of pornsex and sex at that time.
charmanestar
Member

14 Posts
2/10
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 1:10PM
So what should I give her?
Joey Starr
Senior Member

Still wanking after all these years.
8082 Posts
10/00
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 1:16PM
Just don't.
charmanestar
Member

14 Posts
2/10
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 1:38PM
I understand the reasons not to but at the same time I feel showing her respect and treating her like an adult (something I always wanted growing up) means lettering her decide for herself whether it's something for her or not.
Joey Starr
Senior Member

Still wanking after all these years.
8082 Posts
10/00
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 1:56PM
Are you also underage?
charmanestar
Member

14 Posts
2/10
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 1:56PM
no
NewRomancer
Deactivated User

under THEIR avatar
738 Posts
7/08
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 3:58PM
Don't they call that "Contributing to the delinquency of a minor"?
People in your life WILL find out that your 12 year old sister got porn from you... How will you feel about that when it happens?
Letting her decide for herself, doesn't mean you have to PROVIDE it for her....
As for treating her like an adult, she's 12... She's NOT an adult....
My 0.02 is that you tell her no.
(not that my 0.02 is even worth that much)
Gore Gore Girl All-Star Supporter
Doctor of the Erotic Arts

7238 Posts
1/09
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 4:22PM
I wonder if there would be a different reaction if this were your little brother...
I agree that your family will probably find out it was you - would you find this embarrassing? If so, why? The answer to that question will probably resolve this issue.
If you do end up doing this, think really, really carefully about *which* films you lend her.
Edit: I just realised you might be a dude - does this change the situation somewhat? I dunno...
Edited by - Gore Gore Girl on 3/3/2010 4:23:54 PM
bi_girl
Member

157 Posts
11/09
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 4:59PM
Depending on how close you are with your sister and how mature she is, I'd say go for it. I give the little bugger credit for mustering up the courage even to ask. There's nothing taboo about educating your younger siblings, even on the topic of pornography. I'd sit her down and let her know about porn in general; that there's a lot of weird stuff out there, but also a lot of good stuff if you look in the right places, that it's a far cry from real sex, etc. If she's straight I would suggest giving her quality pornography - nothing too hardcore. Though when I try to think of a straight porn that would be "acceptable" for a 12-year-old to watch, I can't really think of one :(. So another thing is rather than giving her DVDs, perhaps you could give her a magazine or a book of erotica? Erotica is a great way to introduce someone to the world of pornography; it's how I started around 11. If she likes to read, erotica is every horny 12 year old girl's dream, and if she doesn't, she might start liking it! Who knows, her spelling, grammar, and punctuation might improve too :).
EDIT
Oops I didn't see she was straight before.
Edited by - bi_girl on 3/3/2010 10:04:31 PM
Clay
Member

216 Posts
8/00
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 7:52PM
The correct answer is no.
 
WardqueenJanine
Member

914 Posts
2/08
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 9:34PM
Of which if you arrested and convicted will require you to register as a sex offender. Try explaining that to a date. Not worth it.
NewRomancer
Deactivated User

under THEIR avatar
738 Posts
7/08
Posted - Mar 3 2010 : 11:36PM
^Ouch! Great point!!
Bobcat
Senior Member

1490 Posts
2/08
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 4:16AM
^,^^ For me, this is the crux of the matter. Say she takes the DVDs to school and the principle catchs her and her friends with them, they will call in the authorities, and it won't take long for them to break a 12 year old into telling them that you gave them to her. It's a smoking gun for you, you'd be a very foolish man to do it.
ma meeshka
Iconoclastic Member

3939 Posts
4/06
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 6:55AM
I like that the people in this thread have already put you in prison for these hypothetical crimes you've committed when they have little to no information to go off.
I don't see how there can be a clear-cut answer when we knew very little about you (the OP) and even less about your sister.
What type of person is she? How mature? What is her mental state like? What do you feel would be appropriate for her to watch? Do you think she could contextualise what she's viewing? Do you think it might shape her views on sexuality adversely at her age? How close are you with her and can you talk about these kinds of things? How was the subject of her borrowing your DVDs brought up? Could she have malicious intentions? What kind of person are you? Are you responsible? Are you just trolling and is this thread a complete joke?
This goes on and on and on.
I like the point raised about if it were a little brother, it highlights how most of the responses in this thread feed of the word 'sister' rather than '12'.
Savoy All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Sucker for Sinners
1844 Posts
12/06
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 10:53AM
Hell no.
She should have to sneak and steal like the rest of us had to at 12.
Moony
Member

143 Posts
8/08
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 11:04AM
Or go hunting for "hedge porn".
Joey Starr
Senior Member

Still wanking after all these years.
8082 Posts
10/00
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 12:48PM
Movies with Ron Jeremy?
seedfeeder
Member

My balls are full, who's hungry?
716 Posts
4/09
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 4:58PM
So I'm the only one that thinks this is yet another BS story?
NewRomancer
Deactivated User

under THEIR avatar
738 Posts
7/08
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 5:25PM
^ yer not alone in that impression at all! LOL
Bobcat
Senior Member

1490 Posts
2/08
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 5:36PM
He introduced himself, on another thread as being 28 and from Toronto, so he has a sister 16 years his younger....ummmmm. I think this is some sort of fucked up fantasy, about giving underage girls porn to watch!
Edited by - bobcat on 3/4/2010 5:38:55 PM
 
Gore Gore Girl All-Star Supporter
Doctor of the Erotic Arts

7238 Posts
1/09
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 5:42PM
I think it's BS...
redhead
Member

Not so redhead these days...
718 Posts
1/08
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 6:18PM
My underage (15) brother asked me for porn. Instead of giving him Cum Spoiled Sluts, I just gave him an old Penthouse calendar. 'Coolest sister ever' I recall.
WardqueenJanine
Member

914 Posts
2/08
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 6:21PM
No, this is really starting to not pass the smell test.
bi_girl
Member

157 Posts
11/09
Posted - Mar 4 2010 : 9:04PM
I'll wait for a reply but I think ma meeshka raises a good point in asking if this guy's responsible. Considering he posted this in another thread I'm a bit disheartened: "I do also agree with the above post that it will hopefully get girls fucking as they should as teenagers and then ready for porn at eighteen."
Gore Gore Girl All-Star Supporter
Doctor of the Erotic Arts

7238 Posts
1/09
Posted - Mar 5 2010 : 7:45AM
^ I saw a couple of people say similar things and it grossed me out.
Bobcat
Senior Member

1490 Posts
2/08
Posted - Mar 5 2010 : 10:15AM
Taking this thread at face value though.... has anyone every given someone who's "innocent" porn?
When I was 16 I gave my brother who was 13, my stash of porn mags. He hadn't seen any before or had a gf! They were very soft, nude girls and stories, but I could tell they blew is mind. I wish I'd let him be, I felt bad about it, like I should have left him to find out about girls and sex for himself.
Clam Digger
Deactivated User

Many a man fails as an original thinker simply because his memory is too good.
2268 Posts
1/05
Posted - Mar 5 2010 : 10:50AM
I think you need to show some respect for your parents. She's 12. If they were ever to find out, that you supplied your sister with porn, what would be the consequences? Trust, especially amongst family, once lost, is very difficult to rebuild.
Edited by - Clam Digger on 3/5/2010 10:54:55 AM
seedfeeder
Member

My balls are full, who's hungry?
716 Posts
4/09
Posted - Mar 5 2010 : 11:27AM
When I was in 7th grade, I had a porn mag business: I would go to the flea market and buy big boxes of playboys, penthouses, etc. for like $0.25 each, then sell them at cover value ($6.00) to the other boys. My locker, was about 2' deep in porn mags on any given day... I made quite a bit of money.
On the other side of things... my older sister (5 years my senior) gave me my first mags, and I saw some of my dad's (in his bathroom) and I turned out okay... right?
ronin3
Member

82 Posts
10/07
Posted - Mar 6 2010 : 1:43AM
Blackmail is getting extremely popular on the underage circuit these days.
Everything from webcam shows to phone pics are being used against these girls as young as 9. A few even committing suicide. You'll be a great brother to help her into this type of misery.
She'll be blowing every guy that threatens to tell in no time.
Porn is not real sex. It's intent is fantasy. If you really want to help then tell her the truth as best as you can describe it. Peer to peer is usually best Or as others have recommended let her parents get the first crack at it. Did you happen to see the 16 year old who almost ended up as a sex offender for bringing a Playboy to school ??????? You can google these stories if you don't believe them . Harmless as you think it might be the results will still be on your hands. Porn is entertainment. Sex and sexual relationships are person to person and not person to paper images or plastic dvds.
ma meeshka
Iconoclastic Member

3939 Posts
4/06
Posted - Mar 6 2010 : 5:15AM
I wrote a long post, but the summary was it's a troll thread.
 
jayo All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

2117 Posts
7/04
Posted - Mar 6 2010 : 12:58PM
NO
But really I have no idea what to do.
Don't do it.
jayo All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

2117 Posts
7/04
Posted - Mar 6 2010 : 12:59PM
Agreed.
Roggie71
Member

Porn - There are worse vices!
49 Posts
10/07
Posted - Mar 6 2010 : 1:29PM
I don't understand all the reasonning people have about being caught and consequences...
Right is right and wrong is wrong. I'm sure you know the difference otherwise, you would have given her the porn and not bother asking us!!
12 year olds don't have the maturity or developped brain to properly digest porn for what it is.
18 is 18 for a reason. I know some 18 year olds have the maturity of a 16, and some 16's are mature like 20. But 12?

Roggie the Addict - Long Live Porno

charmanestar
Member

14 Posts
2/10
Posted - Mar 10 2010 : 6:48AM
wow talk about being bashed.
seedfeeder
Member

My balls are full, who's hungry?
716 Posts
4/09
Posted - Mar 10 2010 : 7:08PM
Most of your rant seems irrelevant since it's a troll thread-further proven by the OP going silent.
BUT, I would point out that your "18 is 18" argument isn't rock solid. 16 is okay in some states. And in other cultures (Borneo is one example I believe), 12 is "a-okay". Further, in our own culture historically (or at least those of us of European decent, or from India, China, and many other places) 12 was the common age to marry and begin sexual relations. So the issue at bar is "It is culturally 'wrong'." and certainly an issue of a legal nature also.
My point is "right" and "wrong" are subjective. You don't define them, neither does our culture. They are subjective, so what is "right" today is "wrong" tomorrow, and what is right for you might be wrong for your neighbor, both on your street and/or across the ocean, etc.
I think most of the world believes sex with a 12 year old is wrong, and porn OF a 12 year old is wrong. But a 12 year old viewing porn is another issue that would probably be more spread out as far as people's views on it. Personally (in case you care) I'm against it, but I won't let my 4 year old watch sponge bob square pants... I also think "Bratz" dolls are evil...
But that is all MY perspective, and I don't believe in dictating, or legislating my morality onto others, nor should you.
Gore Gore Girl All-Star Supporter
Doctor of the Erotic Arts

7238 Posts
1/09
Posted - Mar 10 2010 : 7:57PM
Why won't you let the 4-yr-old watch Spongebob??
Asmodeus
Lord of Lust

az-mo-day-us
6338 Posts
10/01
Posted - Mar 11 2010 : 5:26AM
Whether the OP's question was real or not the fact remains that providing pornography to minors is against the law (at least here in the US and many of it's allies) and the consequences of such actions can be severe.
seedfeeder
Member

My balls are full, who's hungry?
716 Posts
4/09
Posted - Mar 11 2010 : 10:24AM
Okay, I'm busted, when I said "I" that was the plural marriage "I". It's my wife's rule and it's one of those deals where I asked her the same question and then got distracted by a squirrel outside as she began to answer the question. Short answer is: I don't know. But knowing her, there is a very good reason. She probably doesn't like the way they talk or something.
Gore Gore Girl All-Star Supporter
Doctor of the Erotic Arts

7238 Posts
1/09
Posted - Mar 11 2010 : 11:38AM
^ I was just wondering if you were one of those "Spongebob is gay" Christian homophobes...
Bobcat
Senior Member

1490 Posts
2/08
Posted - Mar 11 2010 : 11:58AM
LOL, and here's me thinking you're a "playa", looks like the games over for you. What competition are you playing exactly......unfucking believable
seedfeeder
Member

My balls are full, who's hungry?
716 Posts
4/09
Posted - Mar 11 2010 : 1:13PM
That's a good one. I'm pretty far away from the Christian Right on the spectrum. While very spiritual, my faith is completely atheist. I believe all life, not just people are equal, so I have no beef with gays. Instead, I like to point out to those christian folks that from a biblical perspective, "sodomy" really just means "any wrong hole" so that means blow jobs are just as evil and sinful as anal sex folks, regardless of the genitalia of the performer. I don't like self serving double standards or hypocrisy and I don't like people who try to legislate their religion on others, especially when that religion is centuries out of date and involves one or more sky monsters.... Clear enough?
seedfeeder
Member

My balls are full, who's hungry?
716 Posts
4/09
Posted - Mar 11 2010 : 1:19PM
Again, your lack of deductive reasoning is no failing of mine. Perhaps you read everything with some very skewed glasses my friend. Also, you have no future as a detective. Instead of assuming I'm playing head games, or whatever your less than succinct statement suggests, why don't you consider the possibility that you don't read people too well and perhaps are a poor listener.
Or is it always the other guy that made a mistake bobcat? I'm about as straight up as it gets, I play no games in how I present myself. And I did have a life before marriage regardless of your need to wrap all 3 time periods into today.
I definitely USED to be a "player" and I'm pretty sure anyone with good reading skills could see it was a past tense aspect of the discussion. And I thought you went through my "rambling posts", I've mentioned my wife, etc. many, MANY times- so explain where the inconsistency is or this so-called "game" is? You should back that up if you're going to make the allegation-unless you have no sense of honor. So I look forward to your evidence of this unfounded claim.
If you look for something not to like in a person bobcat, you'll definitely find it. I don't really care what your beef with me is, all that matters is that it is YOUR beef.
Bobcat
Senior Member

1490 Posts
2/08
Posted - Mar 11 2010 : 1:44PM
So you no longer view sex as a competition, at your time of life?
You never quantified your stance on this, before! I'd agree that for an 18 year old it is, but when you get to mid-twenties it should no longer be.
Buddy, some advice, go see a quack and get prescribed some chill-pills, you fuckin' well need them, either that or some 20 year old pussy, the latter always works wounders for me, I'm feeling very chilled today !
Bobcat
Senior Member

1490 Posts
2/08
Posted - Mar 11 2010 : 3:03PM
Cat Got your tongue, hey?
So far in the posts of your's that I HAVE read, I've found out the following; you like to cum in a girls food and watch her eat it-without her knowing, you view sex as a competition, the idea being to fuck as many women as possible, make women cum as many times as possible, have a threesome and prove your a better "lover" then the other guy and do this by making the girl make noise he can't!
Then today in this thread I find out you claim to be a mature married man with a wife and child.........., WOW........something is wrong....somewhere....and you claim to be "playing it straight" ....un-fucking-believable.....you are my all-time favourite poster to laugh at...thanks!
seedfeeder
Member

My balls are full, who's hungry?
716 Posts
4/09
Posted - Mar 11 2010 : 3:20PM
I'm not the one freaking out, stalking someone's posts and hollering... so who really needs a shrink here?
I've been clear and consistent, again you have a selective listening disorder. Sex IS a competition, but the nature of that competition changes when one gets married in a loyal manner. As I said before, "everything in life is a competition"... perhaps what you are missing is, generally one should compete with oneself... read the posts a few more times maybe it will sink into your thick skull.
Now to address your additional rhetoric: First, I've seen no where that I ever claimed to be mature. Again you reveal that you need to make things up to make even a semblance of a point. And I didn't deny being competitive, anywhere, in any way shape or form. I have simply said that in my youth (and into my 20s, I was indeed a player, and now, as a married man, I am not) none of these statements validates what you are trying to claim I said, so let me reiterate since it appears English is not your first language:
1/ I was a player, now I am not.
2/ I have ALWAYS viewed sex as a competition, even as a married man.
3/ No where have I contradicted myself, nor have you shown otherwise.
And as far as my sexual tastes, distastes, habits, etc... No again I assert it's none of your business and not a concern of mine if you have questions, statements, thoughts, opinions about it. I could really care less and my only thought is that you must lead a very boring life to take such a strong interest in mine, a stranger to you.
Lastly, so you indicate with the "cat got your tongue" remark that I should be sitting here, waiting and waiting for your response and if I don't respond right away, I must have nothing to say...
Again, you sound like you live in bobcat land. Did it ever occur to you that I might have a job, to feed that wife and child(ren)? I do, I'm not on here all day, some of my job is in the office, some is in the field, I'll be leaving again in about 30 minutes for another appointment, but I should be back within a couple hours... is that okay bobcat?
Also, you are behaving like a troll and nothing fancier. Trolls have anger issues. I am the wrong target for your rants as ultimately you will indeed look like a fool, as I think you already do.
I'm not going to speculate on what you need, but I don't see that attacking strangers will help you in the long run with your anger problem.
Bobcat
Senior Member

1490 Posts
2/08
Posted - Mar 11 2010 : 3:41PM
What's the competition, who you competing against, is there a long line if dude's fucking her or something????
I don't view life as a competition anyway...what's the point...who am I competing against, why should I worry what the next guy does, how much money he earns, what car he drives, how big his house....there's always going to be someone with more...........if you worry about this all your life, all you'll do is screw up your brain and become paranoid.....ummmmmmmmmm, lets see, who's like that
All Forums > Sex Talk > Sex Talk Forum Page 2My sister wants me to lend her porn dvd's

Previous topic: Prostate Massagers
Next topic: Favorite Porn Podcasts (topic moved)
Page 1 of 2 Last



Jump To: