New Pornstar Interviews - [more]
Chloe Temple Interview

"I’ve hooked up with multiple people in one day, just bounced from one to the other."
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 55 > New To Replace IDE Drive
AuthorPost
lazenby
Member

London, United Kingdom
274 Posts
12/00
Posted - Sep 4 2004 : 7:06AM
I need to replace my dieing 80gb IDE drive.

I'm looking for 120gb replacement. Any recommendations?

Thanks Lazenby

Extreme Anal Pounding Movie Lover

Feel free to e-mail me or

GaySatyr
Senior Member

Half dirty ol' man; half horny ol' goat!
1684 Posts
10/00
Posted - Sep 4 2004 : 9:58AM
Assuming that it is a standard, parallel EIDE drive, I'd recommend either of these: Western Digital WD1200BB or WD1200JB hard drives -- the differences between the two models are the warranty (1-yr/3-yrs), and the cache (2MB/8MB - 8MB gives better performance). ~ GS (ABB)
Horn
Member

Finland
46 Posts
1/03
Posted - Sep 4 2004 : 11:31AM
Well,

if you want quiet and fast then go for a Seagate Barracuda 7200.7. Seagate just upped the warranty of their drives bought after July 26, 2004 to 5 years. :)

The drive is fast, really quiet (No idle whine, reads and writes can be heard if you listen carefully.) and it has an excellent reputation for being a very reliable drive. The plus model comes with an 8MB cache. Linkage: Seagate product page for ST3120026A.

I have never had a Seagate drive from this family or from one of the before (Barracuda IV and V) fail on me. During the years I have installed them to our clients and our own work machines, no problems encountered. I currently have four of them running at my home (40GB Barracuda IV, 80GB PATA and SATA Barracuda 7200.7´s and 200GB SATA Barracuda 7200.7). Fast, quiet and reliable.

Edited by - Horn on 9/4/2004 12:56:07 PM

Wicker Man
Member

56 Posts
8/04
Posted - Sep 4 2004 : 1:04PM
Hey I also agree with GaySatyr and recommend that you go with the Western Digital Drives, I have had the WD1200JB hard drive in my computer for a couple of years now I think and never had an issue. I even got the 200GB version and about to buy another! He provided a link to www.newegg.com which is a good place, I'd also recommend www.zipzoomfly.com
Kperv
The Cuddler

*struck
(She slipped)

1818 Posts
1/04
Posted - Sep 4 2004 : 4:42PM
I'm partial to the Seagate Barracuda 7200.7.
It's not the fastest drive out there, but it is quiet and good quality.

Personally I'd only consider drives from Seagate or Western Digital. They've never failed me nor, I believe, anyone else I know.

 
jamesn
Senior Member

Cambridge, MA
750 Posts
1/04
Posted - Sep 4 2004 : 7:48PM
Seagate or samsung are probably making the quietest drives with the best warranties. I'd go with the 200gb barracudas, they're the only 100gb/platter drive out there now, 8mb cache, and they've got upgraded bearing-mechanisms versus the rest of the seagates. Mine is noticably quieter and faster than the 160mb version I have--you can pick one up for under 130 dollars.
Spew
Deactivated User

Bend over for the rod and staff of Jesus!
334 Posts
7/04
Posted - Sep 5 2004 : 3:18AM
I'd get a set of Maxtor 73.4GB Atlas III KW073L8 10000RPM
Spew
Deactivated User

Bend over for the rod and staff of Jesus!
334 Posts
7/04
Posted - Sep 5 2004 : 3:19AM
Harri Patel
Senior Member

#SDNY he's all yours. -- Michael Steele
5110 Posts
3/03
Posted - Sep 5 2004 : 4:16AM
I also like the Seagate drives.
Spew
Deactivated User

Bend over for the rod and staff of Jesus!
334 Posts
7/04
Posted - Sep 6 2004 : 2:32PM
You could run a 6 gig OS from the Hitachi 36.7GB (8mb cache) UltraStar 68Pin 10000RPM drive, and then have a set of 80GIG 10000's for storage. Fast!
jamesn
Senior Member

Cambridge, MA
750 Posts
1/04
Posted - Sep 7 2004 : 3:49AM
those are fast, i'm not sure scsi is the best answer given his question. for a lot of stuff especially for just storing stuff, fast drives are hotter and louder than you'd want, and scsi means buying extra hardware for most people.
Horn
Member

Finland
46 Posts
1/03
Posted - Sep 7 2004 : 4:02AM
Well, I think lazenby meant IDE drives?

That Maxtor Atlas III sure is one fast drive even for being a 10K drive but for a home or even for an ordinary workstation machine that would be genuine and total Overkill™.

The difference in performance in desktop and office use is negligible when compared to modern 7200rpm drives. You really can´t tell the difference if the rest of the machine isn´t state of the art or even relatively modern and you don´t push it to the limits storage systems wise.

The cost is also prohibitive especially if one has to buy the controller etc. And figuring in the factor that that thing is not quiet by any means and pumps out quite a lot of heat...

For the best site about HDD´s and such I would guide you to storagereview.com. Lot´s of nice people there, just go to the forums and ask. The advice you get is usually the advice you need.

Horn

(Oh, even for SCSI I would still go for Seagate, 15K.3 (or the coming 15K.4) Cheetah´s all the way baby...)

lazenby
Member

London, United Kingdom
274 Posts
12/00
Posted - Sep 7 2004 : 4:04AM
Thanks for all your replies.

I`ve opted for the Barracuda 7200.7+ 120GB UDMA100 8mb Buffer.

I did want to go for a 160gb but have read about some BIOS problems with anything above 137gb on a Dell 8200.

Spew
Deactivated User

Bend over for the rod and staff of Jesus!
334 Posts
7/04
Posted - Sep 8 2004 : 12:44AM
sorry, i was getting carried away, i must remember "IDE only". but those drives are pretty elite, i dont have them myself, but ive used them and couldnt think of anything better (but yes they are VERY loud and produce a lot of heat...but the speed is amazing, i love it!)



Jump To: