Reviewers Recommend
Big Ass DPBig Ass DP - review by bono-one
Director: Sid Knox
Starring: Seth Gamble, Christian Clay, Anna Claire Clouds. Read review
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 19 > PC power supplies with quiet fans
AuthorPost
Bobcat
Senior Member


1490 Posts
2/08
Posted - Jul 17 2010 : 6:24AM
I just replaced my power supply as the fan had become noisey, the new one isn't much better . Who makes quiet/silent ones? I'm looking for an ATX one with an 8cm fan, around 500 watts.
Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14595 Posts
3/02
Posted - Jul 17 2010 : 11:17AM
ninja1
Senior Member

2939 Posts
1/08
Posted - Jul 17 2010 : 1:41PM
Check your other fans - case fan(s), cpu fan, graphics card fan - for dust accumulation on the blades and on the heatsink fins. Dust accumulation causes extra air turbulence which (in additional to reduced cooling) makes more noise.
The 8cm fan isn't mandatory; it's just a commonly used size for the output fan on power supply units (PSU). Designers can make a quieter PSU by using larger diameter fans which can provide sufficient airflow at lower rpm speed. Lower rpm = quieter operation. The larger fans will be located on the underside of the PSU, not visible from the outside of the computer.
Also take a look at these power supply review articles for some useful information about power supplies in general; it can be useful for choosing your next PSU, if you decide to buy a new one.
Link 1
Link 2
Bobcat
Senior Member

1490 Posts
2/08
Posted - Jul 18 2010 : 7:32AM
Thanks, I didn't realise the larger fans with the different configuration were interchangable with what I had. I may well get one.
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Jul 19 2010 : 4:17PM
This may be an opportune moment for me to ask.
My fan in my PSU has been speeding up when I'm doing things that are processor intensive. Now while this kind of makes sense, I'm wondering if this is a sign that it may be nearing it's demise? I don't recall it doing this when the PC was new.
 
Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14595 Posts
3/02
Posted - Jul 20 2010 : 12:39AM
The fan is doing what it is supposed to do. If anything has changed it is more likely to be the amount of dust in your case. Ergo, clean the filters, blow out the dust and then see how it goes.
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Jul 23 2010 : 1:05PM
Bobcat - If you haven't bought anything yet, I just bought and installed this yesterday. I paid $49 for it at Best Buy (I always prefer to buy stuff like this locally so returning it isn't so much of a hassle).
As near as I can tell, it's almost silent (I have an external drive and an old Seagate internal drive that makes quite a bit of noise). Unless you have a silent hard drive and case fan, you won't hear this power supply running under normal load. It seems to be a great power supply (For the price) from all the reviews.
This supply should be sufficient for a standard computer. I guess it depends on what kind of graphics card you have in it. Unless you have something really power hungry, it should be fine.
Edited by - randomprecision on 7/23/2010 1:23:39 PM
Dave_K99
Member

497 Posts
12/07
Posted - Jul 24 2010 : 4:14PM
Silent PC Review is the only site I trust for reviews of low noise products.
Their PSU test rig is comprehensive, and as far as I know they're the only site to use an anechoic chamber and decent dBA meter for accurate noise comparisons.
Most of the other sites compare products by ear, or just quote the manufacturer's spec. From what I've seen, many of them test components in such a noisy environment that all but the loudest are going to be inaudible.
I used a fairly cheap Nexus Value 430 in my last build, mainly because I was using a cramped case and it's more compact than a typical PSU, but that's been very quiet.
If you aren't using a super high end gaming PC then any half decent 400W+ PSU should provide more than enough power.
Edited by - Dave_K99 on 7/24/2010 4:15:14 PM
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Jul 24 2010 : 5:36PM
Just be careful with that site unless you have a lot of money to spend. I discovered it about 3 years ago and started thinking about building a system and making a list of all the things I wanted to do to it. In the end, I gave up in frustration after adding up the price of all the things I was going to need.

I love the site though and you're right. It's an awesome site. I try to refrain from reading it though because it reminds me how loud my computer is.
Dave_K99
Member

497 Posts
12/07
Posted - Jul 25 2010 : 12:34AM
I first found SPCR back in the days before low noise computer products were common and easily found. Back when it was normal to modify PSUs because nothing on the market was quiet, when people hunted down specific batches of a particular hard drive to get the least noisy motor, rewired imported fans designed for other products, and built their own fan controllers from scratch. My first really quiet PC definitely left a hole in my wallet, but all the time spent trying different tweaks was more of an issue.
Of course a lot of those popular modding projects are commercial products these days; many common features, like hard drive vibration damping in cases, started out as tweaks written about on SPCR. Now there's such a big choice of products labelled "silent" that it's a daunting task to sort out the good stuff from the bullshit. Funny how quickly it went from being a particularly geeky fringe interest (even among computer hobbyists) to being big business. I guess computers becoming media centres and entering people's living rooms played a big part in that. Low power consumption "green" PC components have been a big help for low noise fanatics too.
Looking back at my carefully planned case mods and all the messing about in the past, it's amazing just how easy it is to make a near silent PC today. If you're willing to make a few compromises (e.g. relatively low end graphics and a mid range CPU) then it doesn't even add much to the cost and complexity of the build. I've chucked systems together for people without taking a lot of care to keep them quiet, yet the finished PC has been less noisy than the heavily tweaked "silent" Athlon I was using a decade ago.
Along with the availability of big, cheap, high quality LCD displays (I remember when my bulky old 21" Sony CRT cost as much as the PC it was connected to), the improvement in PC noise has been my favourite computing development in recent years.
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Jul 25 2010 : 4:37AM
^ Amazingly, the cheapo (Around $300) Emachines I have now was remarkably quiet when I bought it (The clunky old hard drive I added makes it noisy). I think it's around four years old now. They made some major improvements in low end fans and hard drives between the time I bought my last PC and the one I have now. The 250 gig WD drive that came in this thing has always been very quiet (For a hard drive) and has been rock solid
Harri Patel
Senior Member

#SDNY he's all yours. -- Michael Steele
5110 Posts
3/03
Posted - Aug 3 2010 : 8:23PM
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 19PC power supplies with quiet fans

Previous topic: Site Ripping Software ?
Next topic: Posting Porn Pics



Jump To: