Reviewers Recommend
Sexy Brunette Fucks Her AccountantSexy Brunette Fucks Her Accountant - review by Danielmayu33216
Director: Derek Dozer
Starring: Christian Clay, Isa Bella. Read review
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 20 > Sound Card Recommendations
AuthorPost
jayo All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member


2117 Posts
7/04
Posted - Feb 6 2010 : 8:11PM
I think the hardware of my on-board sound is failing, so I want to try an add-on sound card (I've already installed, deleted, re-installed, all sorts of drivers and codecs).
I need to get a card that runs off PCI Express. I don't run high-end games so I just want something tame. I think it boils down to three: a Soundblaster, a Turtle Beach, and something from Diamond.
Any comments/opinions on them? I had a bad experience with a Diamond video card, but that was a decade ago. I've had SBs before but no real opinion either way. Never owned a TB product. I know they used to have a great reputation, but again, that was a decade ago.
(System is a mid-level PC running Win XP.)
Edited by - jayo on Feb 6 2010
Harri Patel
Senior Member

#SDNY he's all yours. -- Michael Steele
5110 Posts
3/03
Posted - Feb 6 2010 : 8:28PM
Are you sure you don't have regular PCI slots available? From a quick look on newegg.com, there aren't many PCI-E sound cards, and they're all pretty expensive. If that's really the situation, and all you want is something that makes sound, you might consider one of the little cheap external ones that plug into a USB port - they're about the size of thumb drives.
jayo All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

2117 Posts
7/04
Posted - Feb 6 2010 : 8:46PM
Yup. I had the computer open to make see what was available before I bought a card.
BYOB_Kenobi
Senior Member

“Life can only be understood backwards; but it must be lived forwards.” - Kierkegaard
2684 Posts
8/09
Posted - Feb 6 2010 : 9:26PM
I've had a horrible experience with a PCI-E sound card by CL (SoundBlaster ExtremeAudio). Fucking died only about 1 year after I got it. Personally, I don't like any exotic (only PCI, but haven't tried USB).
If you have a PCI slot, personally, I'd go with a proven $25 PCI SB 7.1 card. I have read a lot of good reviews by testers for Asus's Xonar/Sonar PCI sound cards and thought about getting their $50 PCI model for something above onboard audio that provides good fidelity (but this is just me).
You're options:
I don't like Diamond (have heard too many problems and company has gone downhill since late 90s)
I only like SB if it's cheap (able to get another brand card if problems) and only non-exotic models (PCI or maybe USB) proven models (been out a while w/lots of satisfactory users).
I actually like TB from little I know (probably not enough experience for a recommend), but definitely not as bad as Diamond.
---
Yeah, I just checked Newegg and the model that died is the Creative SB X-Fi Xtreme Audio 70SB104000000 that are the only PCI-E sound cards under $99. Not sure what to tell you. I never used a USB solution, but Harri probably stated the only other PCI-E alternative.
If you have to go with PCI-E and you want to can afford it, if it was me, I'd go with the ASUS Xonar DX 7.1 Channel PCI-E Sound Card Retail (http://www.zipzoomfly.com/jsp/ProductDetailp?ProductCode=10008407) over at ZipZoomFly (in stock) for $84 (out of stock @ Newegg). But caveat is I've only read & heard of these good Asus audio cards, never used them. But I have used ZipZoomFly and they are a decent vendor that I go to if there are supply issues @ Newegg.
Edited by - BYOB_Kenobi on 2/6/2010 9:34:22 PM
jayo All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

2117 Posts
7/04
Posted - Feb 7 2010 : 3:34PM
Thanks everyone. I think I'll try the Turtle Beach USB add-on and see how it goes.
 
DrP0rn0
Senior Member

1836 Posts
5/04
Posted - Feb 8 2010 : 3:06PM
I guess I'm late but here goes anyway:
Turtle Beach cards had a great rep way back when; mostly for high quality applications like recording studios. These days I think it's more hype than anything else. Sound Blaster tends to be very solid value for the money and largely compatible. Drivers seem to mostly "just work". I had a few really bad experiences with Turtle Beach card drivers, but that's been a long time now.
Seems like you're the perfect candidate for an entry level SB USB external sound card. I'm using one on a PC with no slots and it works like a champ. Excellent sound quality both in and out. The on board sound card had really awful recording quality; the SB is very nice in that respect.
I think I paid $50 for mine several years ago. I see they are still available in that range. Best of luck.
Dr. P
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 20Sound Card Recommendations

Previous topic: Video Joiner
Next topic: Sound problems



Jump To: