Reviewers Recommend
Seductions 3Seductions 3 - review by Captain Jack
Director: Kayden Kross, W.C. Walker, Autumn Rose
Starring: Marina Gold, Maximo Garcia, Amber Moore, Leana Lovings, Parker Ambrose, Chocolate God, Jewel Diamant. Read review
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 43 > Sound Editing Programs
AuthorPost
Michael Saint
Photographer


Alexis Texas is always lovely
1062 Posts
2/01
Posted - Mar 19 2006 : 10:41PM
Okay I just got this neat little device from ADS Tech called "Instant Music" which allows me to take all my old interviews (currently on micro cassette) from past conventions and convert them to digital files.

The problem is that at conventions there is a ton of background noise.

Can anyone recommend a good sound editing program that can help me get rid of that?

I run both a PC and a Mac but a Mac version would be preferred.

Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8031 Posts
9/99
Posted - Mar 19 2006 : 10:46PM
I use windows media encoder. You can download it from the microsoft site. It won't do a great job on background noise but you can play with it a bit. That's what I used for the two interviews skroners did at blog.adultdvdtalk.com


Edited by - Drew Black on 3/19/2006 10:47:32 PM

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14606 Posts
3/02
Posted - Mar 19 2006 : 10:58PM
It looks like Instant Music for the MAC includes Roxio's CD Spin Doctor 2 which, according to this page includes audio filters and a 10-band graphic EQ. Chances are that will be good enough.
Jeff @ IAFD All-Star Supporter
Webmaster IAFD.COM

933 Posts
6/00
Posted - Mar 19 2006 : 11:13PM
As a semi-pro sound designer, I live and die by Adobe Audition (previously Cool Edit Pro). It's a fabulous rogram and thru the use of DirectX plug-ins its highly extensible.

I've also used SoundForge which is fine, too, tho I tend to stick with what I know, so CoolEdit, er, Audition it is.

If you're on a Mac, I'm told ProTools is the be-all/end-all; but I'm not on a Mac, so it's lost on me. :-)

All that aside, noise reduction is more art than science -- despite what the scientists tell you.

I've found noise reduction to be merely OK, and it often leaves all sorts of messy artifacts behind, resulting in a tinny or ringing sound.

So you end up having to process discrete bits of audio to reduce the noise without introducing tin, which makes the whole process rather laborious.

You could also just try to EQ it which might be easier, and its somewhat less prone to the tinny/ring of the dynamics processor.

A quick Google search on "wave noise reduction" popped up this tool which on first glance does as good a job as any...


Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14606 Posts
3/02
Posted - Mar 19 2006 : 11:21PM
Adobe bought Cool Edit Pro? Shows I haven't been paying attention. I'm using Sonar, which does a good job but is probably too expensive for what Lee wants to do, as is Pro Tools.
 
Michael Saint
Photographer

Alexis Texas is always lovely
1062 Posts
2/01
Posted - Mar 19 2006 : 11:29PM
Hardware - mine didn't come with the Roxio software it came with "Nero" but said it was for Macs. I don't know if there is a different one out there any more or not. Though I may just try that one.

FTR Nero would not load on my Mac system.

I used Garage Band to import the file onto my computer. Currently I am just playing with the Jesse Jane interview I did in Digital's office just to get the feel for how it will work.

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14606 Posts
3/02
Posted - Mar 19 2006 : 11:56PM
Unfortunately, I don't know of any products that would meet your need that don't include a whole lot more functionality, and are priced accordingly.

The link provided by Jeff might work for you. If not, then you might find a pro/semi-pro music shop in your area that has somebody who can steer you in the right direction.

BigBobxxx
Senior Member

2681 Posts
5/04
Posted - Mar 20 2006 : 9:28AM
Nero does not make a Mac version as far as I know.
snowman872
RainCoatReviews.com

400 Posts
6/00
Posted - Mar 23 2006 : 12:30AM
Lee ... Magix's Audio Cleaning Lab works pretty good for this sort of thing:

http://site.magix.net/english-us/home/music/audio-cleaning-lab-10/

I see it pop up at CompUSA all the time almost free after rebates.

-- Snowman




Jump To: