If you're going purely by performance, that's totally subjective because everyone has preferences on what they think makes a good/great performance.

Edited by - draxxx on 3/31/2021 8:18:22 AM

[Link]

By the way, my username is based on a silly sex act, not being a person who commits acts of robbery while harbouring deep seated resentment.

Edited by - AngryPirate on 3/31/2021 9:04:35 AM

[Link]

Only Aurora Snow even comes close.

[Link]

The reason why Adriana is the GOAT hands down is because you know her body of work. She brings it every scene. She has done everything you can think of. When you think of a pornstar and how slutty they can be well thats Adriana way of life. Not just for work. She is also super intelligent and competitive so again she brings it with everything she does. Im glad she has done tons and tons of g/g scenes, love that she has a passion for doing trans scenes, and she is the squirting queen which I love as well. She is also someone who is adamant that squirting isnt pee. She actually said on her live tonight that she cant pee in front of others. Its a true struggle for her. The thing though that you can say separates Adriana from plenty of performers is that she truly care about people. I was just watching her live show tonight and how she was like nope she is not doing anal because apparently I dont think she was prepared for it. She was saying that throughout the show but as people kept asking, guess what? She did anal. She cares about her fans even to the point where she said if there is anything anyone is concerned about in regards to feeling like they arent getting their money worth for her onlyfans to talk to her about the issue and she will go about fixing it. She mentioned about how she can understand some people feel like they arent talking to the real person in the DMs but she can assure you that they are talking to her even to the point where she said her pussy is literally sore because she really be rubbing herself while sexting with people so she can truly be in the mood and not faking like she is. Even got emotional at the end of the live because she was just saying how much she truly appreciate her fans and just want to treat everyone good. To me it really hit home that its more than just scenes with female performers. I know some dont see it that way but they are humans and for me thats why Adriana is not just an all-time favorite of mine but a personal favorite. That is to say I dont ever have to watch another scene from her and still think she is the greatest and have the utmost respect and love for her because who she is as a person.

[Link]

Jennifer White: I don't think people give her enough credit beauty wise because she has been a super nasty slut since she got into porn but if you take a step back, you'll see she's not only one of the most beautiful women in porn but she has one of the best bodies abs genuinely likes fucking. I mean you can't take it to the extent that she has unless she's an Oscar level actress. Beauty and filth, my favorite combo.

Angela White, fuck me.. what else can I say about Angela. She can put on a dress or skirt and heels and be the classiest, most beautiful woman in the room one moment and be the dirtiest whore you've ever seen the next. Her accent, her blue blue eyes, pale skin, perfect natural body and her presence make her contender for GOAT IMO

Jayden Jaymes, okay I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that Jayden is in my opinion the best looking girl to ever do porn with her equals being only Kortney Kane, Amy Reid and Sunny Leone. What sets Jayden apart from these girls is that she did everything and she was dirtier than all of the super model type girls I just mentioned. Jayden really pushed herself and did an interracial dp (where she really struggled to take both cocks at the same time but in a totally hot way), she did a gangbang with anal and dp, she did ass to mouth and ass to other girls mouth.

I can't choose between the three girls I mentioned here. They're all beautiful with insanely hot bodies.

Honorable mentions:

Aletta Ocean - the prototype bimbo fuckdoll. She has transformed herself into what can be described as a literal fuck doll. Fake cheeks, lips, ass, calves and has even had her pussy prettied up with surgery. I usually hate any kind of body altering surgery but my fucking god! Her plastic surgeon knows what he's doing. She looks remarkable and is as filthy as ever (okay she has toned it down a bit to be honest compared to her earlier work. Worth mentioning because she's stunning and filthy.

[Link]

As an example, Mason Moore has been out of the business for at least 3 or 4 years now but I keep going back to her scenes.

That makes her a GOAT to me.

[Link]

I'm not a legalporno fan but when some of my favorite stars do work for them I watch the scenes. Go check out her gangbang there where she's wearing turquoise lingerie. This is the first scene I've seen Jasmine tap out. The one dude fucks her in the ass in doggy and she clearly isn't taking it easily as she does normally with anal. It's so hot but not gross like most of LPs shit is. She's being pushed in this scene and it's so hot seeing her finally meeting her match and getting railed HARD!

Sorry for the thread jacking here OP but bro my favorite Jasmine Jae scene ever was her JJ scene with Rico and Prince. What makes the scene so hot? Well she's with Prince at home fucking and Rico knocks on the door. Jasmine goes to answer the door wearing nothing but high heels. Just fucking HOT seeing her casually answer the door naked then walks back to Prince abs starts sucking his cock in her heels on her knees. Pure perfection by Mr Jules Jordan. These are the things that turn me on in porn.

[Link]

Voting the GOAT based purely on performance is a completely and totally subjective thing. Some might name the best based on how nasty/extreme they can get. Some by the amount of penises they are able to take on. Some might say the best girl is the one who looks like they're enjoying themselves the most. Some might choose a girl that they simply enjoying watching.

[Link]

If I'm reading something into your post that isn't there then I apologize.

[Link]

First off, her longevity from the 80's until now.

Secondly, she's done just about everything somewhere along the line. Straight, Lez, IR, Anal, Gangbang, BDSM, MILF, lesbian older younger, BG older Younger, GILF ... I'm sure there's more I am missing.

Thirdly, she was just plain hot. Even now, in her 60s, she's doable.

Finally, attitude. She's one of those performers that always seems to be having fun in her scenes. Even in her more strict BDSM scenes her delight in what she's doing comes through.

[Link]

Sooo. I don't know of any one female performer checks all these boxes, but here's a short list that checks most of these, I think:

Asa Akira
Francesca Le
AJ Applegate (RIP Bill Bailey)
Anikka Albrite
Jessica Drake (I absolutely hate the condoms only Wicked films as well as their artsy themes, wished she would do gonzo)

I'm sure my list isn't complete.

Edited by - 2manyDVDs on 5/14/2021 11:56:33 AM

Edited by - 2manyDVDs on 5/14/2021 8:43:21 PM

[Link]

GOAT based on more what I think of as "factual" reasons...

Angela White. She's built a strong brand name in porn. She seems to be a great business person. She a performer who can do a large variety of genres . She's got the looks. She's a very solid performer. She has a steady stream of content coming out of all different genre types of porn because she puts in the work. She's very intelligent. But I must admit...I don't watch that much of her stuff. I don't know why. She should be a fav of mine because she's got the type of looks I like and she's a great performer. But I don't go out of my way to watch her. I find it sort of strange.

Riley Reid . I'm a big fan of Riley. I am most impressed with Riley's popularity because it kinda goes against the odds. Riley is petite and looks young. Most petite girls who look young get stuck in the "barely legal" genre and can't escape unless they get a boobjob, gain weight, or go for doing the more "extreme" stuff. Yet, Riley transcended the "barely legal" genre and did a a bunch of other genres. Riley was able to stay mostly a top ten girl for years without being able to do "Big Butt", Big Tit", or "MILF", scenes. Plus she didn't do anal, DPs, gangbangs, or the more extreme stuff until the last few years of her career. She's not a great actress. She's well known in porn but seems to have very little mainstream presence. Riley seemed to be able to pull off a fantastic porn career by just being cute, a performer who seems to actually enjoy the sex, being smart and working hard.

Jenna Jameson . Jenna is/was one of the most popular girls of all times. I tend to think it was a perfect storm of luck, timing, and being able to capitalize on the luck and timing when it happened. She also had the right amount of sexiness and good looks without quite having the over the top pornstar looks. Because of the brand she was able to build she was a major force in porn during her run. She moved a lot of product. She had major popularity. She had a mainstream presence. She was the girl many pornstars wanted to emulate. I'm guessing she won a lot of awards. For awhile she was the face of porn. But I wasn't much of a fan. I've seen very little of her work. I saw her as bland compared to what most other were doing. Her brand of porn was made for a specific audience. Lucky for her that audience was huge and able to give her the type of success she had.

Sasha Grey I'm a big fan of Sasha. I don't feel quite as strongly about calling her the GOAT as I do about the others. She was a huge figure in porn while she was in but looking back at career I'm thinking she wasn't as big a deal as I remember or thought she was. Great scenes. Very popular. Mainstream presence. Did lots of different genres of porn while she was in the business. She's been out of the game for years but is still ranked high (considering) in porn searches. Part of me thinks as big as she was she still wasn't as big as she should've been. Very popular but I don't think she played the porn game and didn't get the same sort of industry recognition as other lesser performers got. Or maybe she did. I'm not sure.

Adriana Chechik . Fantastic performer. Great looks. Seems to very much be into the sex in her scenes. Fun to watch. One of the GOATs? Debatable. It all depends what you're into. She's not a major force in porn. Her brand isn't as strong as an Angela White or Jenna Jameson. She isn't as versatile as some other pornstars as far as being in a variety of different porn genres. She could easily do that stuff as far as I can tell but chooses not to do much of or doesn't stand out as much when she does...I'm not sure. But Adriana is a go-to when it's time to do the mainstream porn extreme stuff. There are other girls who may be more extreme/nastier but they probably don't have the charisma, likability, beauty and presence of Adriana. With the extreme stuff there's only so much you can do and after a time you're just repeating the same thing but fans still get excited to see the next scene from Adriana even years after her debut.

[Link]

Heather Lee. My favorite pornstar of all time to watch. Heather was out of porn when I discovered her. I ran across her buying cheap Big Boob compilation DVDs years ago. Do I think she's the best performer? Nope. Best looking? Nope. Best body? Nope. but I looove her looks and her boobs and she's just so sexy to me. I really like watch her in scenes. I wish she had a longer career and more of her stuff was around in better quality. I never get tired of watching her.

Riley Reid . I someone would ask me to describe what I think is the perfect female body and type it would be the total opposite of Riley. I'm into curvy big boobs and butt types mostly. Riley has a great body for a petite girl but I tend to prefer curvy. Mostly for porn I tend to go for the more stereotypical pornstar or bimbo look. Yet, Riley is an all time fav based on her cuteness, attitude, likability, and performance. She's just so fun to watch. I've never seen what I consider a bad Riley scene. She seems to always have the attitude of sh couldn't wait to have sex with her partners. She seem to always be enjoying herself. In reality that probably isn't always the case but she makes me think she is. She a combination of sexy and cute. She makes me smile. I can sit around and watch Riley when she not having sex and enjoy it. Also, she doesn't get the credit for being as smart as she is. But that kinda makes sense because that's not why people watch her.

Sasha Grey . Love watching Sasha. In my book she's about on equal level with me as Riley. But the two are different types of performers. To me Riley comes across as the girl who really wants to have sex because she's into the person and want to do them. Sasha is more of a fuckdoll performer and is there to let you do whatever you want to her. Sasha puts on more of a performance (not a bad thing) and at times can go overboard with the talking but the scenes are just great. She doesn't have typical model looks but I find her to be strangely sexy. I find her butt to be fantastic! Some of my fav Sasha scenes are the ones where the director spends time showcasing her butt. I saw a clip from some low level studio of Sasha wearing some booty shorts walking down the street and the camera focuses on her butt and I think it's great. I wish it were available somewhere to buy (maybe it is).

Chastity Lynn . Just fun to watch. Great performer. So cute. She has a real girl next door or down the street look about her. She comes off as likable. she seems to enjoy doing her scenes.

Syren De Mar Great body. Great performer. She has the looks of a sexy woman who knows she looks good without going too far with it. She seems up for anything and seems to be into the sex. I like her nude but I really like the way she looks in clothes. She looks like a hot woman you could come across at a mall or shopping. Something down to earth about her. Sexy to watch.

Britney Amber . Sexy. Great body. Love her personality. Looked good in the early part of her career but back then she didn't do much for me. Over the past few years I've really been into her. She probably doesn't get that much attention these days because she's been in the biz for awhile but she's a solid performer. Her looks and personality play a big role in why I enjoy watching her.

[Link]

Seka was popular with me and my high school buddies. Marilyn Chambers, too.

Meanwhile, The French had their version of the goat in Brigette Lahaie and deservedly so.

I am not a huge fan of Ginger Lynn so her continued popularity surprises me.

Christy Canyon was also really popular and I see Angela White as the modern day version of her.

As mentioned, Jenna Jameson was huge at the turn of the century.

In the past 20 years, so many beautiful performers have come and gone so I will jump to someone working today.

Just before the pandemic hit, I bought a huge stash of newer DVDs (last 5 years or so) so I watched some great scenes from

Stoya, Megan Rain, Lana Rhoades, Jennifer White, Morgan Lee, Katrina Jade, Dani Daniels, Mia Malkova and Keisha Gray.

However, the performer that stuck out to me for her all-around beauty and top-notch performances is

Adriana Chechik

and we are lucky that she is still around.

tb

[Link]

Since many years now ANGELA WHITE.

Edited by - German_Gooner on 5/16/2021 2:49:53 AM

[Link]

Since many years now ANGELA WHITE.

[Link]

How did Sheena Shaw stack up against Adriana? I haven't seen that much of Sheena's work and I don't know if Sheena and Adriana were in the biz at the same time but I seem to remember Sheena used to get the same type of praise Adriana is getting now before she left the business. Am I misremembering? Were Sheen and Adriana in the same league? Did Sheen stay around long enough to make her mark?

[Link]

Now, having said that, I'm also going to defend Sheena as a really good performer. She always had a lot of energy in her scenes, gave a very sloppy blowjob, and was up for anything sexually. She was also a pretty good dirty talker with a sexy voice which I always appreciate.

I don't think you going to be unhappy if you watch any Sheena scenes but, for me, Adriana has a certain "something" that places her head and shoulders above most pornstars.

It's a real shame what happened to Sheena, it would have been interesting to see what she could have become in the business.

[Link]

GOAT: Nicole Aniston

[Link]

I excerpted the post I'm quoting here just to comment on the bold I added. I definitely think Sasha Grey DID play the game really well. The game has changed, but she was a pioneer.

[Link]

As far as Sasha Grey goes...I've been looking back over her work lately and I'm kinda surprised how much work she did for the smaller companies of the time and it seems she didn't have the type of presence in the top studios of the day as I thought she did considering her popularity. She did work for the top studios but she didn't seem to be that big a deal at the time for most of them. That's why I tend to think she didn't play the game. Or at least play the game to the extent someone like Bree Olson for example who seemed like a bigger star during her time in porn in some ways but didn't seem to have the same type of impact Sasha had. Maybe I'm wrong or misremembering but it seems like Sasha never had the type promotion many girls at that level got.

[Link]

This is what I hate about these lists. Skin wasn't on mine but how could she not be? She 100% should be, absolutely gorgeous and her performances matched her looks.

Going through my list, I realise how many girls I missed out on like Skin Diamond, India Summer, Jillian Janson, Blair Williams.

It's good though, shows how spoilt for choice we are when you can't cover the girls who have 10's for looks and performance. A good problem to have.

[Link]

For my own personal preferences it would be Lana Rhoades just based on her looks, her enthusiastic performances and willingness to do a lot of things, and her dirty talk.

In terms of current day, I don't know. I get the love for Adrianna Chechik and Angela White, but I don't think they are GOAT status at least not yet. Maybe Mia Malkova has that potential as well. I also can't keep up with who is actually retired these days. Reilly Reid, Abella Danger, Jessa Rhodes could also all be contenders in terms of their popularity.

[Link]

Names that pop into my head right away:

Belladonna
Bree Olson
Gauge
Barbie Angel
Piper Perri
Chastity Lynn
Brianna Banks

But for my number one, guaranteed to get me off anytime anyplace no matter what...

Taylor Rain - totally hot, LOVED sex, very natural, no fakeness to her. Born to take cock in her ass. If you look up anal sex in the dictionary there is a picture of her with a huge cock in her ass

[Link]

Stacey Valentine

Julia Bond

Memphis Monroe

Megan Rain

Lana Rhoades

Current: Kali Roses

[Link]

& All time debatable (new school) - Adrianna Chechik

All time (old school)

Julia Ann

[Link]

I like hardcore scenes, and I respect when girls do DAP or something crazy. But for example vaginal from Eva will turn me on way more than Adriana Chechik DAP. I feel like today girls work too much and when they fuck them in the ass or do dp for them it's like walk in the park.Maybe it's just me but I don't feel same energy like there was 10 years ago.

[Link]

I think I'm willing to take a position finally. Though I'm sure for all of us it could change. For me it's probably Taylor Rain. Taylor came onto the scene and brought everything I enjoy in porn models. I loved her petite and perfect body, her stunningly beautiful face, her fun attitude and her willingness to do just about anything on camera. For me, timing was a bit of an issue too. I had really started collecting porn seriously in the mid-1990s and by the early 2000s when Taylor came around she instantly became my favourite. I looked for anything with her in it.

Aside from me thinking that Taylor's body was perfection, I am definitely a fan of petite asses and Taylor hooked me from first sight with her tight little ass. And on top of my love of the female ass, I love seeing things go into said female asses and Taylor delivered on that too. I recall in either a BTS or in pre-scene banter the male talent commented with amazement at Taylor's ability to take large cocks anally with no problems at all. He asked her "where does it go?" She giggled and said "I don't know!" Even she recognized her special talent and thankfully was willing to share it with her fans.

Honourable mention here has to go to Inari Vachs. Inari was a lot like Taylor in her appeal for me but I think I have to give the edge to Taylor.

[Link]

The Greatest of All Time

The best currently active

Goldmember�s Porn Pantheon

[Link]

Jayna Oso
Belladonna
Annette Schwarz
Dana DeArmond

Close contenders:
Jenna Haze
Taylor Rain
Amber Rayne
Gauge
Kat
Tiana Lynn
Holly Hendrix
Adriana Chechik
Nikita Bellucci
Roxy Jezel
Sasha Grey
Vicki Chase
Riley Reid

[Link]

That said, can I give a shout out to Rocco Siffredi? I realize everyone has chosen the female GOAT but Rocco defined new genres and introduced us to the most amazing group of female talent in the history of porn.

[Link]

Ana has done every kind of scene imaginable and really has withheld virtually nothing of herself from her fans. Her longevity and popularity speak for themselves--as does her status as the most awarded black female performer of all time. I hope we have her in front of the camera for another decade to come.

[Link]

There are girls who enter porn and no one makes a big deal about them. Some are very good looking but no one pays much attention to them. There are some girls who get into porn and they're wild and do all sorts of wild scenes right off the bat and are up for anything and no seems to care. Star power is having a look or that extra something that makes everyone take notice. They don't have to be the best looking or do the most extreme scenes. They just have that something that makes people pay attention.

There have been plenty of girls who come into the porn biz and are hot for awhile but it only lasts for a brief time. Sometimes a girl might have a bit of star power but doesn't do the right things to maintain it. I think girls have to have goals and some sort of plan to remain popular. Sometimes just shooting as much as they can will get that result but more often than not quality is more important than quantity. Making moves to shoot with the right studios/directors, holding back on doing certain types of sex acts for a bit, building your brand/fanbase, and being reliable, all help in a girl having staying power in porn.

While it's not the same for every girl, it's always a good thing to be versatile. There are girls who are great at doing the extreme stuff but you rarely see them doing the more typical porn scenes. No everyone likes to see the wild hardcore DPs, gangbang, and extreme anal stuff. On the flip side, I don't expect every girl to want to do the hardcore stuff, they need to at least not get stuck in one genre. You can only shoot so many MILF, "teen", big boob, big butt, scenes over and over before the studio and fans have seen you do that enough times. Unfortunately, some girls are stuck doing one genre and for whatever reason can't branch out of it or choose not to but I believe for a long porn career at some point you need to do different things and expand your fanbase and work options.

Some will disagree but I don't think performance skills are as important as the other things I've named. Sometimes being a great performer is enough to make and sustain a star but I don't think it's as important as the other things long term. But being great performer is always a good thing. It adds to and enhances all that other stuff. But I think Jenna Jameson and a few others have proved that you can still be a porn superstar without being a great performer.

However being the GOAT to an individual purely based on what that person likes is a totally different thing. While I think Angela White is one of the GOATS, and has a look and body type I usually like and prefer and I think she's a great performer...I don't go out of my way to watch her stuff. Meanwhile, there are girls I don't think are as good looking or as good a performer that I love to watch. Crazy how that works.

[Link]