I noticed a lot of the films I have been getting for reviews are compilations. We all know Adam & Eve have always put out a lot of comp titles, but lately Elegant Angel and FusXion has been doing it too. I heard a rumor that this is because the adult film industry is in trouble financially. I don’t know about all that, but my main reason for the post is how do you feel about comp DVDS?
For me I am mixed. I like the idea of a lot of great scenes of one specific genre from a quality company compiled in one disc. But also from what I understand is the performers don’t get a single penny from these comp DVDs. To me that doesn’t seem entirely fair.
Granted they get paid a lot of money for the scenes they do, but if the aforementioned scenes are re hashed over and over making the company money but not the girl, doesn’t that seem wrong? i know several performenrs I have interviewed aren't really pro the comp dvd.
Girls get pay for the scene, once the scene is done, its the property of the compagny and they can do whatever they want with it. Seem fair to me, its no different than mainstream movie, if they re-release a 1980 movie on dvd, do they pay the actors again? no they get pay to play in the movie, thats it.
As for comp, usually they get a lot of great girls, they are really cheap(10 bucks or so) 4 hour long, and for someone like me who pay porno at full price like...never or close to that(prefer renting) it can be a good way to get good porn for low price
I hate them, though some cumshot compilations and anal compilations are ok because there may be stuff you would never see otherwise.
Butchered scenes, no performer listing and cheap packaging... it's not for real porn fans imo.
That performers don't get payed for comps is not wrong imo, they're selling the rights to a scene upon signing the contract... just like selling an article to a paper... unless you're in the position to ask for royalties.
Mainstream actors get paid for every sort of repackaging.
It's only in the olden days (say Gilligan's Island) that the actors were paid once and then forgotten. After the success of say, Gilligan's Island, in reruns actors said "Hey, if Joe Producer is making money off my image, then I should too." Enter residuals.
Remember the Seinfeld episode where Jerry got writer's cramp because he had to endorse a ton of checks for a buck apiece? those were residuals. They're not always enough to live on, but they sure can be.
Porn however, it's pretty much "here's your money, see ya." and then that scene will end up in a dozen different formats (VOD, VHS, DVD, Cable, Satellite, Hotel, etc.) and even more movies, and the perf won't see a nickel beyond her original performance fee...
Jeff is right - actors get risiduals for both movies and TV roles. Every time the movie is sold on video or even aired on TV, the actor gets a check. Why don't porn stars get this? Because they've been too stupid to unionize and form their own actors guild...too afraid that studios will just find other chicks willing to work for a day's pay.
[Link]
myadultgroups Deactivated User
Los Angeles 755 Posts 10/04
Posted - Aug 1 2006 : 5:35PM
Companies are going compilation crazy at the moment. I don't like them because the commissions can be crappy (Vivid's pracing their comps at $12.95!). Vivid's compilation releases seem to outnumber their original releases. Plus, Wicked has a few comps they are heavily promoting on different online stores. I do believe its an indication that the industry is in desperate trouble. There is a terrible glut right now, because the entry point for making an adult DVD is so low right now. The five porn DVDs for $20 booth was quite popular during Erotica LA. As long as video cameras keep getting cheaper, the comp glut will keep getting worse. There's no closing the gates on who can make porn, but perhaps their ought to be a guild.
For consumers, comps are a good way to see a number of different performer and possibly discover a new favorite.
Thanks for everyone’s opinion. I really appreciate it. From what I gather regular porn viewers, like die hard porn fans are against the comp, but the casual viewers like the comp. It is a good way to get more fuck for the buck for sure, especially if you are on a tight budget.
Recently I read where more and more girls are getting a percentage merch sales too i.e. shirts, posters, hats whatever. Like mainstream actors. So maybe they can work a compilation clause in their contracts who knows.