New Pornstar Interviews - [more]
Introducing Lady LorReign

"Good oral on me turns me on. Also, knowing that my partner is enjoying themself,"
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 32 > Thoughts on a formatting change to the forum
Page 1 of 2 Last
AuthorPost
Drew Black
broken crankshaft


8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 2:35PM
What do you think of the new topic preview in the forum pages?
[edit to remove the link to the test page since it's now live]

Edited by - Drew Black on Aug 22 2007

conquistador
Deactivated User

Hellhamster.
2947 Posts
10/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 2:40PM
I can't tell a difference except the smaller print hurt my eyes (my glasses need to be repaired so I am squinting at small text right now).
Looks good to me, I can enlarge everything myself anyway.
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 2:43PM
GaySatyr
Senior Member

Half dirty ol' man; half horny ol' goat!
1684 Posts
10/00
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 2:49PM
Is the only difference the preview of the first post in a thread? The small print is difficult for my aging eyes; however, having the preview is a nice touch. And, if the print within the thread, itself, is normal, then I like it, despite the small print in the preview snippet.
~ GaySatyr (ABB)
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 2:50PM
Yes, the only difference is the inclusion of the first ~200 characters from the first post in the thread in 10pixel font.
I figured it would help people determine if topics are of interest.
 
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 2:52PM
I changed it to 11px instead of 10.
GaySatyr
Senior Member

Half dirty ol' man; half horny ol' goat!
1684 Posts
10/00
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 2:56PM
11px makes a BIG difference in terms of legibility. Very nice.
~ GaySatyr (ABB)
conquistador
Deactivated User

Hellhamster.
2947 Posts
10/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 3:02PM
Okay, I see it now that you mentioned it.
I agree with GaySatyr, the slightly larger text is better.
I still need to get my glasses repaired.
threesomebody
Official BlowBang Judge

Would you like my autograph?
2491 Posts
12/04
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 3:03PM
I like it.
I visit another forum where the 1st 200 or so characters pop up when the mouse is dragged over the subject line. I like that, too.
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 3:05PM
I set it live, i figure the feedback will roll in quickly then. If people hate it I can always go back to the old way.
3sb - I had thought about doing the mouse rollover kind of thing but that has negative implications for search engines viewing the site. Not all search engines are happy with text that's displayed as part of a java script action tied to a user input event.
Edited by - Drew Black on 8/21/2007 6:47:05 PM
Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14595 Posts
3/02
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 3:20PM
For me, the thread title is what determines whether or not I want to read it. Having text from the initial post just makes it harder to scan the thread titles, so I don't see it as an improvement.
justalurker
Member

241 Posts
8/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 3:26PM
Is it possible to make it an option? Like Hardware I go by thread title.
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 3:32PM
I can make it an option with the default setting displaying the text.
MisterNoGood
Member

195 Posts
2/04
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 3:34PM
I agree with Hardware, it is harder to scan thread titles, and it does not seem to be an improvement.
I would much rather have it as an option or not at all.
Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14595 Posts
3/02
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 3:35PM
Options are good.
 
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 3:39PM
Does the 15px margin help?
Jacco All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

"liable to deprave and corrupt"
2673 Posts
5/04
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 3:39PM
I don't really see a difference, but then I have my minimum fontsize at 11. And I always use Active Topics, so it would not make a difference to me.
Jacco
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:00PM
I think it's pretty cool, myself.
conquistador
Deactivated User

Hellhamster.
2947 Posts
10/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:02PM
Larger text is better for me. Drew, 15px helps.
conquistador
Deactivated User

Hellhamster.
2947 Posts
10/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:04PM
Also, I was wondering why the message board doesn't use normal text "point" sizes.
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:10PM
Because the point system is hit or miss from browser to browser. Pixels are pretty specific.
conquistador
Deactivated User

Hellhamster.
2947 Posts
10/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:11PM
Thanks. I didn't know.
LubeNLuv
Senior Member

1854 Posts
3/06
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:16PM
I dunno...I'm seeing a LOT of wasted "white space" now on the page offered as a sample. I'm on Firefox on a Mac....looks like there's a formatting issue.
Edit: Here's what it looks like on my screen
Picture 1.jpg
Edited by - lubenluv on 8/21/2007 4:21:40 PM
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:18PM
Any way you can forward a screenshot?
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:19PM
BTW, it looks good in the beta version of Safari for Windows.
 
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:23PM
thanks for the screenshot. (quite quick too.)
It looks about the same on my end.
LubeNLuv
Senior Member

1854 Posts
3/06
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:24PM
I think I've just a preference for "busy" screens. All a matter of personal taste.
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:35PM
I rearranged the location of the the topic paging links. That appears to compress some of the whitepsace.
Everett
Senior Member

2088 Posts
6/05
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:49PM
pros & cons
the only con I could see is maybe just a little tad clutter don't you think.
pros with everything else. I guess it's like trying on a new change of shoes.

"I don't like progress, it doesn't become change but disintegration" - Lady Marjorie Bellamy(Rachel Gurney), Upstairs Downstairs episode 1 "On Trial"

Dither
Persona non grata

I love America
650 Posts
8/05
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:50PM
I think too much text, it's messy. The first five to ten words from each topic, in a single line, would suffice as a preview. IMO.
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:51PM
I will create an option for people to disable the display of topic summaries. I don't think I'll get to it today but maybe this weekend.
Everett
Senior Member

2088 Posts
6/05
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 4:52PM
Drew, has Steph seen it yet? what does she think about it?
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 5:28PM
She hasn't seen it yet. She's away today.
She and I discussed it a few weeks ago. I had a few moments today to do something quick so I threw this together.
conquistador
Deactivated User

Hellhamster.
2947 Posts
10/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 5:40PM
I hope this doesn't sound really stupid. In the new format are the pictures people use as avatars slightly smaller?
the unknown pervert
Deactivated User

I'd like to stay but I've got a plane to catch.
3243 Posts
5/06
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 6:04PM
I haven't seen it on Firefox yet but thumbs down on IE. It jumps the title pages of the forum about half way off the screen to the right. It also does the same to the post reply screen. This is the experience I'm having with my PC your mileage and results may vary.


I'm probably exaggerating a little with the halfway off the screen comment but it is bad enough to be very distracting and annoying.

 
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 6:14PM
The avatars aren't displayed on the page that was updated.
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 6:15PM
What version of IE?
BTW, the post reply page wasn't changed recently.
the unknown pervert
Deactivated User

I'd like to stay but I've got a plane to catch.
3243 Posts
5/06
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 6:26PM
I believe IE 7 but I might be still on 6. I've kind of lost track of the updates. The title threads in Tech Talk and Feature Side still align correctly. Everything else goes Rush Limbaugh (jumping way over to the right).


Oops, Story Time lines up okay also.
Edited by - the unknown pervert on 8/21/2007 6:27:50 PM

Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 6:37PM
TUP - Just so I'm on the same page as you, could you copy/paste the URL in your browser if a page that has "title threads". I'm not sure what this term means.
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 6:42PM
I shortened the brief to 150 characters or less. That might be a happy medium.
I suspect that people browsing at resolutions wider than 1024px are happy with the change and those at 1024 or less are bumming.
BigMatt
Member

Sunrise Adams, Queen of Cute.
498 Posts
12/04
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 6:44PM
Confusing. While I used to be able to browse the forums while half asleep, now it takes an effort. Why don't you rather show some of the post on mouseover?
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 6:45PM
See this post above
nietzsche
Deactivated User

5470 Posts
8/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 6:53PM
I like this because I'm tired of having to express complex topics in 50 characters or fewer. This is a boon for complex thinkers like myself. Now I must excuse myself, I have to make a post about solar powered enema machines.
the unknown pervert
Deactivated User

I'd like to stay but I've got a plane to catch.
3243 Posts
5/06
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 7:22PM
Bill All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

5334 Posts
6/00
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 7:40PM
One problem that I see is, if someone puts a long URL into their post, somewhere within the first 200 characters, it screws up the formatting of the page, forcing some of the columns off of the screen.
It might be a good idea to put something in that eliminates the text of a post if there are more than "X" number of consecutive characters without any embedded spaces in the first 200 characters of the post.
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8011 Posts
9/99
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 7:51PM
It makes the cut at the first space character encountered starting from position 150 (previously 200) and working backwards. If there are no spaces found it won't display the text. HTML is stripped too so a period in text should qualify as a line-wrappable character.
Bill All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

5334 Posts
6/00
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 8:30PM
The view of WN&N is screwed up because of the "Russia lays claim to North Pole" thread. It's currently about the 60th thread down in that forum.
Edited by - Bill on 8/21/2007 8:30:41 PM
Son of Dad
Member

99 Posts
3/05
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 8:38PM

I don't like it. I like to be able to scan quickly through the topics and since I have bookmarks in a side bar only three or four topics are visible at a time.
I like the idea of the mouse rollover. That allows both a quick scan of multiple topics and a chance to have a quick preview of each topic.
//

Tinaka
Member

953 Posts
8/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 8:44PM
I hate it. It looks a mess and is no use to me at all.
Harri Patel
Senior Member

#SDNY he's all yours. -- Michael Steele
5110 Posts
3/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 9:01PM
As I said in the other thread, I don't like it, but as long as there is going to be an user-selectable option to stay with the old format, then I don't care.
@Neech - it isn't *that* hard to "headline-ize" your posts -- nowhere near as hard as trying to cram enough info in a negative feedback on ebay in the limited # of characters they give you.
HeyNow All-Star Supporter
Oblivious

Gold Star Hey!
5965 Posts
1/03
Posted - Aug 21 2007 : 9:05PM
It's okay, but I usually read the boards using Active Topics and the change hasn't hit there yet. Maybe it won't which would be a nice compromise and an option for those that just want to see tread titles.
Page 1 of 2 Last



Jump To: