more performer info on...

The Collector

All Forums > The Feature Side > The Feature Side Forum Page 58 > Thoughts on "The Collector"
AuthorPost
ObiBong
Senior Member


1162 Posts
12/02
Posted - Nov 15 2004 : 6:01AM
This Brad Armstrong film got 17 AVN Award nominations by my count, so I guess they thought it was pretty good. My rental arrived in the mail the day the nominations were announced, which was pretty good timing.

Overall, I can't say I was that impressed. The plot is very spare ... it's really more of a vignette movie with a simple device that sets up the scenes. Mike Horner is a rich collector -- coins, insects, vintage costumes, cars -- who begins to "collect" scenes of sexual voyeurism. Jessica Drake is his procurer, formerly of collectibles, now of "perversions."

Pros: I like Drake more every time I see her (especially her ass). And if you like to see porn hotties elegantly dressed, from pretty polka-dot dresses to smart business suits to beautiful lingerie, this is a good movie for you. Good wardrobe is an Armstrong trademark and a strength of this movie.

*It's a good cast. I like to see Wicked use women other than the usual suspects (what, no Nicole Sheridan in this movie?) Nautica Thorn puts in a good performance in a three-way scene with Aria and Randy Spears. Lucy Thai looks great as usual. Olivia O'Lovely has a nice scene.

Cons: All the narrative comes in voice-over by Drake. The writing is a little unimaginative and cliched; Armstrong usually does better.

*Some of the scenes switch to black-and-white for brief periods for no reason other than forced artsiness. Lame. That doesn't help this movie escape an air of pretentiousness it fights a losing battle against.

While I'm at it, I may as well run down the nominations.

Best Film: It's not a deep field, and I've only seen three of the seven nominees, so it's probably deserving.

Best DVD: It's a two-disc set, and I only rented Disc 1, so I can't really say.

Best Actress (Drake): There's not a lot of acting, and the voice-over isn't so great. Thumbs down.

Best Non-Sex Performance (Mike Horner): After the first scene, in which he hams it up pretty grotesquely, he does little but sit around and peer over his glasses. Thumbs down.

Best Director, Film (Armstrong): I only saw one other nominee. Eh, why not.

Best Oral Scene, Film: Drake takes on three guys wearing African masks. We've seen things like that before. It's kind of an average scene, not bad, but nothing I'd give an award to.

Best Couples Scene, Film (Drake and Cheyne Collins): Again, I saw only one other nominee, and I never know what they mean by best couples scene. So why not.

Best Group Sex Scene, Film: Two scenes are nominated here. The Spears/Aria/Thorn scene was good but nothing special. A three-way with Drake, Lezley Zen and Armstrong was very good -- including Drake getting a DP with Zen using a strap-on in her ass while Armstrong anchors, and Zen being doubled-vaginaled by Armstrong and a dildo. It's legit.

Best Solo Sex Scene (Drake): I saw only two of the 12 nominees, and this one didn't really interest me much.

Best Screenplay, Film (Armstrong): I thought this was one of his weaker writing jobs. Depends on how much worse the competition was, I guess.

Best Art Direction, Film: It's up against two Blake movies I didn't see, which are probably nice, but this is a very nice-looking movie with some cool locations, props and costumes. Thumbs up.

Best Cinematography: Why not.

Best Editing: Well done, and with some occasional creativity in the tease sequences. Why not.

Best DVD Extras: Can't judge.

Best DVD Menus: No better than every other Wicked disc, as far as I can tell.

Best DVD Packaging: Dunno, I rented it.


More than you needed to hear, I'm sure.

Edited by - obibong on Nov 15 2004

Michael Saint
Photographer

Alexis Texas is always lovely
1062 Posts
2/01
Posted - Nov 17 2004 : 2:03AM
Obi -

Just watched this one last weekend myself. Your review was kind of "in-depth" so I won't respond to everything but...

It isn't a two disc set just one. I bought my copy.

I have't seen any of the other nominee's so I thought this one was great but like you said that would really depend on the competition.

First off I love jessica and she is a friend so you can imagine my opinion may be a little colored. That being said my honest opinion of this movie is...

It is one of the most beautifully shot movies I have seen in a long time. Everything is pretty much flawless and jessica looks even better than ususal.

I am not sure about the acting because as Obi said it is all done in VO. And Mike Horner rarely talks.

My problems with this movie:

The aformentioned switching between B&W and color in the jessica drake/Shy Love scene. I thought the B&W look was acceptable since they were talking about old film prints and the women looked great.

I liked jessica's DP scene but it just seemed to appear out of no where. There really was no set up leading to it. And Lezley DV was real but you can't really see it from the angle provided.

That being said I thought it was a great film. The script wasn't as ambitious as some of Mr Armstrongs previous works but still outstanding in all areas.

ObiBong
Senior Member

1162 Posts
12/02
Posted - Nov 17 2004 : 4:24AM
That's funny, I don't know what made me assume it was a two-discer, but you're right. Now I feel like an idiot because I already returned it and I didn't watch any of the extras.

Just going by what the listed features are, there's no way it should be up for Best DVD Extras, then. It just has the basic Wicked package that every new movie has, and no commentary. That's absurd.

Michael Saint
Photographer

Alexis Texas is always lovely
1062 Posts
2/01
Posted - Nov 19 2004 : 12:16AM
Obi -

I too found it kind of odd that a movie that both jessica and Brad seemed to put so much effort into didn't get a little bit better treatment in the DVD extra's department. Especially considering it as the only "film" they shot this year, I think.

ObiBong
Senior Member

1162 Posts
12/02
Posted - Nov 19 2004 : 12:36AM
It's probably dangerous to makes guesses based on parallels with mainstream, but maybe they just wanted to hurry the DVD out so that when it got all those nominations, it would be available. Last year, "Beautiful" didn't come out until a while after the awards, and maybe the heat had gone down a bit.

But I wonder if there are more than a couple of dozen people like me who even pay attention to shit like that. Which is sort of the point of that other thread.

 
Daniel Leslie Metcalf
Public Relations

Los Angeles CA
70 Posts
12/00
Posted - Dec 2 2004 : 4:24PM
Hi Obi and Lee,

I enjoyed reading your comments on this DVD. All PR hyperbole aside, I absolutely love The Collector. Personally speaking, it was Andrew Blake's Night Trips that lured me into a career in this industry back in 1989, and I'll always have a weakness for lush, shot-on-film vignette erotica that features beautiful women in elegant locales...

Regarding The Collector, we're delighted with 17 AVN noms it had received, and we've received great feedback on both the movie and its stylish, "shadow box" style DVD case.

I agree that the movie sorely needed an audio commentary, and it's my hope this is something that's addressed with a re-release or special edition down the line...

Thanks again, and I hope to see you both in Las Vegas next month!

Sincerely,
Daniel Metcalf
Wicked Pictures

Michael Saint
Photographer

Alexis Texas is always lovely
1062 Posts
2/01
Posted - Dec 4 2004 : 9:57AM
Obi,

I think this year I am going to keep a running list of movies that came out "after" the awards cut off because come next year I just won't remember which ones came out when.


Daniel,

I loved the "shadow box" design of the box. That was actually an extra I wish had been on the DVD. A little clip on how the box was designed and shot. I would have found it interesting but that is just me.




Jump To: