New Pornstar Interviews - [more]
Audrey Madison Interview

"I really want even more DPs and double anal. And more gangbang stuff."
All Forums > The Porn Pool > The Porn Pool Forum Page 530 > URGENT: Scottish Parliament To Ban ALL Adult Porn?
AuthorPost
struan
Member


SCOTLAND
242 Posts
8/02
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 6:46AM
(Only just found out about this; they seem to have sneaked it in during the run up to Christmas!)

Hot on the heels of the UK & Scottish Government’s proposals to criminalise the possession of so-called ‘extreme porn’, the Scottish Parliament’s equal opportunities committee has accepted a petition from the pro-censorship, extremist (so-called) feminist pressure group ‘Scottish Women Against Pornography’ (S.W.A.P), which asserts that ALL adult porn should be considered incitement to hatred against women, and therefore outlawed.

Scotsman newspaper

MelonFarmers (article titled “Nutters With hatred in mind…”

Sunday Mail newspaper


I suggest that anyone who is unhappy about this potential further repression, contact the relevant authorities to complain/express your concerns, e.g.

Cathy Jamieson MSP (Justice minister) – She would be responsible for the implementation of any legislation.

Cathy.Jamieson.msp@scottish.parliament.uk

Nichol Stephen MSP (Deputy First Minister, & leader of the Scottish Liberal Democrats)

Nicol.Stephen.msp@scottish.parliament.uk

Patrick Harvie MSP (Scottish Green Party) – convenor of the cross-party working group on Human Rights.-

Patrick.Harvie.msp@scottish.parliament.uk

Brian Monteith MSP (Independent) – Has previously expressed opposition to the ‘extreme porn’ proposals, as he seemingly believes that adults should be free to view whatever (consensual adult) material they wish.

Brian.Monteith.msp@scottish.parliament.uk


The contact details for your own, or any other MSP, can be found at:

MSP contacts

MSPs who are also Government ministers can also be contacted by emailing the following address and, presumably, putting it for the attention of the respective minister:

scottish.ministers@scotland.gsi.gov.uk


The Scottish Parliament’s website

The Scottish Government’s website


If you live in one of the other constituent countries of the UK, remember how repressive, illiberal & pro-censorship the incumbent Westminster Government has been (it is they who originated the ‘extreme porn’ proposals), and you can see that if anything were to happen in Scotland, how likely it would be for Westminster to try and extend it to the rest of the UK.

If you are lucky enough to live the in free world, please feel free to contact the Scottish authorities, perhaps to detail how adult entertainment is ‘regulated’ in your country etc.

If any pornstar ADT members feel the urge to convey their feelings toward, & experiences of, the industry, please feel free.

As usual, we are fighting an uphill struggle, but if we just sit back and do nothing, and S.W.A.P. get to impose their view on society at large, we could end up with the complete prohibition of ALL adult porn. As this petition first surfaced back in 2004, and was assumed to have ‘died a death’, but didn’t, as well as the biased comments from the committee’s convenor, this seems to be a potentially serious threat.

Remember also, this is an election year in Scotland, when politicians are at their most ‘receptive’ to the concerns of the electorate, whatever side of the argument they are on.


Edited by - struan on Jan 13 2007

RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 8:56AM
Shit. Where's Mel Gibson and his big mouth when you really need him?
gent82
New Member

Great Britain
5 Posts
6/06
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 9:28AM
Thanks for the heads-up, Struan.
I sure hope my so-called 'representatives' in the Welsh Assembly don't get any similar ideas. Knowing how illiberal and oppressive they and their Westminster counterparts can be, it's certainly possible.
Dracula
Member

Women's necks are too damned sexy for me!
756 Posts
3/06
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 11:42AM
I guess they won't be making any Girls Gone Wild videos over there anytime soon. Darn it!

Adult porn is the greatest thing to happen to this world since, well... dracula! :)

night_lick
Member

196 Posts
7/06
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 12:00PM
Well, I guess a new underground market will be starting if

their legislation passes. Downloading should do a brisk

business there.

 
junglew
Senior Member

1042 Posts
12/02
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 12:51PM
Hell, and I thought all the religious nuts took a boat over to the new world and set up shop. We have the bastards on the run over here and hope the same for you guys. My ancestors came from Scotland.
Wayne In Dallas
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 2:15PM
They're like roaches. You can never get rid of them for long. And everytime you start to relax, thinking they've gone, you walk into a room in the middle of the night, turn on a light and they scurry in all directions.
jackthetreacleeater
Senior Member

Shame on you!
2003 Posts
10/06
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 2:27PM
edited for inappropriate content - scipio

Edited by - scipio on 1/19/2007 8:03:04 AM

struan
Member

SCOTLAND
242 Posts
8/02
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 5:50PM
quote and response to it removed - scipio

BTW, I agree entirely about how repressive & illiberal the UK has become, but it wasn’t exactly a liberal utopia under Thatcher’s regime (who is English, I hasten to add), now, was it?


Edited by - struan on 1/13/2007 5:55:53 PM

Edited by - scipio on 1/19/2007 8:03:50 AM

struan
Member

SCOTLAND
242 Posts
8/02
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 6:11PM
Yes, the already healthy ‘black market’ will surely increase - R18 titles, as ‘classified’ by the BBFC, are still subject to considerable censorship, so some (many?) people try and source the uncensored originals, wherever they can.

As for downloading, I'm not sure – If the 'extreme porn' proposals go through, mere possession will make people liable to (upto) 3 years in prison, whereas existing censorship concerns distribution of material, so you can (currently) possess whatever (adult) material you wish. It’s one thing to risk the (relatively anonymous) purchase of ‘offending material’ in ‘hard copy’ form on the ‘black market’, but another thing entirely to download it, given the lack of privacy involved (monitoring & retention of surfing habits, emails etc.) – you may as well sign your own arrest warrant!

Edited by - struan on 1/13/2007 7:00:16 PM

struan
Member

SCOTLAND
242 Posts
8/02
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 6:26PM
You mean that you don't have room for anymore that we may wish to offload? Damn, that's that plan buggered, then!
Click to expand
junglew wrote:
We have the bastards on the run over here and hope the same for you guys.
Click to expand
Thanks for the encourgament.

I assume that now that the Republicans have lost Congress & the Senate, there may be light at the end of the tunnel over there?

Click to expand
junglew wrote:
My ancestors came from Scotland.
Click to expand
I'm guessing that you don't fancy a move to the 'old country', then?


Edited by - struan on 1/13/2007 6:32:48 PM

struan
Member

SCOTLAND
242 Posts
8/02
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 6:31PM
LOL

Too busy keeping his head down, I guess.

Joey Starr
Senior Member

Still wanking after all these years.
8082 Posts
10/00
Posted - Jan 13 2007 : 6:57PM
Run for the hills!
jackthetreacleeater
Senior Member

Shame on you!
2003 Posts
10/06
Posted - Jan 14 2007 : 4:01PM
irrelevent and inappropriate content removed - scipio

Edited by - scipio on 1/19/2007 8:05:16 AM

khyber
Member

197 Posts
5/06
Posted - Jan 14 2007 : 7:31PM
From the Scotsman article, it looks like they're going for the old line that Porn=Violence Against Women.

It's always hard to get a conclusive argument for or against this, but this research (link below), suggests that watching porno causes a decrease in the number of rapes.

link

 
AlexPanzer
Deactivated User

1593 Posts
6/03
Posted - Jan 14 2007 : 7:41PM
I bet that all those SWAP women are repulsive to look at.
scipio
Senior Member

1901 Posts
2/00
Posted - Jan 14 2007 : 11:14PM

Mod:
Here's your warning, mate.

Drop the bigoted language. Right now.

jackthetreacleeater
Senior Member

Shame on you!
2003 Posts
10/06
Posted - Jan 15 2007 : 11:31AM
Bigoted, I hardly think so.
Gabriel Nine
Senior Member

Firecracker
1273 Posts
8/01
Posted - Jan 15 2007 : 12:45PM
Mod:
smg4ever, it would be appreciated if you could please read the forum etiquette and try to abide by it when posting here.

Adult DVD Talk is an international community with readers across Europe as well as the USA, and the language you are using in your posts, specifically comments such as "influx of Eastern European scum", are extremely offensive to many readers, and significantly detract from Struan's worthy attempt to highlight the topic with which the thread is concerned.

Please stick to the topic in question.

chupacabras
Member

161 Posts
1/03
Posted - Jan 15 2007 : 7:01PM
Lots of quotes of the above excised stuff, and replies removed to keep the peace - scipio

Edited by - scipio on 1/19/2007 8:06:23 AM

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14596 Posts
3/02
Posted - Jan 15 2007 : 7:12PM
OK, this thread is done. Sorry about that struan, but nobody seems to be able to stay on topic anyway.
scipio
Senior Member

1901 Posts
2/00
Posted - Jan 19 2007 : 8:02AM
Mod
After some discussion with some forum members, and because the topic is a worthy one for discussion, I've decided to unlock this topic, with the caveat that people don't act immaturely and stay on the topic without insulting one another. You know, like the rest of the topics on this board.

With this in mind, I'm editing a number of posts to remove the offensive parts and argument, so that the topic may restart without new readers to it reacting to the closed issue of insults. There's already been someone warned, so I'm sure that person will respect the rules of this forum so that they may continue to be a happy member here.

Having said that though, I'll thank all members of ADT who particpate in this thread to stay on topic and avoid insulting one another or anyone else. It's a pretty important issue for a number of ADT's members, and ceratinly of interest to those outside of Scotland.

Derailment and insults will not be looked upon kindly. Thank you.

scipio


Edited by - scipio on 1/19/2007 8:08:10 AM

Robbie
Member

884 Posts
1/05
Posted - Jan 19 2007 : 9:58AM
Hi struan, did you see Red Road? I heard it won 5 Scottish Baftas. I will probably catch this on DVD at some point but I just wanted to say how odd it is that the censorship issue has come around again, in the same year that Scotland has produced its most sexually explicit mainstream/crossover film to date.
Lexi Bardot
Member

86 Posts
8/05
Posted - Jan 19 2007 : 2:08PM
thats nuts
chupacabras
Member

161 Posts
1/03
Posted - Jan 20 2007 : 5:42AM
I'm not too concerned yet - the petition dates from 2004. See the last update here.
Anyhoo, I don't think the Executive would be too keen to push this forward. I'm Scottish and live in one of the more conservative areas of Scotland, and even here i don't think they would get much public support for this.
 
struan
Member

SCOTLAND
242 Posts
8/02
Posted - Jan 20 2007 : 5:54PM
Thanks scipio, and everyone else involved in the decision to unlock this thread – much appreciated.
struan
Member

SCOTLAND
242 Posts
8/02
Posted - Jan 20 2007 : 6:20PM
I hope you are correct, but, as I mentioned in my original post, I would argue that the fact that the petition should have ‘died a death’, but hasn’t, means that it is all the more worrying. In addition, the biased comments from the committee’s convenor do not give much hope for a fair hearing:-

“Elaine Smith, MSP for Coatbridge and Chryston, said: "We need to hear from academics who work in this field about whether they think pornography is harmful and how serious a problem it might be”.

"We don't expect any of them to say it is a good thing so the next question will be what we can do about it. There are those who say it should be banned completely."

I think it is better to potentially overreact now, by expressing opinions, submitting complaints, lobbying etc., before something happens; if any further momentum gets behind it, there could be no stopping it.

KaylanNicole_fan
Member

542 Posts
2/06
Posted - Jan 21 2007 : 1:19PM
You know what I'd like to know ? How would the people who want a prohibition get their porn ? They would have to get it in an illegal way ! No one can tell me that none of them who are making the laws watch porn.
Well, I thought Europe and the world are moving into the future. But it seems we're moving backwards !

stickybelly
Member

16 Posts
10/06
Posted - Jan 21 2007 : 7:07PM
I'm not sure how they would enforce it... But remember that Harriet Harman, who hopes to become deputy leader of the Labour Party after Blair buggers off, responded to the Ipswich murders by saying that all men who use prostitutes should be sent to prison. (A demand repeated in letters to newspapers by other interest groups.) A laughably ignorant view, if it weren't for the thought that she could actually have real influence in a few months time.
struan
Member

SCOTLAND
242 Posts
8/02
Posted - Jan 27 2007 : 5:34AM
I wasn’t aware of this movie – thanks for the heads-up.

The problem is, the ever smaller ‘moral minority’ just get ever more vocal in their attempts to impose their views on the rest of society; unfortunately, politicians keep listening to them .
This is why it is so important that as many people as possible, who hold opposing views, contact the relevant authorities to complain, expose the pro-censorship propaganda for the lies that they are, etc.




Jump To: