Reviewers Recommend
All For UsAll For Us - review by Captain Jack
Director: KGB
Starring: Richard Mann, Gianna Dior, Kylie Rocket, Dwayne Foxxx. Read review
All Forums > The Porn Pool > The Porn Pool Forum Page 649 > Why is Puking and Pee Common but Dirty A2M Isn't?
AuthorPost
Smartycookie2
Member


169 Posts
9/04
Posted - Feb 7 2005 : 8:41PM
So I guess in truth none of these fetishes would be considered "common" in American porn. However, I think if you do a bit of underground searching one can perceive a definite attempt to explore Pee and Puke themes in videos.

Pee seems to be the most common. Euro versions (see Max Hardcore) contain plenty of this, but even American versions of mainstream movies like Hustler's Barely Legal often have it. Even Pee Drinking is often brought into movies under the theme of orasmic "squirting." I remember seeing Alisha Klass drink a lot of squirts.

Puking seems to be a little less common but gaining fast. The directors of most of the "face fucking" blow job series' now tend to leave the puke scenes in their videos. Videos like Cocktails have people eating puke and Max Hardcore features sometimes have even more extreme content. I remember seeing a scene where Summer Luv's mouth is held open with a speculum and Catalina barfs into her open mouth.

Now many of you may find Pee and Puke gross. But suspend your revulsion for a second and answer me this. Is there really much difference between eating/drinking Pee or Puke and Dirty Ass to Mouth Sex?

Personally, I've never quite understood lots of the pee and puke stuff because it doesn't seem to have much connection to sex, and thus I don't see what turn on it is. I suppose I can understanding why people like seeing drinking of "orgasm squirt" or fucking a girls head until she pukes. This isn't my cup of tea but at least it has some sort of connection to sex. However, there's a huge amount of material (in lots of mainstream American porn) featuring simple peeing and puking (on people). I'm not quite sure what the attraction of this is.

In the end I assume that the attraction of Pee, Puke, and anything having to do with scat is a combination of a "dirtyness" and a "humiliation" fetish. They all fill the same niche, though in my opinion some do it better than others.

At any rate, it seems to me that dirty ass to mouth sex (as in ass to mouth action where the girl's bung hole wasn't entirely cleaned out ahead of time) is a lot less extreme than a lot of the pee and puke stuff out there. This is particularly true in the context of all the regular ATM that already exists.

So what are so many mainstream american porn directors focusing on pee and puke, but none of them focusing specifically on Dirty A2M? Max Hardcore for instance. He does all sorts of extreme stuff with pee and puke, but has he ever done a dirty A2M scene on purpose? Not that I know of. Is there something about the porn director psychological profile that just gravitates toward pee and puke fetishes?

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14595 Posts
3/02
Posted - Feb 7 2005 : 8:48PM
Greed.
Loraine
Senior Member

1559 Posts
3/04
Posted - Feb 8 2005 : 12:55AM
Maybe it's about risk minimisation? You know a crappy ass can be unpredictable, perhaps even unreliable, not to mention potentially unpleasant.

Smartycookie2wrote

A fetish for words that start with "P" ?
MASAMUNE
Senior Member

1452 Posts
12/04
Posted - Feb 8 2005 : 1:30AM
peeing and puking i can bear.... . i doubt i could bear dirty ass to mouth...

plus, you can get really really sick from that, the others you dont....

Darth-Morpheous
Deactivated User

1701 Posts
3/02
Posted - Feb 8 2005 : 11:49AM
I don't think there is that much "dirty ass to mouth" other than some behind the scenes outtakes. I am totally not into the peeing or puking. I hate stuff that is meant solely to degrade the women. The hardcore anal stuff with A2M is sexy to me because it all falls under the umbrella of anal play or Ass worship. In a recent scene from Perfect Specimens 2 with Jules Jordan and Christy Lee(my pick for scene of the year), there was lots of rimming by both parties and both did A2M from Christy of course. It wasn't "dirty A2M" or anything that was meant purely to degrade Christy. It was just good ole fashion anal fun. I hope to see more of this kind of hardcore but I won't bother seeing stuff from Manuel Ferrera, Erik Everhard, Brandon Irons, or other directors that shoot the real rough stuff with all the spitting, slapping etc. I don't have anything against that stuff but it just doesn't turn me on.

Darth-Morpheous
adultdetective.com

 
Kperv
The Cuddler

*struck
(She slipped)

1818 Posts
1/04
Posted - Feb 8 2005 : 12:08PM
Constipated?
Can Poo then be far behind?
Loraine
Senior Member

1559 Posts
3/04
Posted - Feb 8 2005 : 5:30PM
Kperv wrote
Well, I guess it's this very unpredictability that I'm alluding to K. As always in any life endeavour, just because you can, doesn't mean you should.
sir wankalot
Member

UK
904 Posts
5/03
Posted - Feb 10 2005 : 8:16PM
Is there a big enough market for dirty A2M?

Actually......there probably is.

Fockwolfe
Member

104 Posts
9/04
Posted - Feb 11 2005 : 5:17PM
I'd pay $200 for a well made dirty A2M vid.
scipio
Senior Member

1901 Posts
2/00
Posted - Feb 11 2005 : 7:01PM
Isn't scat play considered "illegal" in the US? Or at least considered one of the thngs covered by the "we don't do that because we'll be busted and shut down" legal advice clause?

That might be your answer right there.

scipio

jamesn
Senior Member

Cambridge, MA
750 Posts
1/04
Posted - Feb 12 2005 : 12:56AM
dirty a2m is stupid, there's some really, really nasty shit living in shit. like send you to the hospital and maybe kill you shit. there's a reason we eat polish sausages at sporting events not our feces...
skronker
Notable Legendary Icon

Scopophiliac
9780 Posts
9/02
Posted - Feb 12 2005 : 1:04AM
You see it often enough. Except most girls stop the scene when they glimpse their breakfast dangling from the hot fuck sausage.

I'm not real excited by girls puking, but I guess everyone has their fetish. Me, I just enjoy watching hot girls get off having hot sex. Deliver that, and I'm a happy spanker.

sir wankalot
Member

UK
904 Posts
5/03
Posted - Feb 12 2005 : 6:45PM
Really??

Right....i better get started then!

Malachi Ecks
Member

Los Angeles
55 Posts
9/04
Posted - Feb 14 2005 : 5:19PM
Fockwolfe
Member

104 Posts
9/04
Posted - Feb 14 2005 : 5:27PM
Awesome! $300 to see Isabel Ice instead of the toys!
 
Gunzo
Senior Member

1377 Posts
2/05
Posted - Feb 14 2005 : 6:31PM
Puking makes me remember that jackass-episode where one guy eats eggs and the rest of the recipe and then pukes it all up... only to fry it and then eating it again...
So I doubt puking will ever turn me on...

Pee and bukkake are similar I think, and that I can live with. It's sort of disgusting... but not too disgusting. If you were payed enough you would probably do that... but shit? Maybe if I could live wealthy for the rest of my life then... if that...

Dirty A2M is shit eating... and that reminds me of 'What to do in Denver when you're dead'... which is a great flick... but it doesn'r really turns me on.

However, I'm sure there must be some dirty A2M out there - if not I guess there's a market opening!

DavidK126
Member

79 Posts
4/04
Posted - Feb 16 2005 : 2:42AM
Smartycookie has raised the topic of dirty A2M in other threads on this site in addition to this thread. I think that there is a market for virtualy everything porn, and I would be astonished if a dirty A2M production would not be profitable for its producers, particularly when it might be possible to employ premium pricing, as is mentioned by other posters to this thread. As many people who have worked in various capacities in fetish areas recognize, consumers of unusual fetishes expect to pay more for the products or services that address their fetishes. With premium pricing, one would hope that the female dirty A2M porn performers would be properly compensated, too.



Jump To: