I'm in the process of building a new pc and was going to buy a pentium 4 2.4 cpu for it , but i was talking to a guy in a computer shop and he was telling me that the AMD cpu's are far superior to Intel.Has anyone got any views on the subject?
[Link]
DenverDon Benevolent
Firmly Embedded in Depravity 5914 Posts 7/02
Posted - May 26 2003 : 7:08AM
pornlord, I prefer the Intel.
Years ago we experienced a few 'glitches' with the AMD. The concentration seemed to center upon CPU speed rather than overall compatability.
I do want to emphasize that I am talking 8-10 years ago. I don't know if those problems have been solved, but I just stuck with Intel.
First things first, AMD chips are not "far superior" than Intel chips. Having said that, I've bought AMD for the last 3 or 4 chips I've bought. Intel makes faster chips now and have better bus speeds and generally you can overclock them without much trouble. The AMD chips run much hotter so you can't really squeeze any more performance out of the Athlon chip, but they're cheaper. If you want the best chip out there, you have to go Intel -- if you want a chip for the price of the P4 2.4GHz, I'd go with the AMD Athlon XP 2600+
Given the current state of technology and the current price structure, the Intel P4/533 2.4GHz ~ 2.8GHz and the P4/800 2.4GHz processors using either the i845PE or the i865PE chipsets make the most sense (the i875P chipset is very slightly more powerful [about 3~5%] if you have dollars to spare.) RAMbus memory is essentially dead - it just doesn't know it yet. Go with DDR333 PC2700 or DDR400 PC3200 memory, depending on your motherboard and wallet. Check out this thread: Dream System
Thanks for the replies.I'm sure I'll buy a pentiun 4.This is a bundle of hardware which i found on a web site here in the UK which seems good for the money.
If you plan to do any gaming than the GeForce4XM is not a good choice. You better go with a Ti4200 which does not cost much more! I also have the GF4MX
The SiS 648 is an interesting chipset; however, it hasn't proved out in performance terms. Motherboards based on the i845PE are similarly priced (actually, should be dropping in price now that the i865PE is available) and are more capable. It is true that the i845PE does not support 8X AGP (only 4X); however, that is much less a consequence in terms of total system performance than chipset and bus performance. If you want 8X AGP as well, look seriously at a motherboard based on the i865PE chipset.
If u are getting that P4, then i would NOT buy that graphics card. your system will be too bottle necked. i suggest a ATI Radeon 9700 PRO (or 9500) , becuase it carries DDR memory too and is 128Mb, this co-responds to your PC2700 RAM and works along side it really well.
What are u going to be doing with your PC ? I will help u where i can
Cheers
------------------ Regards and Thanks ShiWarrior - - Minka Fan - -
Thanks for the reply ShiWarrior The pc will eventually used for video editing , music , no games. The Group of hardware that i listed in the earlier posting all comes Together fromX-Case.co.uk,It seemed like a good price just to get the pc up an running , but i would be up grading the graphic card at some point. At the moment i'm just looking around at various components , either i'll buy the comonents as a bundle or i'll buy them all seperatly at various times.
Pentium is more expensive than AMD. But I think you'll run into fewer software compatiblity problems down the road.
"There are three ways to get to the top of the ladder: talent, luck, or being an asshole by stepping on someone's head. Most people on the top of the ladder are neither talented nor lucky." - Unknown
AMD's CPUs are not even faster - more cost effective (by a small margin these days) - but not faster. Given the heat issues and the cost of "high-end" cooling hardware, price-wise, AMD is essentially essentially neck and neck with similar speed 533MHz FSB Intel processors; however, the new 800MHz FSB Intel CPUs pull well ahead.
I've always used Pentiums for general computing use. I just purchased a new P4 system (Dell Dimension 8300) with the 875P chipset and the 800MHz Front Side Bus that I intend to use mostly for video editing. The system was just about $1100 with a coupon and free shipping.