^Why? I mean what would be the point in trying to prove something that by your own you think is overrated. You might have a better chance of getting into a discussion if you argued that the oversaturation of the market has made anal porn less interesting but then again it would be subjective.
I think all-anal scenes are boring and terrible. I don't mind it when some is mixed in with vaginal sex.
[Link]
Lezzyist Deactivated User
Make Porn Erotic Again 1736 Posts 9/19
Posted - Oct 24 2021 : 1:33AM
No one can "prove" that anal is overrated. I agree though lmao. But I don't get ALOT of stuff porn is pushing the most; high schoolers, incest, encouraging people to have sex after they say no at first, et cetera, so anal is really par for the course.
I rarely watch scenes without anal intercourse. Always the most thrilling part of a scene imo.
Only with a new actress I make an exception to follow her way to the first anal scene (when this hope turns out to be false, I lose interest in following her after a while).
I like porn and the Golden Age of Porn 1947 Posts 9/21
Posted - Oct 24 2021 : 10:40AM
you speak the truth but that's all people watch here. If she doesn't do anal, she's labeled as boring. I would like more in my porn but people just want anal and more anal. Gonzo is overdone and boring, most women don't like anal sex and gapping is stupid. Anal isn't hardcore it's vanilla as fuck. Yes, anal is very much overrated
[Link]
1976 Deactivated User
122 Posts 6/21
Posted - Oct 24 2021 : 11:09AM
^ exactly my point. There's already people screaming "lock this thread" simply because I posted it. If you don't like it, simply don't engage and this thread will disappear into obscurity if it has no discussions or activity.
IMHO all this incessant gaping and an over abundance of sites specifically focused on one activity, makes it quite overrated to say the least, especially when we know the pay for anal scenes is supposedly much higher. That extra money could be spent elsewhere. It would also help if anal sex is just considered another vanilla sex act and not the only focus on the scene.
People wanted this thread locked because you did not qualify your opinion until you made this reply. People WANT to hear your opinion and discuss it, but your first post was akin to someone going to a movie reviewer who only writes, "it sucks". Had you opened with this reply, you would've gotten far more positive responses.
From a business-side, anal scenes have been the biggest return on investment for me, and for a lot of people. Anal creampies even more so. Whatever people may think of anal being vanilla, it's still taboo enough that it generates lots of interest.
From a production side, it's a nightmare. Fewer girls do it, and you get many instances of cancellations or backing out. There's also the occasional "accident".
I agree with the gape thing. Don't understand it at all, but Greg Lansky once told me that's the money shot and indeed if you look at the Tushy thread on this forum, a lot of people praise "good gapes" (I don't know what that means).
I like porn and the Golden Age of Porn 1947 Posts 9/21
Posted - Oct 24 2021 : 12:57PM
God, I can't believe this industry is still doing anal creampies. This industry is built on following trends and only producing what's marketable. Yes, I understand that's what sells but this industry has lost all originality and eroticism because of it. Anal gap and anal creampies(very risky) aren't sexy or erotic.
It's not an either or thing. To me sometimes anal sex enhances the scene, sometimes it doesn't add anything and sometimes it actually hurts the scene if the girl isn't comfortable with it. To each their own but the people who dismiss a scene completely just because it doesn't have anal I'll never agree with because anal doesn't automatically make a scene better. I'll never quite understand a person rather seeing a crappy poorly shot anal scene with no chemistry from the performers over a well shot, well performed scene just because it doesn't have anal.
It's a strange thing from a performer standpoint also. We've seen many, many, many times...okay let's be honest...every time...A girl gets hounded to do anal and she finally decides to do it and makes the announcement. She names the performer and the studio she's going to do it for and almost without fail there will be those who bitches about her choices. They don't want to hear about a nice first anal scene to ease the girl in. They want the girl to team up with the guy with the biggest junk and the most extreme studios right out the gate. Then there's also "it's never good enough" attitude. The poor girl has finally done anal and thinks her fans will be happy...but no. They immediately start requesting for her to work with the biggest guys, then start asking for DPs, then want a gangbang, then double anal. Then that's all they want to see from that girl. I'm not saying everyone wants that but a big part of the audience seems to.
And lastly, there are the girls who become know for their extreme anal antics. With those performers for me at least, it gets to the point they do the extreme anal circus act scenes so often it becomes mundane and par for the course. That's not to put down the women who do that stuff and often do it well but for the fans who only want to watch that stuff I don't know how it can't start to become bland fairly fast. Extreme porn girl just did a must see 3 man DVP, DAP, scene for this studio. Hey, same extreme porn girl just did a must see DVD, DAP, at that studio. Great news! Same extreme porn girl is going to going to Europe to shoot a 4 man gangbang DVP, DAP scene! I'm not putting these performances down I like to watch them from time to time. But a steady diet of this stuff is what leads you to wanting to see gaping, rosebud(I think that's what they're called) and all the other strange stuff that directors have to throw in to try and make things different and more exciting.
Anal sex porn may not be overrated but I think it can be overdone and it can be a crutch to try prop up an otherwise lackluster scene.
[Link]
1976 Deactivated User
122 Posts 6/21
Posted - Oct 24 2021 : 2:11PM
^ I agree with your point that sometimes anal sex can enhance a scene. But when they entirely of the scene is focused on anal penetration and the plethora of sites that are specifically focused on anal insertions is why I believe it is very overrated and overdone.
^^ I agree to most of your points as I prefer what is nowadays called vanilla scenes and not the extreme ass pounding or dap, tap and whatever is demanded by many fans from their favorite performers. I don´t feel any pleasure seeing a performer suffering respectively unfomfortable with the scene.
I like anal , but even more so DP . However the trend from the recent years to include prola.se and 0 % pussy scenes in BBG scenes ( only DAP instead of DP ) disturbs me a lot .
Similarly the sites which only show close-up anal penetration without showing the whole body ( especially feet and legs ) are boring . However these sites feature sometimes double-licking on pussy and ass , which gives it some variety .
Ideally , a good 1on1 anal scene for me is not 100 % anal , but mixes in some vaginal also . In this way during vaginal cowgirl I can imagine that a 2nd guy comes in from behind into the ass to form a Dp , similarly during reverse cowgirl anal penetration I can imagine a 2nd guy coming into the pussy frontally to form a reverse DP .
I´d like to see all my favourite models do anal , if possible ( but not required to advance in my ranking ) ; so even while I complain about the current state of affairs I can not say that anal is overrated .
Notwithstanding the fact that you haven't answered my question, your statement that there are way too many anal sites rather undermines your thesis. The reason why there are so many sites is because the demand exists in the first place. If the demand wasn't there, these sites would not be successful in attracting the numbers they do. Clearly the punters that pay to visit these sites do so in belief and expectation that they are satisfied with their content and ergo do not think it is overrated.
[Link]
aurecius Deactivated User
344 Posts 10/08
Posted - Oct 27 2021 : 1:43PM
Those statements I 100% agree on. I like watching a great anal scene but if the chemistry in the scene is lacking or the performer is not 100% into it I can feel it as I belive most of the other porn fans do. I like it when the girl is enjoying it and when there is hardcore pounding included in it. I do not like if the scenes are 100% anal or 100% DAP. There are cases where i watched the scene and enjoyed it just by a liztle bit although girls where not much into it. Those are the scenes where my favourite pornstars did anal and i really wanted to see them do anal scenes. But if I am not that much into her and the anal is lame without chemistry i rather skip it.