Taboo 1: my first porn I watched (prior to that it was a lot of girly magazines). I have 2-3 copies of it in my collection today.

All American Girls 2: In Heat : my first VHS rental (and re-rent over & over). I have it on DVD & watched it the other day in fact.

Gang Bang Girl 1: my first time watching "raunch" (gang bang, DP, cum drinking out of condoms). This had it all.

Miami Spice 1 & Sex Asylum 2: Sheer Bedlam : both movies have wall-to-wall great sex with all-star casts. No fast forwarding needed.

[Link]

Your mention of GBG 1 gave me a chuckle. I'm also a fan of the older GBG editions (back when they were in their heyday - there are new ones coming out but they don't have the heat of the older ones) and #1 sticks out for me for the cheesy acting and big hair. But the sex was hot, and it was among the very first gang bang movies I had ever seen.

[Link]