All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 50 > Can I burn dvd movies with a DVD-RW?
AuthorPost
maquiavelli
Member

90 Posts
4/05
Posted - May 13 2005 : 2:11AM
Anybody knows?
GonzoAnalFan
Member

700 Posts
6/04
Posted - May 13 2005 : 3:26AM
You mean CSS protected mainstream movies??
maquiavelli
Member

90 Posts
4/05
Posted - May 13 2005 : 3:46AM
what are CSS protected mainstream movies? and how do you find out if such movies have this kind of protection?

I mean if I go to out there and buy a DVD movie, can I later on burn a copy with a DVD-RW?

GonzoAnalFan
Member

700 Posts
6/04
Posted - May 13 2005 : 4:00AM
Well..not legally.

(& this thread will likely be locked if I elaborate further )

juha
Senior Member

2752 Posts
3/05
Posted - May 13 2005 : 5:58AM
Nearly all mainstream films and a growing number of adult films are CSS copy protected. There are other copy protections out there but CSS is the most often used.

I don't know about the USA.
But in Germany its totally illegal even for home use.

The usual software like Nero or CloneDVD doesn't copy protected discs. And software to crack CSS is illegal.

 
sir wankalot
Member

UK
904 Posts
5/03
Posted - May 13 2005 : 3:35PM
Can you back up dvds you already own?

BigBobxxx
Senior Member

2681 Posts
5/04
Posted - May 13 2005 : 4:45PM
In the United States, making a backup copy of copyrighted material that you own for your own personal use is legal and considered "fair use" (provided you retain rightful ownership of the original item).
juha
Senior Member

2752 Posts
3/05
Posted - May 14 2005 : 4:06PM
Last year the copyright laws were changed due to massive pressure by the film and music industry.
Now in Germany you are only allowed to back up your own DVDs if you don't have to crack a copy protection to make a back up.

juha
Senior Member

2752 Posts
3/05
Posted - May 14 2005 : 4:08PM
even if its copy protected?
BigBobxxx
Senior Member

2681 Posts
5/04
Posted - May 14 2005 : 4:50PM
Yes and no.
Copyright wise, no problem.
BUT, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act makes it a crime "to circumvent anti-piracy measures built into most commercial software."
Digital Millennium Copyright Act highlights

So, while the concept of "fair use" is long established, nothing says the copyright owner(s) need to make it easy to do. Making a "fair use" copy is legal... but defeating the copyright protection measures to do so is now a crime.

Interestingly enough, this is the polar opposite thinking when compared to "head shops" and drugs. Selling bongs and roach clips was legal, yet their intended use (i.e. taking drugs) was against the law.

Bill All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

5334 Posts
6/00
Posted - May 14 2005 : 5:59PM
Once again, discussion of copying DVD's is not permitted at ADT. If you want to find information on this topic, I suggest searching the rest of the Internet for anwswers because they won't be found here.

I'm locking this thread.




Jump To: