Almost all creampies follow the same formula: missionary position with the guy just barely penetrating the girl, so that his cum will quickly leak out.
I'm looking for something very different: the girl in cowgirl (either forward or reverse) position, banging away at the guy as he cums, and continuing to bang him until his cock goes limp, as his cum runs out of her pussy and down his shaft. I think that's far hotter than any staged creampie.
Reading this thread made me think of the scene with Jill Kelly and Julian. She rides him cowgirl and keeps stroking up and down as she talks nasty in her husky voice until he explodes into her. She never stops riding even as the cum is dripping down. It was hot. You guys know the one I'm referring to?
I can't read this thread without thinking about cowpies. Wikipedia link here for you city folk.
But anyhow to stay on topic I think I see just as many doggie style cream pies as missionary. It seems like the reverse cowgirl would be an obvious way to show creampies as the guy could even lift and spread the girls legs after he pops.
Call me old fashioned, but I don't want to see any guy eat his own cum (or anyone else's cum for that matter!).
I definitely prefer the guy to cum in the girl and for her to keep riding him as his cum oozes down his shaft... VERY sexy!!! In general, I love it when the pounding continues long after the guy ejaculates... and the visual of his cock getting covered in thicker and thicker gobs of his cum, and it starting to pool on the base of his shaft, is about as good as it gets in porn.
Personally I'd prefer normal cowgirl over reverse cowgirl... if the girl is good with her pelvic thrusts (April Summers/Flowers raised this to a high art form) and has a great ass (April again is the gold standard), there's nothing better than her slamming her pelvis against his rod as the hot white goo drips out.
I'd love it even more if she kicks it up a notch after he cums... really slams her pussy against his hips and gives his spent cock no quarter.