Reviewers Recommend
Innocent Girlfriend Rewards Him With PussyInnocent Girlfriend Rewards Him With Pussy - review by GregtheBaka
Director: KGB
Starring: Nick, Juniper Ren. Read review
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 15 > External Hard Drive Recommendations?
AuthorPost
Midnight Max
Deactivated User

And put an end to the Chicago-style Thuggery
678 Posts
3/08
Posted - Dec 27 2011 : 12:00AM
Any good External Hard Drive recommendations? Looking for a good 1TB model to save videos on and would appreciate some feedback from you tech-savvy guys and gals. Thanks
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Dec 27 2011 : 6:54AM
I use Seagate FreeAgent Go hard drives, which I've always been very happy with. You can buy them on Amazon in various size increments. Last time I bought one (I have 5), 640 GB was the largest storage I could get and still power the device directly from USB. Beyond that, it seems like you need to have an external power source. But, that purchase was 7-8 months ago and the technology may have improved since then.
One feature you may want to consider is USB 3.0, which is supposed to offer really improved data transfer speeds vs. USB 2.0.
Harry Joystick
Member

740 Posts
8/02
Posted - Dec 27 2011 : 8:56AM
I've owned a Seagate Free Agent 1 TB USB powered external hard drive for almost 2 years now and am pretty happy with it. It's only USB 2.0 though. Seagate now makes a 1.5 TB USB 3.0 USB powered external HD.
I buy either Seagate or Western Digital brands because they are the most popular but that's just me. Western Digital HDs are usually more expensive. As Porn Scout said, USB 3.0 would be good to have even if you don't need it right now. Chances are it will come in handy in the future.
Midnight Max
Deactivated User

And put an end to the Chicago-style Thuggery
678 Posts
3/08
Posted - Dec 28 2011 : 12:02AM
Thanks for the feedback, guys. I had been looking at a Toshiba Canvio Basics 1TB because of all the high ratings on Amazon.com.
Harri Patel
Senior Member

#SDNY he's all yours. -- Michael Steele
5110 Posts
3/03
Posted - Dec 28 2011 : 1:21AM
Really? I'm way less right wing than you seem to be, and I still won't buy anything those bastards make.
 
Midnight Max
Deactivated User

And put an end to the Chicago-style Thuggery
678 Posts
3/08
Posted - Dec 28 2011 : 3:56AM
I never knew this- though the right-wing stuff is a slapped on label from a certain handful of turd posters who I like to give shit to because they're amazing hypocrites.
Funny thing and FWIW-
I believe in Gay Marriage, I'm pro-choice, I'm for the legalization of Mary Jane, I believe in the separation of Church and State, I believe in Evolution. I did not vote for John McCain and I do not listen to Rush Limbaugh. I feel I have no candidate to vote for this next November who best represents me. My favorite comedian is Lewis Black and John Cusack is one of my favorite actors. I'm a Los Angeles Laker fan.
I believe in no new taxes, no new laws, a strong military, conservative spending and I could give a shit less about foreign policy when our backyards are so fuckin dirty. I believe in the right to own as many handguns and rifles as one should so choose, I believe in the death penalty, I'm a big fan of The Duke and I hate Bill Maher. I'm guessing it's this second portion of my beliefs which the powers that be find to be so distressing. :)
Joey Starr
Senior Member

Still wanking after all these years.
8082 Posts
10/00
Posted - Dec 28 2011 : 1:26PM
I own two La Cie external drives. One I bought years ago stll going strong and another one bought last year.
We also have La Cie external drives at work (I work in IT), we used to have problems with a shitty brand before that and since we switched to La Cie, not a single problem.
Don't know anything about their politics though...
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Dec 30 2011 : 8:47AM
The first WD external drive I bought a few years ago started making strange clicking noises shortly after I bought it. I foolishly kept it and it has continued to make that irritating noise in the ensuing years. It hasn't died though.
I think WD drives are better now than they used to be.
jayo All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

2117 Posts
7/04
Posted - Dec 30 2011 : 12:07PM
I used to buy bare WD drives for various systems and they were always fine.
I bought a WD MyDisk and it failed within 6 months. I lost everything. The guy I took it to says the little controller boards inside are the weak point, and they often fail.
On the other hand, I gave a close relative the same thing for her computer, and it works perfectly. It's been well over a year. So go figure.
I recently bought an external Seagate and it's been running fine (about 3 months).
Harri Patel
Senior Member

#SDNY he's all yours. -- Michael Steele
5110 Posts
3/03
Posted - Dec 30 2011 : 2:08PM
^ If the controller fails, you can just take the drive itself out of the housing and put it in another one, or in a computer. No reason to think you lost everything unless the drive itself has somehow been damaged.
jayo All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

2117 Posts
7/04
Posted - Dec 30 2011 : 4:27PM
I actually did that. The HD itself has internal problems--I kept getting errors and faults, so it ended up being retired from service with the help of a heavy hammer.
This is a touchy spot with me. I paid for the drive so I'm out that. I opted to try to get the data rescued, which required breaking it out of the housing, which violated the warranty. They couldn't do it so I was out the money spent to attempt it. Then I bought a housing and the hard drive failed after a new low-level, partition and reformat, so I'm out that, too. (Though in theory I could use the housing for something else). It was a bad experience all the way 'round.
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Dec 31 2011 : 12:48AM
What I usually do when I buy a new drive is I fill it up by copying data onto it from another drive (without deleting the original data) and just let the drive sit with that data on it for a few weeks. Maybe even running an error scan on it or defragging it once a day in the meantime. Anything that puts it through it's paces. If it lasts a month under heavy use, it's less likely to fail. Or at least that's my reasoning.
norrinradd
Member

55 Posts
10/11
Posted - Jan 3 2012 : 9:01PM
This is my experience with externals so hopefully this helps. Video libraries grow and never get smaller and these new hd vids could be 2GB or bigger so you'll quickly outgrow any 1TB drive. I strongly advise getting a 2TB, but not the 3TB, I'll explain later. I currently have around 7TB accumulated over the past 10yrs.
I've had good luck with WD My Books but my 3TB crashed. Externals are basically hard drives in an enclosure and if it fails u can just remove it and put it in a new enclosure. Unfortunately I couldnt find a new enclosure for my 3TB so it was a total disaster. I've had other externals or even my desktop die and I've usually been able to recover all the data from the disks. Most of the time the enclosure breaks, not the drives.
As my library grew I just got more externals but ran out of usb ports + you'll need a power cord for each so I had a cable nightmare.
Lo and behold out came enclosures that could hold multiple hard drives. I bought a startech enclosure that can hold 4 ordinary drives yet it only has 1 usb & 1 power cord. U can pop drives in and out which is helpful if u want to consolidate or you get a new computer but want to keep the content from your old drive. So far the only downside is the fan can be a little noisy.
Organizing 7TB of porn is a different story but at least I have it accessible on one computer.
BYOB_Kenobi
Senior Member

“Life can only be understood backwards; but it must be lived forwards.” - Kierkegaard
2684 Posts
8/09
Posted - Jan 3 2012 : 11:40PM
I would go with Seagate or Western Digital.
I use Western Digital Passports HDs for work and have a few of them. The USB 3.0 >500GBs ones are great.
Stay away from LaCie drives. Had massive failures and lost lots of data that took me a week to recover (GetDataBack is life saver BTW) across 3 different LaCie drives (all 3 failed).
Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14594 Posts
3/02
Posted - Jan 4 2012 : 11:19AM
A couple of years ago I bought four WD10EACS drives, all within a few months of each other. Two of them are dead already so, even though the others have survived them by many months, I don't have a lot of faith in Western Digital, either.
I think that margins are so thin in the business that you really can't count on anybody over-engineering their product to make it last longer.
 
Midnight Max
Deactivated User

And put an end to the Chicago-style Thuggery
678 Posts
3/08
Posted - Jan 4 2012 : 11:39AM
Do you guys leave yours plugged into your PC's or do you use them for "tucked-away" storage? Are some of the aforementioned "failures" happening with those being used as "tucked-away" storage? Sounds like I need to buy multiple modules from different makers...
jayo All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

2117 Posts
7/04
Posted - Jan 4 2012 : 10:10PM
I leave mine plugged in but turned off. I just spin it up when I want it.
BYOB_Kenobi
Senior Member

“Life can only be understood backwards; but it must be lived forwards.” - Kierkegaard
2684 Posts
8/09
Posted - Jan 4 2012 : 11:48PM
I've had failures using older gen WD drives. I wanna test Seagate "Passport like" drives next, but so far my WD Passport USB 3.0 has had no problems.
Unfortunately, I think there are many failures in HDs across many manufacturers, but some more than others.
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Jan 8 2012 : 12:24PM
Well, they're a bit different I think but I have both a (newer) WD and a Seagate internal drive and the WD seems more refined. The Seagate is noisier and makes weird sounds sometimes I never hear from the WD. I don't think this means the Seagate is inherently bad or unreliable. But it seems to me that the quieter drive is evidence of more thoughtful engineering. Which (I hope) translates to a smoother ride and better reliability.
I also have a 1 TB WD Mybook that I bought at Costco maybe 3 years ago. It's been going along just fine. I even took it apart out of curiosity and it went back together pretty easy. I think (but can't remember for sure) that I even put the drive in my tower for a couple of days so it is, apparently, just an internal drive in the Mybook case.
Edited by - randomprecision on 1/8/2012 12:30:09 PM
GhostMonkey
Member

18 Posts
3/11
Posted - Feb 17 2012 : 1:57AM
Just a note/warning with seagate. You don't get the full amount of space that it says on the box. Usually, it's 20 GB less. I bought a 320, and it only holds about 280.
Harri Patel
Senior Member

#SDNY he's all yours. -- Michael Steele
5110 Posts
3/03
Posted - Feb 17 2012 : 4:03AM
That's not unique to Seagate. All the manufacturers quote the unformatted size of the drive in the marketing process.
Edited by - Harri Patel on 2/17/2012 4:05:24 AM
Opium
Deactivated User

300 Posts
3/12
Posted - Mar 21 2012 : 8:28AM
i currently am using a very old PC. i also pretty much have my external HD on all the time so i can access porn when i'm um, in the mood. if my PC were to crash while my external HD was on would any of my files get corrupted? i've been told by various people i should be safe unless i was playing a video or audio file when the crash happens and even then "most likely" everything should be OK. any truth to this?
Drew Black
broken crankshaft

8009 Posts
9/99
Posted - Mar 21 2012 : 9:20AM
If you're using a MAC vs. a PC you will get different usable storage amounts.



Jump To: