Shot at Home has the biggest variety of amateur girls, and just started a monthly "club" (or whatever you call it) as well as selling DVDs. I'd try them first just due to their variety (and because they have some darn good movies too!).
Tied for second would be Pixie's Emporium (which just sells DVDs IIRC) and Marie Madison (which does DVDs, videos, and VOD). Pixie's has the younger, fun feel while Marie's movies are often darker and more professional.
Coming in at fourth, at least for me, is Hal Maroon. He has a decent variety, but often lacks a bit for me by being a little too into himself. I've found a few of his movies where he was mouthing off like he was channeling Wesley or Cuntree Pipes, and that was just with sitting behind the camera.
I've reviewed stuff from each of these companies, and you can find them using the review search mechanism.
"Vegetarianism for me is about saying ‘yes’ to things - even meat." - Coupling
Many "amateur" sites lure you in with he promise of amateur content. You are then confronted with the same old same old girls, who've taken it up the ass on a hundred other websites.
The girls at amateur-facials.com seemed to be (with the exception of the extra content they have on their site) mostly exclusive to that website.
The halcyon days of true amateur porn are over; now, as soon as a girl has a scene under her belt, she bolts for the big commercial releases, and you'll see her in "The 1,000 Dude Cum Slam, Part 450."
I know you asked for WEBSITES, but I will respectfully suggest my DVD's at profanepirate.com. I cast the videos with a mix of pro girls and amateur girls and couples, but I had a "No silicone/no plastic surgery" policy, and the pro girls that you do see in the videos are A. very very real (they pretty much all had real orgasms) and B. They are girls that you don't see in a lot of mainstream porn. Pale, often very slender or very zaftig little vixens. So anyways, click the link... at least nobody will have fake tits.
To piggyback on this topic, I want to know if any one knows of any amateur sites to buy compilations of what they have on thier sites I will use: this as an example.
phatbasey, IIRC, Shot at Home has a few samplers. They also normally include about a half hour of bonus footage showing stuff from other releases. Hal Maroon also has a couple compilation DVDs. I can't think of one from Pixie's Emporium (I'm sure Mandi* will bitchslap me down, I mean correct me, if I'm wrong).
"Vegetarianism for me is about saying ‘yes’ to things - even meat." - Coupling
For those interested, later this week I'll be submitting reviews for a few of Hal Maroon's DVDs. I'm going to try to get Pixies and Shot at Home in later this month...
"Vegetarianism for me is about saying ‘yes’ to things - even meat." - Coupling
Just got the SAH e-mail back after the e-mail crash. Here's the relevant parts:"Vegetarianism for me is about saying ‘yes’ to things - even meat." - Coupling
I also recommend Pixie's Emporium. They are constantly having sales that basically feel like you're stealing from them.
I just ordered 4 of their premium DVD's last weekend, and I only paid about $28! And that includes shipping. They have some 50% off thing going on often.
At those prices, I don't know how they make money, but I'll certainly keep buying from them.
i know that all the girls here arent complete amateurs because ive seen at least one of them in a few dvds but most of these girls ive never seen. the site is all girl solo scenes too so if youre not into that type of thing dont bother. otherwise... enjoy!
I've just been doing a little exploring on the Club Shot at Home site I posted the e-mail about above. Granted, it's the first pay site I've checked out, but I'd definitely recommend it. Andy keeps the regular Shot at Home site pretty friendly, and I think he made the club site even more so. There's plenty of photo galleries and clips, and Andy seems pretty good about updating things in the site. For fans of Shot at Home's movies there's several club exclusive clips of lost footage, as well as footage of upcoming releases. It nicely breaks up the footage too between the UK stuff (which I think is leaving the site fairly soon), homemade videos (real homemade stuff, not porn star with a guy who's fat, old, or both), lost footage, etc. If you're looking for an amateur pay site, check out Club Shot at Home.
"Vegetarianism for me is about saying ‘yes’ to things - even meat." - Coupling