Logo of Naughty America
Naughty America Movies
reviews | trailers | website
All Forums > The Porn Pool > How is Naughty America?
Page 1 of 27 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 13 > Last
AuthorPost
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Feb 21 2018 : 11:37PM
I'm mulling over a membership there. I like vanilla porn and the annual membership is super cheap, and I've never really heard people complain about NA the way they do about other sites. Also, the catalog is huge, so it seems almost like a can't miss proposition. But, you never know so may as well ask the community.
Some questions I have:
1) How reliable are they in their update schedule?
2) What level of quality are the downloaded scenes in terms of frame rate, bit rate, etc.?
3) Do they ever have technical issues and how responsive are they in addressing these? For example, corrupted downloads, etc.
4) How is their customer service?
5) Is there anything that's just flat-out annoying to you as a member? For instance, I have Brazzers and I could frankly do without the whole comedy-porn shtick. It's not a big deal though since my annual rate with them is really cheap.
6) Is my vanilla porn assumption correct? How are the scenes generally in terms of the technical proficiency - lighting, sound, camera angles, etc.? In terms of quality, are there other sites, or networks of sites, that you would compare them with?
whatsatelephonebill
Senior Member

2935 Posts
10/11
Posted - Feb 22 2018 : 4:55AM
1.) Their update schedule is usually generally reliable, but it did just change a bit very recently. They used to release 13 new scenes a week(in a 2/1/2/2/3/1/1 format), with 2 of them being VR scenes (Monday and Friday), and a remastered old scene on Tuesday. Within the past month, they dropped the number of new weekly updates to 10 (2/1/2/1/2/1/1) and increased the VR scenes to 3 (Monday/Wednesday/Friday).
2.) The quality level is generally pretty good, but not top of the line in terms of bit-rate. The framerate I believe is the same 30fps that nearly everyone shoots at.
3.) They do occasionally have tech issues, and their e-mail tech support is usually decent at helping fix it, but you'll have better luck if you go to their forums and report the problems.
4.) Customer service is okay though the automated process, but again you can get better support through their forums usually.
5.) Most people's biggest annoyance with them nowadays seems to be the increased reliance on VR scenes, since there's a lot of people that don't have very much interest in those scenes. Other than that, they don't go as over-the-top comedy wise as Brazzers does, it's just very basic vignette scenarios.
6.) The technical proficiency is generally fine, and pretty comparable to Brazzers in that regard. While they do have one or two exclusive directors, most of their other directors have actually shot for both companies.
pat362
Senior Member

10083 Posts
3/10
Posted - Feb 22 2018 : 9:47AM
The site puts out some really good scenario driven porn which stars some of the most popular performers. There is a decent mix of younger and older performer. The sex scenes are all well shot with good camera angles and variety. The only negative and this is very subjective is that if you are a huge fan of anal sex than you won't find as many as on other similar sites. Now I'm not saying that they don't have plenty of them but that they decided a long time ago that they wouldn't add multiple anal scenes each month. Instead you get maybe 1-3 anal scenes each month.
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Feb 22 2018 : 2:58PM
This is really great feedback. Thanks to both of you guys: whatsatelephonebill and pat362. I really, really appreciate it.
It's kind of too bad about the lack of anal scenes. I wonder about that as a policy since so many girls are willing to do it. I can't imagine it's purely a budget issue since you're talking just a few hundred dollars more in most cases for a performer's "anal rate". But, it is what it is, and as I said before, the annual membership is cheap as hell.
PCP_is_Back
Deactivated User

249 Posts
1/18
Posted - Feb 22 2018 : 3:05PM
Naughty America has a catalog of legendary scenes, however, they have not consistently put up that caliber of scenes in years. If you are interested scenes that are several years old, I would endorse them, if you are looking for new or recent content, I think you could do better with other online sites.
 
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Feb 22 2018 : 3:56PM
Well, the catalog is a big part of what interests me, but also newer scenes.
What other sites do you think are good? Right now, I have Brazzers, PornPros (the whole network), Tushy, and Evil Angel. Tushy and Evil Angel are going away soon though. At various times I've also had Jules Jordan and XEmpire.
Edited by - Porn Scout on 2/22/2018 3:56:53 PM
pat362
Senior Member

10083 Posts
3/10
Posted - Feb 22 2018 : 4:20PM
^Before I add a couple of possible sites to your list of sites to join. I want to say that while NA does not update with as many anal scenes as Brazzer. They still have over 500 anal scenes to choose from and many of them are really amazing.
Sites you might want to check out: Reality Kings, Dogfart(if you like interracial porn) and 21Sextury(if you like European porn).
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Feb 22 2018 : 4:32PM
Actually, I have RK. I forgot to mention them. I got the membership from a one-time upgrade fee to my Brazzers membership. I feel like most RK scenes are basically super low-budget, cut-rate porn. Occasionally there are some good scenes, and the library is huge, but I usually just glance at the new content every day or two and then move on.
I've had 21Sextury at various times in the past. I like them, but there's something kind of antiseptic about their scenes. The next time I subscribe to a euro site, it will likely be either DDF or Perfect Gonzo.
I had a Dogfart membership for a month maybe 5 years ago. Production values were rather poor at the time and I've found over the years that I very rarely watch those scenes that I downloaded and stored. Still, I'll probably subscribe to them again at some point. It's just not top of mind. Also, I hate the name "Dogfart". I'm sorry, I know it's meant to be funny, but it's just gross to me.
pat362
Senior Member

10083 Posts
3/10
Posted - Feb 22 2018 : 4:47PM
^I don't think Dogfart spends a lot of time or energy developing their scenarios and they probably don't spend a lot of money on production values but I find that neither of these things is all that important because they still shoot some great porn scenes. Mind you maybe I'm biased because I absolutely love IR porn and for the longest time they were one of the few that was shooting that type of porn on a regular basis. Over the last few years. Others have tried to forge a space on the net for their brand of IR porn but I think that DF is still the king.
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Feb 22 2018 : 6:08PM
^I had a Blacked membership for just one month about this time last year. I like their content, but it's incredibly choreographed and at times doesn't feel real. I think some sort of middle ground between Blacked and Dogfart would work for me.
PCP_is_Back
Deactivated User

249 Posts
1/18
Posted - Feb 22 2018 : 11:03PM
No one is really impressing me right now. Brazzers used to drop at least a hot scene every other day, no you can easy go a week without something to tune into to. Bangbros is putting out the most consistent hot property in my opinion, but they need to amp up the anal. You used to get a couple anala scenes a week from Bang Bros, now you can go weeks without a poop plunger.
All said, sounds like you got memberships to the better sites. If you haven't checked out mompov.com, they put out decent scenes. Something about amateur women always makes the sex hotter.
clev792
Member

11 Posts
8/09
Posted - Apr 6 2018 : 11:47AM
So I rejoined Naughty America after my membership expired. I have had a membership for years. I did this on 4/3/2018. I bought the annual membership thru EPOCH. When I went to log in it only gave me access to a limited number of scenes. After 3 days of trying to access to the entire site I finally called EPOCH. They told me within the last week Naughty America restructured their membership access. For my annual fee I only get access to 100 scenes and must pay by the individual site to unlock them. WTF? Never heard of anything so ridiculous. Who created this business model? Needless to say I cancelled my membership immediately. they are giving me a refund. They are going to loose business buy being so greedy.
MrHamburger
Member

195 Posts
10/15
Posted - Apr 6 2018 : 7:44PM
I just joined as well. For a monthly sub. It seems this change is indeed real. You get access to only 100 scenes. If I want to view any of the more recent scenes I have to purchase them by channel. RIP I can't see this being a successful model to punish those that actually try to support them.
Edited by - mrhamburger on 4/7/2018 3:21:42 PM
rearadmiral All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

6518 Posts
12/11
Posted - Apr 7 2018 : 7:28AM
There is a bit more detail on a thread over at PornUsers. One of the members there seems to sum it up well when he wrote that:
"It's like going to a restaurant where you 1st have to pay a gate fee. Then they throw you a random side order of last years fries, onion rings, who knows could be anything.
Then you can order from the secret menu no one can see from outside the restaurant from a growing number of food categories for an unknown price that may contain fresh food or may be something stale that was made years ago.
And if you leave the restaurant for any reason they will take the food back via the Heimlich Maneuver."
Other information there indicates that your monthly subscription fee gives you a small amount of random access (of their choosing) and the ability to pay additional fees to join 'channels.' I understand that the porn business has been devastated by piracy but it seems to me that fucking over paying customers isn't the solution.
RIP, Naughty America.
moviefan420
Member

48 Posts
2/15
Posted - Apr 9 2018 : 9:49PM
How is adult DVD empires streaming service?
R.I.P. videoage.com
 
whatsatelephonebill
Senior Member

2935 Posts
10/11
Posted - Apr 10 2018 : 1:01AM
Yeah, I would suggest that no one join right now.
In my personal opinion, it's only a matter of time before they realize how stupid this whole idea is and go back to normal, but the amount of bad sentiment they've gained from doing it in the first place just points to someone there being completely clueless about, well, everything.
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Apr 10 2018 : 3:08AM
Glad I started this thread and glad I didn't end up joining.
Jackie Treehorn
Member

It'll knock both your eyes out!
311 Posts
3/04
Posted - Apr 10 2018 : 12:07PM
Glad I didn't see this thread a few days sooner as I would of praised NA. I've had a running membership for several years now, so I had no idea about these changes for new members. It's a shame because regardless of what one thinks of the type of content they offer, they have been the one major porn site that has actually been at the front in adopting new tech. They have offered 4k of most all scenes for several years now. The quality was weak at first but they improved greatly since. They have offered a consistent flow of VR scenes for a year or two now as well. Most the top mega sites still don't have 4K or VR. Hopefuly this new approach gets dropped quickly. I wouldn't begrudge them for raising monthly fees a bit, as surely it must cost them money to offer so much 4K and VR stuff.
It's just puzzling why porn sites come up with these convoluted plans rather than something more simple and straight forward. Like maybe Tier 1- NA Classic: Access to all 1080p and lower scenes. Tier 2- NA Gold: Access to all HD, 4K and VR content for and extra $5-$10 a month.
tintintin
Senior Member

1230 Posts
8/07
Posted - Apr 10 2018 : 12:37PM
Although the scenes became boring the last couple of years I miss 2chickssametime.
shalalin
Senior Member

1734 Posts
11/07
Posted - Apr 10 2018 : 6:44PM
I'm sure Naughty America's corporate/management structure has changed several times over, but the company seems to be prone to these really, really boneheaded business decisions for some reason. A long time back (2009-ish? right around the time they were starting to be seen as a major player in web porn) their head honcho of the time teased an exciting change, which turned out to be...scrapping all the themed sub-site categories and releasing every single scene branded simply as "Naughty America". For some reason he genuinely seemed to believe that every NA customer would either want to watch every released scene and didn't care about categories, or would be happy to be required to do their own sifting all the time.
That particular idea lasted about six weeks or so, but managed to piss off basically their entire forum userbase at the time. (Who knows what regular users were thinking.) Sadly, I have a feeling this one is going to stick around for longer, if only because this one directly affects their revenue stream and the loss of face will be massive if they have to admit it failed.
Discount sites that don't have user discussions attached are still advertising their NA deals as "get access to the entire network". (Even the landing page on NA's site still does!) I imagine they're gonna have a lot of unhappy new sign-ups over the next few days or weeks.
rearadmiral All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

6518 Posts
12/11
Posted - Apr 10 2018 : 7:54PM
Ah yes, I've been burned by a few site joins through discount sites without user comments before. I'm sure we all have.
whatsatelephonebill
Senior Member

2935 Posts
10/11
Posted - Apr 10 2018 : 7:59PM
^^
Actually, as far as I can tell the corporate structure really hasn't changed much since then. The head honcho that was talking about that exciting change? He's the exact same person that was extolling the virtues of this one over the past month or so. The people underneath him have come and gone, but it's still him at the top making completely boneheaded decisions every few years and having to walk them back.
shenmue
Member

574 Posts
10/14
Posted - Apr 10 2018 : 9:08PM
Stopped paying for NA about a year ago, all the new scenes with 2 or more girls are VR scenes now and i don't watch VR so that is unfortunate for me.
shalalin
Senior Member

1734 Posts
11/07
Posted - Apr 10 2018 : 10:20PM
Oy, I stand corrected then. That explains the pattern, I suppose...
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Apr 17 2018 : 6:58PM
Looking over at their main signup page, the text now reads:
NA_Mem_Options.PNG
Part of the problem here is that it seems like NA is being deliberately deceptive in what they're actually offering. Look at the text next to the asterisk. Their payment processor must be getting annoyed as hell with all the refunds they (presumably) are having to process.
I wonder what prompted this change in policy. NA is one of the big networks and I doubt they've been running in the red.
 
whatsatelephonebill
Senior Member

2935 Posts
10/11
Posted - Apr 17 2018 : 8:05PM
^
I wouldn't be so sure about that. There's rumors out there that they're pretty far behind on their affiliate payments, so it is possible that they're having some cash flow problems.
And also, they finally clarified on Reddit what the basic membership gets you. It's basically 100 videos per week that rotate each week, including a handful of VR videos. And this goes for every sub up to the yearly (I don't know if the year is structured that way or not). If I'm being 100% honest, that isn't a bad idea for the 3 and 7 day memberships (especially if they did something like guarantee access to the past 2 weeks/1 month or scenes on top of that). But it's arguably the worst value in membership porn when it comes for the monthly sub. Even if you logged on each week, that's $25 for 400 scenes on a network of thousands. Every other site on their level is the same price for access to thousands of videos. There's literally nothing in NA's videos that make them worth that level of value.
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Apr 17 2018 : 8:28PM
^That's interesting. I wonder how sophisticated they are from a financial management perspective. Though I'm not an industry insider by any means, it seems like revenues and costs would be fairly predictable; it shouldn't be terribly difficult to track that information in excel and project it into the future.
shalalin
Senior Member

1734 Posts
11/07
Posted - Apr 17 2018 : 11:08PM
^^ Is there any information on what the individual sites/channels/whatever cost? That info is conspicuously absent from their sign-up pages.
I wonder why they didn't just go whole-hog and make the basic site free and use that as an openly available shop window for the paid channels, especially if it turns out that those 100 rotating scenes don't include the latest stuff.
SteveX
Member

534 Posts
4/17
Posted - Apr 18 2018 : 1:42AM
Honest review / lengthened explanations:
- Very pleased with customer service, prompt refund - no bullshitting around. On the forums, I was expecting this to be the complete opposite just the way one of the Admins came across. Lack of explanation & no finesse / customer "care". They didn't care that 11yr members were leaving OR even inform them that keeping their membership would offer them all channel access - till after they cancelled their membership because an Admin dared them to...like who does that?
- Not enthused at all with the new structure, I saw posts prior to this change on here which prompted me to take advantage of their "lifetime discount offer". Then I saw the crazy yearly price (5.95USD/month) and grabbed that only to be walking into a paywall. It was 17.95/m down from 29.95USD/m originally so was expecting a full site access (especially when advertised with full access on discount/review sites).
- The problem is - and I addressed this with JJV before as well - the rebill cycle for yearly either doesn't rebill or will only rebill at $29.95USD, so you're immediately stuck between a rock and a hard place where you're forced to pay an extra $24USD/month to keep all your channels. There is nothing Jules could do from there end, so I suspect it will be the same in this case as well. So what happens when your account doesn't rebill? You would more than likely end up needing another account? Y/N?
- Each channel is either another $17.95 / month or $50-71 dollars upfront whilst on a current membership, up to $2500USD required to open all channels? Some I believe would only have a handful of scenes and the cons on reviews are said that some sites don't get updated anymore, so if you pay $17.95USD you may only get say 10 scenes and no updates?
- NaughtyAmerica was one site I was looking forward to, I'm a fan of non-degrading porn and making women more glamorous for the camera - they do this well and they offer great quality. I was expecting to pay more for their VR side, but for access to every different site/channel was a bit over the top in my opinion. Especially when most sites offer full access for $19.95 etc.
I think the worst part is the lack of transparency, its not hard to have a pop-up notifying you of the changes etc. Personally, I'd rather the membership be you can access all standard channels at the $29.95USD with a VR access is $29.95USD (as its essentially 3-4 scenes a week apparently). I felt really disheartened that I couldn't just jump on and view my favorite performers' scenes. All were locked behind paywalls, I may only want to view one scene in a channel but it requires $17.95USD....
I love their product, but this is crazy. I would happily pay yearly for their product (non-VR) but not upwards of $80USD per month for only a fraction of the content. Yes, they rotate scenes but we like to pick what we want to watch - not force watch one of 100 scenes which may have only 10 that are of interest. Most of us support other sites, they seem to think customers would be happy to pay mountains of money for their content - I've never seen any evidence to support that and lets be honest, most porn customers are those who want to support the website - now it feels like they are just being greedy without any care for their new or returning members. Also, I often see posters on here saying they have a budget they stick to - well this membership would put a dent in the bank so all of those guys are definitely not going to be joining NA any time soon.
TL;DR Honestly, avoid if your porn wallet isn't an open cheque book.
Edited by - SteveX on 4/18/2018 2:33:54 AM
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Apr 19 2018 : 12:11AM
So, it seems like what's happening here is that NA may be going under. Years of financial mismanagement have caught up to them and so they're making this one last-ditch effort to grab some cash, pay some bills, and hopefully save their own jobs. But obviously it's not going to work, at least not for very long.
So what happens next? If they get to a point where they simply can't operate, then it's bankruptcy isn't it? I wonder if they even have the money to pay lawyers? Another possibility would be a buyout. Mindgeek is the dominant player in the industry, but who knows if they would even be interested. Personally, I would rather see a different buyer given how dominant Mindgeek is already.
whatsatelephonebill
Senior Member

2935 Posts
10/11
Posted - Apr 19 2018 : 12:54AM
^
If that's what happening (and I'm not entirely sure it is), then there's enough value in the brand that someone would probably be willing to buy it, though I don't know if Mindgeek would since they already own Brazzers, which was turned into a Naughty America clone from what it originally started as and then proceeded to surpass it. This isn't the first time I've seen them get desperate in their attempts to either make money (there was a time about 10-12 years ago or so where they tried to split the site in two and make people pay separately for each "tier", as they called it) or reduce costs (about 8-10 years ago there was a different time where they decreased the amount of scenes per week for a month or so and went down to as low as 5 new scenes in one week, and another time where they got caught not paying a producer before a scene went out having to pull that scene and not only lower their scenes per week by like a scene or two a week, but the scenes that were coming out were obviously done in a much cheaper manner than their normal quality), and they've normally been able to come back from it, though this time does feel a bit different.
Edit: I see this ending one of two ways. The first is that this was always intended to be a short-term money grab to solve cash flow problems, and they go back to normal and spend the next year or two trying to build back trust in their brand again. The second is that this is a last ditch effort, and the company gets sold out to someone that decides to keep the name going, but maybe do things a little differently.
Edited by - whatsatelephonebill on 4/19/2018 1:15:23 AM
SteveX
Member

534 Posts
4/17
Posted - Apr 19 2018 : 3:15AM
^ Surely not the case, they pump out scenes quite a bit for VR and also the standard, you don't pump out scenes if you can't afford it. I just think its a bad move, unless there is actual evidence to support that claim.
shalalin
Senior Member

1734 Posts
11/07
Posted - Apr 19 2018 : 9:35PM
It sort of feels as though they're trying to ape both Mindgeek's Pornportal model and Pornpros's site setup, except that
1) PornPros does give you full access to one site/niche, so if that's all you're interested in you're not missing out on any of it after paying your upfront signup fee,
2) PornPros at least lets you upgrade from one site to all of them for a single flat fee,
3) NA doesn't have nearly the amount of content under control that Mindgeek does, and
4) unlike what Mindgeek is able to offer by having contracted/bought out lots of separate producers, the content on NA's new channels is arguably total cookie-cutter from one channel to the next.
The scenarios might be different and one NA channel might be having more MILFs and the other more teens, but ultimately it's all been produced to the same standards for the last 10+ years, and thus looks virtually the same. (Arguably to an even greater degree than the other megasites...only the recently revamped RK comes close in uniformity of look in its new scenes IMHO.) That's good if you're selling that content as one single package, not so much if you're trying to charge for it a bunch of separate times.
And at the risk of repeating myself, the strangest part of it is that they're still charging an "entry fee" at all. Offer separate scene packages if you have to, but making people pay just to receive the privilege to pay more to actually get anything worthwhile is rather absurd. Even with upgradeable packages there still needs to be a worthwhile amount of content in the basic tier, and it doesn't sound like that's the case here, at least not at a $17.95 price point.
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Apr 20 2018 : 9:51PM
^I think you're right on almost every count. I really wonder about the thought process of NA managers. I mean, I get that they're looking at the numbers and trying to figure out a way to monetize their content more effectively. It makes sense that someone in that role would do that. But how do you come up with this type of an offering? Or, more precisely, if they're looking at Mindgeek and PornPros for inspiration, how did they get it wrong so completely?
And if my earlier post is on track, in that they are in fact running out of money, I wonder if it's the investment in VR that's done them in. I don't know what the average VR scene production budget is, but assuming $5,000 minimum per scene x 228 scenes, that's a total of $1,140,000 invested into that category over several years. The question in my mind is how effectively that investment has paid off in driving subscriptions. The NA managers should know this but obviously those of us on the outside won't have a clue.
whatsatelephonebill
Senior Member

2935 Posts
10/11
Posted - Apr 21 2018 : 4:11AM
^
The VR scenes have always replaced normal 2D scenes(i.e. they went from 13 2D scenes a week to 12 2D/1VR to 112D/2VR), so outside of costs of buying/updating/maintaining the equipment (which, for most companies, is just top of the line GoPros placed in custom housing), their actual production costs haven't increased that much. And what they got in return, at least for the first couple of years, is a bunch of mainstream press from sites that don't write about porn, like Techcrunch and CNET, the ability to have booths at both CES and E3, and even a brief appearance in a clip on The Tonight Show. The added press more than likely drove traffic and subscriptions up, so I'm pretty sure it has been worth it.
 
SteveX
Member

534 Posts
4/17
Posted - Apr 21 2018 : 4:44AM
If VR is such a huge commodity for them, why didn't they just stick with the standard sub for the 2D porn and then look at a way to make VR side more profitable, starting with paying for VR as an extra - similar to the VIP pricing models on most of the other sites these days? Even have an extra premium package experience for some next-level-crazy VR or creative collab idk.
Half the problem is they're charging HUGE prices and the memberships are hard to keep - afaik EPOCH don't rebill after 12 months or you get $29.95USD per month which is expensive in the whole scheme of things - especially when said fee doesn't actually give you proper access just a rotating bunch of scenes per week - of which you may be interested by one scene or five if you're lucky. Then 50-71 dollars USD per channel to have full access - which you wouldn't go monthly as you would lose quick once membership over and the 50-71 is the better deal, but overall its still the most expensive porn site behind LP - but at least LP you pay for what you want and get premium DP and all the crazy 5-on-1s they do.
I've already seen posts on their forums coming from 10 odd year members that their credit card run out or they went with a special to "avoid the fiasco" and they lost all their channels that they were provided for being members prior - which is a kick in the guts, because it wouldn't matter how long you're a member, just as long as it was before April 2nd. They decided to cancel their memberships altogether.
I don't understand why they needed such a crazy business model, its not like they have the market cornered or are offering the best porn ever. Most people on their forums have criticized the lack of creativity on their 2D side, favoring the VR with top talent and overall just lack of flavor. Unfortunately their admins don't want to provide any inkling into their reasoning or what they expect the outcome to be. I sure as hell know I'm not touching NA while they have this business model.
Your money would be better spent subbing to a few top sites and the other 20 you would be able to buy for the same price of their membership offer.
shalalin
Senior Member

1734 Posts
11/07
Posted - Apr 21 2018 : 4:56PM
Exactly. I don't know if VR is viable for them nowadays, but it clearly wasn't when they started offering it - otherwise they would have done it as a separate site from the outset like e.g. Tonight's Girlfriend. They could have still branded it as "powered by NA" or whatever if they had wanted to give a rub to the main site.
I'm biased because I don't give a damn about VR, but given that it has hardly taken off as a commercial blockbuster for any other porn producers, my feeling has always been that "regular" subscribers have essentially been subsidizing NA's VR adventures for the last few years.
whatsatelephonebill
Senior Member

2935 Posts
10/11
Posted - Apr 21 2018 : 6:59PM
^
And you'd be wrong, seeing as NA has generally said that something around 30% of their subscribers download/watch their VR scenes.
SteveX
Member

534 Posts
4/17
Posted - Apr 21 2018 : 8:44PM
^ I have no problem with VR being popular - I can change into 2D POV through VR player, its not the same but its still good enough to watch.
I just want a fair pricing model for all - is that too much to ask? Unfortunately, NA's new pricing model is beyond crazy.
whatsatelephonebill
Senior Member

2935 Posts
10/11
Posted - Apr 22 2018 : 12:20AM
^
I completely agree with you. It's just that I don't think any of what's going on was caused by the VR scenes. The added cost isn't that much, and the amount of scenes was never so many that they were actually taking over the site (it wasn't until they cut down on the total scenes released that they were more than 25% of the content in any given week).
shalalin
Senior Member

1734 Posts
11/07
Posted - Apr 22 2018 : 2:26AM
I'd love to know how much of that percentage has come about because of rising interest in their VR stuff, and how much because of dwindling interest in their regular output... Impressive percentages don't mean much if the baseline is shrinking. In any case, that may be what it's like now - I was talking about the entire period they've been doing VR.
Edit: And of course, what share of those 30% are NA subscribers solely or primarily because of VR? The revenue effectively brought in by the VR offerings could well be much, much lower if a lot of subscribers merely treat it as a "nice to have" throw-in rather than an actual reason for having their subscription.
Edited by - shalalin on 4/22/2018 2:35:04 AM
whatsatelephonebill
Senior Member

2935 Posts
10/11
Posted - Apr 22 2018 : 2:45AM
^
At this point, what you're asking for is pure download/traffic numbers, which you know you're never going to get. And the last time I heard that number was late Feb/early March, but it wasn't the first time I'd heard it (the time before that was sometime last year).
Edit: I get that you want VR to be the scapegoat because you think it's a waste of time/money, but from what I know about what's going on things just aren't that simple.
Edited by - whatsatelephonebill on 4/22/2018 2:47:48 AM
shalalin
Senior Member

1734 Posts
11/07
Posted - Apr 22 2018 : 3:01AM
^ I don't think VR is necessarily a waste of time or money, at least not as seen from NA's/La Touraine's side. (My view as a potential subscriber, i.e. concerning my time and money, is a different matter.) I just don't think it's anywhere near as big a deal as it's getting made out to be - again, if it was, why hasn't NA stepped up its VR production output and spun it off into a separate site? They thought additional money could be made even with something unremarkable such as Mrs Creampie, after all.
Question, as I haven't seen the specific breakdown of NA's new channels: Are all the VR videos already available and coming in the future part of one single channel, or have they broken those down further by theme as well?
Anyway, I'm not meaning to scapegoat their VR stuff for any potential or actual decline in their fortunes on the 2D side. That that content has become rather uninnovative and unimaginative surely has many reasons unrelated to VR. When I'm talking about possible reasons the 30% figure might be less impressive than it looks, I'm not blaming the existence of VR as the root cause of those reasons.
Edited by - shalalin on 4/22/2018 3:12:55 AM
whatsatelephonebill
Senior Member

2935 Posts
10/11
Posted - Apr 22 2018 : 3:31AM
^
They've actually done three separate VR spinoffs. Randy's Roadstop was the first one in 2015 I believe, then RealTeens VR in 2016 (which lasted the longest at about 3/4 months), and then Big Tits in VR, which had a set of scenes go up in 2016 and then another set of scenes come out this year. I don't know how any of them did except to say that RealTeens and Randy haven't seen updates in years (they did kinda tease a RealTeens revival in one of the more recent VR scenes), and Big Tits still only has 10 videos total (but the most recent one is less than a month old, I belive).
And the VR scenes are split up into channels in a way very similar to the 2D scenes. Each separate theme gets its own channel (so PSE is a channel, T&A is a channel, Fuck My Ass is a channel, After School is a channel, etc.) and the ones that don't fit into those channels are split up by what niche they fall under. Just like you can't just pay one flat fee and get all the 2D scenes, you can't pay one flat fee and get all the VR scenes.
SteveX
Member

534 Posts
4/17
Posted - Apr 23 2018 : 7:03AM
^ And that is where it starts to get crazy. Why would people want to pay $19.95/m for a channel with only a bunch of scenes that doesn't get updated?
I just don't understand this pricing model. I'm meaning VR be added as your premium option on other sites - you get the basic with all the 2d access then premium is additional for VR experience. Either that or separate.
The three channels split VR content is a bit insane. I don't know anyone who would pay the rates they are expecting people to pay.
MrHamburger
Member

195 Posts
10/15
Posted - Apr 30 2018 : 9:47AM
They have updated the amount of videos you have access to. Instead of 100 random scenes you get all the scenes from the present month. So if you signed up in April you get all the scenes from April 2018. Any scene released before this month is locked but you will get access to the next months scenes. However after a certain point those April scenes will get locked into those channels.
I actually have an active subscription to them. I signed up after the change not knowing. They actually took away those previous 100 random scenes and gave the April 2018 scenes without any notice.
https://www.naughtyamerica.com/update-to-naughty-america-membership
Edited by - mrhamburger on 4/30/2018 9:54:06 AM
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Apr 30 2018 : 5:41PM
^Wow. Just wow.
PornStarNamedBuckNaked All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Sometimes life is goofier than a monkey on ether
12073 Posts
7/10
Posted - Apr 30 2018 : 6:25PM
rearadmiral All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

6518 Posts
12/11
Posted - Apr 30 2018 : 8:32PM
^ Yup. If there was a porn list of bad decisions they'd be #1 these days. RIP Naughty America.
Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - Apr 30 2018 : 9:31PM
I would so love to be a fly on the wall watching and listening when these morons look at their numbers.
SteveX
Member

534 Posts
4/17
Posted - May 1 2018 : 2:01AM
^ I understand why they are doing it - to stop people from downloading their back catalog and then unsubbing - but why not just add premium option with VR & downloads for an extra $19.95-29.95USD per month? At least that seems more reasonable than $50-71 USD per channel.... Its pointless to pay an extra 20-30USD per channel each month - since some reportedly only have 10-20 scenes of which maybe 1-3 you may watch because you have select favorites or tastes.
I just subbed to ZZ for 12 months, less than $9.95USD/m - no premium for full access (thank fuck), same price rebill and aren't they meant to be NA's biggest competitor? I know they make good coin, but market competition is market competition. Provide a better product at a good price & dominate - simple. I'd say NA will lose a lot and maybe a few companies are offering great deals at the moment to entice their subscribers to move across.
These "Channels" are starting to become a stupid idea, I understand that Mindgeek push this a lot but you can still access a lot of content for the standard 9.95 & an extra $9.95 for premium on their sites you want to view for a month and collect some great scenes that have released over say 3 month period. I'm happy for these companies to do that, because they offer good prices for what you get. Same with XEmpire & EvilAngel they offer great deals for what you get. You don't get 10-13 scenes per week, but you get a great deal for $9.95 per month.
I would happily sub to a mega-site for the GammaAE (they are looking at doing this based on their latest survey) and pay $19.95/m and then additional for their extra taboo & other bits every now and then. I think they could easily offer a mega-site, combine additional options for EvilAngel etc at sharp prices and then if you want say a DP scene from PureTaboo you can buy for $2.95 for full access or w/e - just likely they offer for upcoming EvilAngel videos.
NA pay for you to only see the new scenes which is stupid really, you may not like anything that gets released or maybe only 1-5 scenes per month if you're picky and thats 19.95-29.95USD per month? Lol.
Edited by - SteveX on 5/1/2018 2:03:00 AM
All Forums > The Porn Pool > How is Naughty America?

Previous topic: Ebony pornstars
Next topic: Sleeping BFF joins couple
Page 1 of 27 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 13 > Last



Jump To: