Featured New Release
Box cover for Elegant Beauty Needs Passionate Sex
Elegant Beauty Needs Passionate Sex
Studio: Vixen
Release date: 7/26/2026


all new releases
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 63 > Need editing & DVD authoring suggestion
AuthorPost
JasonX
Member


23 Posts
5/03
Posted - May 29 2003 : 11:44PM
Can anyone suggest a good software package(s) for editing miniDV tapes and then authoring and burning to a master DVD? Something that will provide lossless quality preferably.

I just shot my first home video and want to burn it to DVD.

tricia_devereaux
Evil Angel DVD

Patience is a virtue, but who wants to be virtuous?
4283 Posts
4/00
Posted - May 30 2003 : 1:43AM
For Macintosh, iMovie and iDVD are sufficient if you just want something simple, and they come as pre-installed software on the new PowerMac G4s.
FinalCut Pro and DVD Studio Pro are a step up for Macintosh.

For PC, a barebones but sufficient one if you want something really simple is DVD Studio Factory from ULead. (about $50 or so).
ULead also has several other versions of MediaStudio Pro, Sonic Solutions has DVDit! and Pinnacle has Pinnacle Express and Impression DVD-Pro.

A significant step up is Avid Express DV (about $1000), but has anything a non-professional would want for editing from DV.

For editing, many of these programs have limited or not-so-limited editing abilities. And another program, just for editing is Adobe Premiere.

I've only used the iDVD and DVD Studio Pro for Mac, and Media Studio Pro, all of which were fine, but at different price points depending on how easy and fancy you want to get.

Juster
Member

67 Posts
3/03
Posted - May 30 2003 : 7:56AM
If I were looking for such a thing, I'd head for www.cnet.com for reviews of DVD authoring software, just to cover all the bases. Maybe just as importantly, there is often a down-loadable trial (or even free) version of popular software. You can find what's what by scrolling down past the most recent stuff to the correct archive and take a look around. Just a suggestion....

J.

Ingenmann
Member

My 3d Porn
113 Posts
1/03
Posted - May 30 2003 : 8:18AM
Considering the scope of your home movie project I would personally go for the macintosh iMovie/iDVD solution if I had the money for a new computer. With a Mac everything you need just works out of the box.

Otherwise if you want to configure your own PC here are a few lists for you. If you want a free basic editing solution check out Microsoft Movie Maker. But just about every computer store has complete editing and DVD solutions at very reasonably prices

http://www.ezdvdadvisor.com/public/department223.cfm - list of DV editing and DVD solutions - almost all of the manufactures have DV editing solution too

http://user850490.wx8.registeredsite.com/features/dvdfaq.asp - Introductory DVD Authoring FAQ

http://www.dvddemystified.com/dvdfaq.html - everything you ever wanted to know about DVD

aybesea
Senior Member

Caroline Cage - Hungarian Hottie!
1485 Posts
5/02
Posted - May 30 2003 : 9:46AM
JasonX,

First off, do you have a PC or a MAC? If you have a PC, I can lend you lots of advice. Which DVD burner do you have? Did it come bundled with any software?

Let me know and I'll try to help.

 
Evil_Rip
Senior Member

Power overwhelming
1117 Posts
12/99
Posted - May 31 2003 : 1:21PM
Pinnacle systems makes a rather good package with a very easy interface Studio 8

Apple machines comes with some decent tools preinstalled.
You may also look at DVDR Help.com

AlexPanzer
Deactivated User

1593 Posts
6/03
Posted - Jun 21 2003 : 9:32PM
Adobe Premiere is really good and affordable software for editing, soon Adobe will release Encore for the DVD authoring. Macs arent that good when comparing them to a pc, I think that macs are limited and slow
cal444
Independent Editor CalCutterPost.com

927 Posts
10/01
Posted - Jun 22 2003 : 5:15AM
Final Cut 4, DVD Studio Pro, the bomb

Cal444
Somewhere

AlexPanzer
Deactivated User

1593 Posts
6/03
Posted - Jun 22 2003 : 2:08PM
Final Cut Pro is great, the first editing app that I used was FCP3, it was a easy for me than Premiere
snooper
Member

19 Posts
6/03
Posted - Jul 2 2003 : 12:50AM
Pinnacle systems makes a rather good package with a very easy interface...

Yes, I've heard nothing but good things about the Pinnacle line as far as internal software goes. That looks like your best bet in that area right now.

However, I get a lot of feedback from fellow film fans wondering why they can't find a good EXTERNAL burner for transfering camcorder material and VHS video material to DVD.

After having read about a hundred reviews on stand-alone video to DVD burners, the picture (literally) doesn't look good:

I say this because the ones putting out the most recorders in the field (Philips and Panasonic, but strangely not much by Sony) seem to be rife with many glitches, mainly including the following:

1) Problems due to units designed only to replace VCRs for recording TV shows.

2) Units suddenly stopping part way through burning the disk.

3) Burned disks that play okay in host DVD players but can't be read by other players.

4) Disks unable to properly finalize after disk burning sessions.

5) Burners working great for exactly one month and then dropping dead like clockwork, etc., etc.

So my conclusion on external units, at least, is to wait until next year - maybe they'll have their act together by 2004. (Maybe Pinnacle will also get into stand-alones?)

But right now it's not worth $500 to only be able to warm up a bunch of coasters for your drinks.

snowman872
RainCoatReviews.com

400 Posts
6/00
Posted - Jul 9 2003 : 8:00AM
I think Vegas Video is easier to use than some of the others but also has lots of advanced features as your skills grow.

DV Capturing with VV works good here.

-- Snowman




Jump To: