All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 21 > Now that the RIAA has cut LyricWiki's throat...
AuthorPost
the unknown pervert
Deactivated User

I'd like to stay but I've got a plane to catch.
3243 Posts
5/06
Posted - Sep 3 2009 : 10:19PM
Anyone know any sites where I can pull up song lyrics from? I have roughly 1000 albums in my music collection and I would estimate that about half of them have no lyrics in the album package. The RIAA can suck my dick if they think I am going to pay for a CD and then turn around and pay them again to access lyrics from some pay for lyric site they are going to try to set up.
Harri Patel
Senior Member

#SDNY he's all yours. -- Michael Steele
5110 Posts
3/03
Posted - Sep 4 2009 : 1:25AM
I usually just Google "[name of song] lyrics"
BYOB_Kenobi
Senior Member

“Life can only be understood backwards; but it must be lived forwards.” - Kierkegaard
2684 Posts
8/09
Posted - Sep 12 2009 : 6:08PM
Wow, I did not realized they did this. This is gotten way out of hand. Congress needs to pass new copyright laws that will put an end to them censoring lyrics! Last time I knew, transcribing a song's lyrics and posting on web was not illegal.
RIAA is way over encroaching 1st Amendment rights here (freedom of press, freedom of speech).
Edited by - BYOB_Kenobi on 9/12/2009 6:12:08 PM
BigBobxxx
Senior Member

2681 Posts
5/04
Posted - Sep 14 2009 : 6:47AM
Song lyrics are copyrighted, just as the music is.
This is not a 1st Amendment issue.
While it may seem to some that they are just being dicks, if they think they can commercially benefit from their property (i.e. "pay them again to access lyrics from some pay for lyric site they are going to try to set up"), they should be protective of their copyrights.
To the extent that they prevent others from creating "lyrics sites," that will impinge on their ability to market their products for profit, I can't say they are wrong to do so.
However, I'm sure that, whatever monies they realize will be more than offset by the customer, and potential customer, ill-will that they create.
Even the Walt Disney Company -- the biggest copyright assholes on the planet -- tolerates numerous fan websites, some which are for profit (profit from a site, not from any Disney material being sold), that share Disney images, music, lyrics, recipes, etc. You name it.
It's great customer relations. And, it's great advertising for the products they sell.
This just may be a case of the Internet creating a new market (i.e. the selling of song lyrics) that was/is not practical with traditional print media. Over the years, of course, there were fan magazines, even printed music & lyrics magazines, that "sold lyrics" as part of the magazine. But, never on a buy-the-lyrics-for-a-specified-song basis that the Internet could easily provide.
BYOB_Kenobi
Senior Member

“Life can only be understood backwards; but it must be lived forwards.” - Kierkegaard
2684 Posts
8/09
Posted - Sep 14 2009 : 9:09PM
I am not strong in copyright laws, but wouldn't posting music lyrics be protected under Fair Use? My interpretation is that lyrics do not make the original song. I personally think Congress needs to get off it's ass and clear a lot of the unresolved issues by updating copyright laws, even though this result would probably piss me off even more.
I totally agree that it will bite them in the ass.
BTW, there were magazines that printed song lyrics? Learn something new every day
 
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Sep 18 2009 : 10:19AM
Wow. You mean I'm breaking the law when I sing in the shower? Who knew? And good lord! I've just been walking around whistling all of that copyrighted music. Granted, it sounds like a wookie being tortured when I sing it but still.
BigBobxxx
Senior Member

2681 Posts
5/04
Posted - Sep 20 2009 : 9:03AM
That isn't what I said at all (i.e. "You mean...).
If you are being serious, you clearly don't have any understanding of copyright facts and issues.
BigBobxxx
Senior Member

2681 Posts
5/04
Posted - Sep 20 2009 : 9:27AM
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 21Now that the RIAA has cut LyricWiki's throat...

Previous topic: google-analytics.com
Next topic: software to organize a DVD library/collection



Jump To: