Oren
Anarchy/Python
| Author | Post |
|---|---|
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | I've had a weird problem with the last two discs that I rented that were released by Red Light District and Platinum X. The discs were "Black Dicks & Asian Chicks" from RLD (on Friday) and "Feeling Black 2" from PXP (today). In both cases, the picture had kind of a halo effect around every change in color on the screen. It kind of looked like watching a rear projection TV where the guns are out of alignment. Depending on whether the color was going from a darker shade on the left to lighter shade on the right or vice versa, there would be either a red or blue line right where the beginning of the ligher shade began. This hasn't happened with any other discs (I've watched other discs on this TV between last Friday and today) and I'm sure that it's not my TV or DVD player (I tested "Feeling Black 2" on another DVD player/TV in the house. Has anyone else noticed something like this on any of their titles. Since RLD and PXP are "sister" companies, I'm assuming that they use the same outside companies to manufacture their DVD's. If so, it might be a good idea to check this problem out quickly so it doesn't happen to too many titles. Edited to change "Feeling Black" to "Feeling Black 2" Edited by - Bill on Mar 13 2004 [Link] |
| OREN Anarchy Films 250 Posts 12/03 | Oren |
| M.B. Senior Member 1679 Posts 2/01 | I'm no expert when it comes to cameras, authoring etc. But I do see that something is definately off with the camera or lighting they are using (PXP) to shoot their porn, it looks absolutely terrible. Some of it actually borders on being totally colourless, almost like it's been shot in black and white. For some reason, Mason's movies are the only ones that look to have decent color to them, but the picture still looks somewhat dull and not very sharp on her stuff as well. Either it's the lighting or the camera. They better figure out who or what the problem is. I don't even rent their stuff anymore (vhs or dvd) because I KNOW it's going to look like hell. I think Brandon Iron once said they use the same camera as RLD does, if that's true it might be the lighting, I don't know anymore, all I know is that they should look into it and quick. I don't buy their movies anymore (except for Mason's) because of the terrible picture quality and serious lack of colour. Their stuff looks like it was taken from a second, third or even fourth generation vhs tape. Whether its on dvd or vhs it doesn't matter, it looks really bad.
|
| mookiemeister Super Cool Dude 181 Posts 7/02 | "The lover knows much more about absolute good and universal beauty than any logician or theologian, unless the latter, too, be lovers in disguise." - George Santayana "To do the useful thing, to say the courageous thing, to contemplate the beautiful thing: that is enough for one man's life.: - T.S. Eliot |
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | One reviewer did notice the problem but isn't it funny how Selena Silver's ass kissing review gives it 5 stars for picture??? Edited by - sanchez_1960 on 3/9/2004 6:33:44 PM |
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | I think that he added the low bit rate issue as another one that can cause problems with RLD/PXP titles. In this case, pixelization. I agree with you though, until they have this problem fixed, I will be renting their DVD's instead of buying them. |
| Brandon Iron BrandonIron.com 3832 Posts 3/02 | I absolutely disagree. While we may have problems technically that vary from title to title, the overall quality of our product meets or exceeds most other companies. Like you, I watch a lot of adult movies. To single us out as being "the worst looking porn on the market" smacks of a mindset that is predisposed towards finding what is wrong instead of what is right. Sincerely, |
| PL Senior Member God hates us all, you know it's true, God hates this place. - Slayer 1726 Posts 10/03 | |
| Brice777 Member MA 93 Posts 3/02 | |
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | Instead of just disagreeing with a generic negative statement from M.B., how about addressing the problem with regard to a specific disc ("Feeling Black 2")? There is currently a problem with the discs that you are releasing. The problem is not isolated to a single title (it's happening with a title from you sister company as well). It's a problem that needs to be addressed. If the problem isn't fixed, I will end up agreeing with M.B. If all PXP titles end up having this "halo effect", because nobody cared enough to correct the problem, your DVD's will be unwatchable.
Edited by - Bill on 3/13/2004 10:45:20 AM |
| Brandon Iron BrandonIron.com 3832 Posts 3/02 | I thank you for expressing your concerns with our product. I don't know what to tell you. I personally screen my DVDs and do not see any problems. They look the same on my television as they do on my computer when I edit them. Also, the edit masters look the same as the original footage that is shot on my Sony 3 CCD camera. I cannot fix what I cannot see. Believe me, I would be the first to change a process if I saw any halo effect. It's just not there when I screen my DVDs. I asked our DVD guy what could be the cause of this and he said he wasn't sure. He will look into it and get back to me. I will then get back to you. Brandon Edited by - Brandon Iron on 3/13/2004 3:08:08 AM |
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | By the way, the problem doesn't exist on Photographic Mammaries, which is the most recent of your titles that I own. The problem is more noticable on larger TV's than it is on smaller screens (it just jumps out on my 56" set) and it is noticable immediately because it actually makes it difficult to read the names of the performers in the opening credits. The purpose of my post was not to complain about the problem (I didn't buy either of the titles, I rented them), but more to let you guys know about the problem before affects too many more titles. |
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | |
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | |
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | |
| Brandon Iron BrandonIron.com 3832 Posts 3/02 | Thanks for the input. I have another suggestion. Can you post 3-5 time codes of places in a Platinum X Pictures movie where the halo effect occurs? This will help us to look at what's going on. For your trouble, we'll send you any other PXP title of your choice. Thank you, Brandon www.platinumxpictures.com P.S. The more I think about this, the more I wonder if it has anything to do with Michael's use of a c-light. If the action is dark, perhaps the c-light was moved in too close and this resulted in a blown-out, halo-type effect. |
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | It's most obvious in shots where there is a drastic change in contrast. So, in shots where the skin of one of the darker skinned black girls is overlapping with that of one of the lighter skinned white guys, the blue or red line is very noticable. Hopefully, if sanchez_1960 is able to get his screenshots, illustrating the problem, posted, he will be able to include the corresponding time codes. If sanchez_1960 doesn't get the pictures posted in the next day or two, I will re-rent "Feeling Black 2" and get you the time codes of points where the problem is most apparent. |
| M.B. Senior Member 1679 Posts 2/01 | Somewhere along the line that master tape is getting fucked up. I'm pretty sure it's not your dvd authoring because I see the same colourless effect on the vhs, as well as the overlapping and blurry credits that was just talked about. It looks like the master tapes you guys are using are second or third generation for whatever reason. I'm not saying that they are, just that it looks that way. During Anal Expediation #2, Katja Kassin was getting fucked by Steve Holmes in a scene with Manuel, Ashley Blue, and Julie Night. The picture looked rally bad, colourless for about 10 minutes then all of a sudden the camera moved and it looked light a light came on or turned off and the picture looked pretty good after that, the colour had returned. It went back and forth twice during this scene I believe. But that still didn't change the overlapping double image people are talking about. I'm sure it's not the dvd authoring because like I said before, I see this on the vhs of PXP's movies as well. Someone over there is messing up the master tapes someway somehow.
|
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | |
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | I've sent the email to Steph. I've been in the US for a few days on business. Btw, I noticed on some PLX movies that the halo problem isn't on the main movie, but appears at "upcoming" movie preview at the end. So maybe it is the master tapes?
|
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | This is grabs from Full Anal Access 2 highlighing the problem. As you can see around the text, you get the chroma/halo effect. The overall picture looks very blury too. Here's how it is from Full Anal Access 3 (Which doesn't have the problem). Almost as good as other studios DVD Quality!
Edited by - sanchez_1960 on 3/14/2004 3:43:22 PM |
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | Brandon, if you look at the 3rd photo, you will see a good example of both conditions of this problem. Around the outside of Michael 7 Taylor's heads, you will see the blue halo. Around this inside of their hairlines, where their hair meets their skin, you will see the red halo. The two pictures that Sanchez provided, contrasting the credits of a movie with the problem and one without the problem, is a great example of we are seeing on some of PXP's discs. |
| M.B. Senior Member 1679 Posts 2/01 | It looks like the master tape they use isn't the original, or that it's a third or fourth copy. I see this in most if not all of PXP's releases and it's the reason why I refuse to even rent their movies anymore other than Mason's because for some reason her movies seem to escape this problem, why that is I don't know. I rent to find out if it's worth buying. If I know the quality is going to suck ass, I won't even bother with a rental because I already know what it's going to look like ahead of time. I have Full Anal Access #2 because I thought when I rented the tape that it was just a problem with the vhs, a bad tape or something. The action was so good in this movie I ordred the dvd thinking the picture would be much better, but when I watched the dvd there was no difference, it looked just as awful. The problem is with the tape somehow because this problem exists on their vhs releases as well. Edited by - M.B. on 3/14/2004 6:38:35 PM |
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | I think the problem here has come from mastering the discs. While I did write earlier that it may be a master tape problem, it can't be since the graphics used in the movie are fucked too. I doubt the authoring house even check the disc as it was finalised and ready to go out to replication. If they didn't notice the awful picture then they are hardly worth having as authoring studio and should be fired. I think the other Redlight and PXP owners and directors should be alerted this thread. Jewel De Nile is always going on about "I don't want that in my company", so maybe she should be saying "I don't want poor picture quality associated with my company"!! Brandon, if and when you find out the problem please let me know as I will be putting PXP and Redlight movies on hold for now on purchase. I can only rent when I'm living in the US so it’s going to be disappointing for me not getting to see my "otherwise" favourite two companies. You don't want to be recognised for poor quality, just like Extreme Associates was do you?
|
| howie Member 144 Posts 11/03 | |
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | |
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | Nuts Butt also arrived on my door this morning. However, I would'nt say the problem is as bad as some movies! If certainly needs to be fixed, i'm a little dissapointed I didn't cancel my pre order. I won't be pre ordering any more titles for now! Edited by - sanchez_1960 on 3/16/2004 3:11:57 AM |
| Brandon Iron BrandonIron.com 3832 Posts 3/02 | Thanks for the posts. Special thanks to sanchez for the screen captures. They really do illustrate the problem better than any words can describe. As I am out of my league on this, I will refer this to our DVD author and ask for his comments. Thanks for your help in identifying this problem. Of course we want to improve things. Anyone who is dissatisfied with any PXP production should return them to the point of purchase for refund/exchange. Platinum X Pictures does not sell directly to consumers but we will honour all returns that come back for quality issues. Thank you, Brandon |
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | |
| Brandon Iron BrandonIron.com 3832 Posts 3/02 | |
| SyberScott Senior Member 1462 Posts 1/03 | PXP & RLD's video quality on their DVDs. Some of the earlier ones had some pixelation There are some controls/settings on your |
| M.B. Senior Member 1679 Posts 2/01 | |
| howie Member 144 Posts 11/03 | |
| Brandon Iron BrandonIron.com 3832 Posts 3/02 | |
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | |
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | |
| Brandon Iron BrandonIron.com 3832 Posts 3/02 | This is really killing me..... If anyone who experiences problems with our dvds lives in the Los Angeles area and would be willing to bring your player and dvd into our offices, we would make it worth your while. Thank you! Brandon Edited by - Brandon Iron on 3/25/2004 9:17:20 AM |
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | Having gave up, i decided to get Bakers Dozen in the end. Cool movie :) If you look at time index 2 mins 37 seconds into the movie. You will see the effect is evident on Manuel's black shirt, you see a massive blue stripe as it blends into the background. Overall the picture is quite blury too. The effect appears on both my PC with LCD display, my Projector, Plasma and CRT TV's all with different DVD Players. All of which are high spec decks. |
| M.B. Senior Member 1679 Posts 2/01 | |
| howie Member 144 Posts 11/03 | I, as a complainant, do not appreciate the inference that I may have a marginal or inferior system. I have a Sony DAV-C770 Dream System with progressive scan and a Sony WEGA TV. I understand the stance, whether contrite or not, you are taking but before you further alienate PXP customers, I would like to hear that your studio is researching the issue at hand and that you will have a response in due time. You've expressed your incredulous disbelief often enough in this thread. |
| M.B. Senior Member 1679 Posts 2/01 | Hell, I'd bring my player down there and hook it up, but I'm way out in Toronto, so that isn't an option. Maybe the PXP guys are so used to seeing their movies look a certain way, that they can't see anything wrong with them, but I sure can. The picture is blurry, the colour (when these is some) bleeds from one image to another, and there are double images. Something is wrong, I rented the latest Latinas #5 (RLD) and it also looks to have a very dull picture, totally lifeless. Maybe Brandon should pop a movie in from another company to compare PXP/RLD movies to, might give them an idea of the difference we are seeing. |
| OREN Anarchy Films 250 Posts 12/03 | Oren |
| Brandon Iron BrandonIron.com 3832 Posts 3/02 | Howie: You took my post the wrong way. By stating the type of DVD player I use (it cost less than $200, by the way), I was not inferring that you or anyone else has an inferior system. I was only relaying the equipment that I use for informational purposes. Far from alienating customers, I think I go the extra mile towards looking for solutions. This business is my livelihood and I take it very seriously. Thank you for your patience. Brandon |
| howie Member 144 Posts 11/03 | |
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | Which Video connection are you using between the DVD player and TV? If you're using the Composite connection (the yellow jack), it could be masking the problem. The composite connection yields the worst color seperation of the three possible connectors. What may not be visible through compostite, could be very evident through the component or S-Video connections. This doesn't mean that there is a problem with the connections, just that component and S-Video will more accurately display what is on the disc. When I bought Lipstick & Lingerie earlier this week, I didn't do so blindly. I'm friendly with the people at the store and explained the problems that you are having with your discs. I told them that I'd like to see if L&L had the same problem as other discs before buying it. We checked their rental copy on their 13" tv with a composite connection and the disc looked good. When I got home, I found that it did, in fact, have the same problem. It wasn't as apparent on L&L as it was on Feeling Black 2. But it was definitely there. Also, the problem was more pronounced in an area of the disc that we didn't check (I don't think that we made it all the way through the opening credits at the store). After not seeing the problem on L&L at the store, I pulled the rental copy of FB2 to show them the problem. While it was very apparent on thier setup, I don't think that it was as clearly evident as it was when I watched it at home (it also may be due to the fact that I'm watching it on a 56" TV at home and they have a 13" TV in the store). |
| Brandon Iron BrandonIron.com 3832 Posts 3/02 | This may help us get to the root of the problem. I spoke with our DVD author last night and he informed me that it may have something to do with our lighting. Michael Stefano always uses a c-light that could cast shadows or otherwise contribute to different colour tempertures. This does not, however, account for the blurriness. His editors do the same work for him, Julian, and Jewel De'Nyle. We are confused as to why Michael's product seems to have the most problems. If the DVD author gets any more information to me, I will relay it. Thanks, Brandon |
| TonyC Comstock Films 2523 Posts 8/03 | I'd look into the step between your final edit and your DVD authoring. My best (but still not very good guess) is you have an extra digital --> analog and/or analog --> digital conversion in your image chain. Are you exporting MPEG2s directly from your edit suite and giving them to your DVD author, or are you dumping to tape and sending that over? If you're dumping to tape, are you doing it via firewire or SDI, or are you going out to tape via analog? If that's the case, that could certainly cause the problem discribed. Tech sucks. -T.C. |
| sanchez_1960 Member 582 Posts 2/03 | Man you are really using Yellow, Red and White leads? Man thats awful, Composite gives a real shit picture anyway! I am glad you are looking into it but as previously mention by other people. Its going to be hard for you to actually guess the souce of the problem unless you watch over closely each stage. As soon as you see the problem appear you'd have it sorted. Yet, you've gotta see the problem in the final product to know what your looking for huh! ;) |
| Sammyboy Member 308 Posts 8/01 | |
| Bill All-Star Member 5334 Posts 6/00 | I can't imagine that this problem has anything to do with lighting. In the Rita Faltoyano scene in Lipstick & Lingerie, there is a picture with a black frame on a white wall all the way across the room. The blue "halo" on the wall next to this picture was so visible that it almost looked as if the picture was backlit with a blue light (which isn't the case because the picture was hanging on the wall). |
| Brandon Iron BrandonIron.com 3832 Posts 3/02 | Thanks, everyone, for the input. TonyC: This is how we master our movies at Platinum X Pictures. Camera masters are edited on Macintosh G4 computers. The footage is digitized using firewire cables and Sony DSR-20 decks. The edit masters are run via firewire to DVCAM master tapes. The master tapes are digitized using DVD authoring software. Check disks are made that are reviewed by individual directors. Once approved, DLT's are made. These are the masters that are used by the DVD replicator. I will try to locate an S-video cable. I assume that this gives better resolution. I am worried that I am not seeing the problem because of the equipment that I am using. Again, all the feedback is appreciated. Many customers have big-screen TVs. We certainly don't want to provide an inferior product. Thank you, Brandon |
| Use the code below to link to this topic or a specific post. |
| URL of this thread |
| Link to this post with HTML |
| Link to this post with Forum Code |