In Kbitches 2: Crazy Cunts, a girl called Gabi is presented with her buttplug, makes a face and shakes her head No, but finally sucks on it. This happens repeatedly, and each time she appears to be genuinely disgusted.
In Anal Delinquent: Babysitters Blackmailed, Taurus Angel gets fucked in the ass, and when the guy tells her to suck his cock she protests loudly and makes faces before taking the dirty dick in her mouth. The other girl in the scene (Raquel Roper) tells her not to do it, appears in shock and makes a disgusted look when her friend does the deed. It's acting, but the dialogue and the situation make it very hot. It's unusual for the girl to protest and make faces while doing a2m.
I know this is an old post I'm replying to, and I know it's off topic, but that Sidney scene has another moment in it that is worth mentioning for Sidney's reluctance. At one point in the scene, Max is standing in the pool or hot tub and Sidney is on her knees giving him head. She seems content to do that but then Max turns around and tells her to lick his ass. She sighs deeply and her shoulders drop in resignation, but she musters the will to reach up and spread his ass cheeks and bury her face in there.
Hollie from Backroomcastingcouch.com He's fucking her ass in piledriver, then he pulls out and tells her to stick it. Initially she's like "oh no..." then he asks her how and tastes and she says "tastes like ass"
Not so sure if it's in the spirit of this topic but Karlie Montana does ATM in her scene with Dana Vespoli for Lesbian Anal POV. Don't remember if she's necessarily reluctant, but she's definitely not too happy to have done it.
There is a great reluctant A2M scene with two great stars Dana Dearmond and Gia Derza!
Initially the ATM scene was planned as Gia sitting on the top and Dana at the bottom.. As Dana rejected, Gia is conveyed..and it was shoot like that.. (this I came to know from one of the followers of Gia)
Old scenes but both Hillary Scott and Brooke Haven in Her First Anal Sex Series. They are convinced to try anal/do and the cameraman insists tasting the dick right out of their asses..super hot scenes because Hillary is afraid it's gonna taste like shit and Brooke smells it before tasting it lol. Once again it's all just acting but done really well
Rocco intimate castings with Alessandra Amore. After he has properly pounded her ass he offers his cock for her to suck. She reluctantly sniffs the cock and tries to dodge it a bit, then only sucks the tip a little. Rocco asks you have never done this before? And then, he makes her do ATM many times and asks you start to like it? to witch she responds mmhmm with a mouth full of cock.
as a absolute Teagan Presley obsessed fan. I have watched all her scenes. This particular teenage Spermaholics 2 scene is one of her very early and best scenes. I have watched this scene hundreds of times and she never shows any hesitation or uncertainty around the ATM parts. You can tell that both guys are massively sweet on her as you would expect as she is literally sensational looking and only 18 years old and yet so willing to be such a hardcore nasty filthy girl. There have been countless times over Teagan's career that doing Anal and DPs definitely made her feel under pressure and uncomfortable but she always got through it like a Queen.