New Pornstar Interviews - [more]
Introducing Lady LorReign

"Good oral on me turns me on. Also, knowing that my partner is enjoying themself,"
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 62 > Replace PC, with what?
AuthorPost
Juster
Member

67 Posts
3/03
Posted - Sep 24 2003 : 8:23AM
I'm about to replace my Dell Dimension P2 450 (20 Gig HD 128 meg RAM). I can't afford your dream system GS :), so how about some comments about current off-the-shelf stuff?

A 17" iMac with 160 Gig HD, 512 RAM on a single chip (making it expandable to a Gig) and Blue Tooth installed, runs just over 2 grand.

I can buy a similarly equipped Sony PCV-RS420 with a Sanyo 17" WS monitor for about 1,750.00

Most of my use concerns photo editing, word processing, wideband (cable) Internet access. Moreover, my daughter is about to graduate with a degree in IT. She tells me she's pretty good with .Net.

Any opinions on which is the better choice? Is there another choice I haven't considered? Should I make this old Dell run a while longer for some new advance I'm not aware of? Thanks!

nietzsche
Deactivated User

5470 Posts
8/03
Posted - Sep 24 2003 : 8:40AM
For what it's worth, I got mine from PCUSA and I'm generally pleased with it. I got a Pentium IV 2.4 Ghz, 512 RAM, 120 Gb hd, a cdrom, cd burner, and a 15' monitor for about $850. The only thing I don't like is the monitor, which is crappy.

Note: As of this writing the link is down. Try later. Sorry.

Edited by - nietzsche on 9/24/2003 8:42:29 AM

Saki
At-Large

2087 Posts
11/99
Posted - Sep 24 2003 : 10:04AM
Dell runs some pretty insane deals at the ends of their fiscal quarters and years to boost their financials. Even so, here's a current deal good through today at Dell Home:

Dell Dimension 8300
P4 2.8GHz w/ 800 MHz front side bus & Hyper Threading
Intel 875P chipset
1 GB 400 MHz dual channel DDR SDRAM, upgradable to 2GB/4 DIMMs
120 GB 7200 RPM Serial ATA Hard Drive
16x Max DVD-ROM
Free 2nd Bay 48x/24x/48x Max CD-RW Drive
128MB DDR GeForce FX 5200 Graphics Card with TV-Out and DVI
17" (16" viewable 0.25mm dot pitch) flat CRT monitor
SoundBlaster Live! 5.1 Digital Sound Card
Harman Kardon® HK-395 Speakers with Subwoofer
56K PCI Telephony Modem
Integrated Intel® PRO 10/100 Ethernet
Keyboard & Optical Mouse
8 USB 2.0 ports (2 front/6 back)
Windows XP Home
Microsoft Works Suite 2003
10 outlet Belkin SurgeMaster Gold
4 Year on-site maintenance

$1947 after mail in rebates and free shipping

The price can vary greatly depending on whether you want to fly with only a 1 year warranty, if you prefer Windows XP Professional or a better office productivity software package, different monitor, or a different Dell model (8300 is their non-gaming flagship line). I've seen deals on lower-end Dells for as little as $400; you can't build it yourself for that.

- Saki [faqs]

Evil_Rip
Senior Member

Power overwhelming
1117 Posts
12/99
Posted - Sep 24 2003 : 10:37AM
you may grad the dell system with Windows XP PRO. And since your daughter is a student. She can buy you office software with her academic discount. Which is far far less than what dell will charge you.
And that's not all. Photoshop, Premiere Pro also can be purchased with academic discount.

If your daughter also plans on using your computer for .NET programming you may go for the PC.

If not, then either choice is fine. make sure you calculate in the cost of software. And how much you're willing to spend.

oreb
Member

92 Posts
6/03
Posted - Sep 24 2003 : 11:03AM
One of my friends is the head programer for a pretty large company and he said Compaq and Gateway computers had the least problems, with Dell and IBM being the worst. He said HP's were average. Of course he owns a few G4's so depending on what the computer is for I would lean towards a Mac for anything professional.
 
Saki
At-Large

2087 Posts
11/99
Posted - Sep 24 2003 : 11:15AM
I actually think Dell has the best desktop build quality--that's from both personal and work experience--their stuff is easy to repair/upgrade and they use name-brand components. Compaq and Gateway have improved quite a bit over the years, but I don't care for their styling personally. HP is near the bottom (mass consumer emphasis). IBM is who you want to buy your laptop from, not a desktop.

I don't have any particular beefs with Macs other than most of the software I'd like to run is on a Windows platform. I love Apple's industrial design capabilities...if manufacturer on the PC side could put that sense of style into a rock solid PC, then they would do quite well. Sony comes closest, but their machines are flimsy and overpriced.

- Saki [faqs]

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14594 Posts
3/02
Posted - Sep 24 2003 : 1:04PM
My experience with IBM is - sometimes you win, sometimes you lose. I would want to see reviews of the model I was interested in so I could make an informed decision.
DenverDon
Benevolent

Firmly Embedded in Depravity
5914 Posts
7/02
Posted - Sep 24 2003 : 1:41PM
I'm a Micron fan, been using them for years.

Not necessarily the cheapest on the market, but reliable workhorses that have been flawless for me.

DenverDon

Anteros
Member

117 Posts
4/03
Posted - Sep 24 2003 : 10:14PM
Build your computer yourself. Its not hard. If you're scared you can get a barebones kit and just put in the rest of the components, optical/floppy/hard drives are all a a piece of cake to install. I got a asus a7n8x dlx mobo w 2500+ amd athlon w/barton core, 512mb pc2700 corsair ram, 2 120gb western digital hdds, radeon 9500 128mb vid card setup with dual 17" Trinitron monitors. All for just over $700.

With the rebate sales for most of the items at best buy and circuit city, a fantastic pc doesnt need to ever go over $1000.

Juster
Member

67 Posts
3/03
Posted - Sep 25 2003 : 9:15AM
Thanks Saki,

I've been checking Dell all along; but I'm noticing their pricing structure is getting kind of high. The Sony is one step down in processing speed and lacks HT, but has a DVD +/- RW, the same number of USP 2 ports, plus a firewire port or two. And then there's the monitor. A 17" CRT is old technology. Add about 400 bucks for a 17" TFT active matrix, and the price goes close to 2,500.00! More for a WS format that I don't think Dell even sells. A lot of money for a 32 bit machine, if you ask me.

What I might do, is what you suggested. Buy a slower machine and add the other components.

Or maybe I'll just wait for 64 bit technology :)

Saki
At-Large

2087 Posts
11/99
Posted - Sep 25 2003 : 9:57AM
It really depends on what your priorities are. You can add a firewire card for less than $40 and a multi-format DVD burner for about $130 now and install them yourself.

The Dell vs. Sony thing is not exactly apples to apples. The Sony only comes with a 1-year mail-in warranty vs. 4-years on site (you can save a couple hundred bucks if you only do a 1-year Dell warranty). There's twice as much RAM (faster RAM at that) in the Dell than the Sony. Ditto on the video RAM on the Radeon card. Serial ATA (150 MB/sec) vs. Ultra ATA/100 (100 MB/sec) on the hard drive. Other differences include the optical mouse, H/K speakers with subwoofer, a non-integrated sound card, and an integrated modem.

CRT vs. FP display also depends on what you're using it for. From an image quality and refresh standpoint, the standard flat screen CRT beats all but the best flat panels. But if asthetics and space savings is the priority, then maybe it doesn't matter. I use my CRT for photo editing and gaming, and I paid like $200 for it a couple of years ago. But my wife loves her 15" flat panel. I like flat panels too, but having used laptops for years, even though they're getting better all the time, they don't match the brightness, sharpness, and viewing angle of CRTs. Finally, there's a significant price difference between a DVI (digital) vs. analog flat panel monitor...

Personally, if I were to buy something in this price range, I'd either get a widescreen laptop or buy a stripped-down performance platform and then add the components I wanted (such as a monitor, more RAM, and a DVD-burner).

- Saki [faqs]

Edited by - saki on 9/25/2003 10:01:28 AM

Juster
Member

67 Posts
3/03
Posted - Sep 25 2003 : 1:46PM
Good point! Looks like I'll be reevaluating - again.
AlexPanzer
Deactivated User

1593 Posts
6/03
Posted - Sep 30 2003 : 12:30PM
Well, the best way to get an excellent computer is to build one yourself. www.newegg.com sells many parts for very low price, take for example a 120 GB SATA Hard Drive, NewEgg sells it for $105 while it is being advertised at a local PC store for $150 and retails (MSRP) at $170, generaly you save yourself $65, which is good. Heres a list of parts that you can buy at NewEgg and make yourself a great computer for the lowest price:


- Intel Pentium 4 Processor at 2.4Ghz (C-model) which can be maximum overclocked to 3.5Ghz (with water cooling) which beats the most powerful P4 3.2Ghz processor.

- ABIT IS7-E motherboard which is a great board, 800FSB, SATA, 10/100 MB LAN / Cable / DSL connection.

- 1 GB of Corsair XMS Memory (PC-3200C2PT), 2x512 sticks, Corsair XMS is the best PC memory maker, comes with lifetime support and warranty.

- Western Digital 200GB SATA at 7,200 RPM, great hard drive with a lot of space.

- Fortissimo III 7.1 sound card, a decent card that is inexpensive and has all the features that you need for supperb sound.

- Albatron GeForce FX 5200 AGP 8X video card, a decent video card for you which can play games with good quality, this card isnt the best one but I figured since you do mostly photo stuff then you dont need the top-notch 3D VPU.

- Samsung CDRW/DVD Combo Drive 52x24x52 CD-RW 16X, you can do both - watch the DVDs and burn the CDs with this all-in-one (except DVD-R) device.

- Kingwin (BLACK) All Aluminum 10-Bay Mid tower case (model K-11-BK-WM) which can be any Dell, Compaq, HP, or Gateway case.

- ENERMAX EG365P-VE(FCA) 350 Watt power supply unit, probably the best power supply unit that you can buy for a good price.

- Floppy Drive, any can work, I suggest the one by Mitsumi.

Optional Stuff:

- NEC/Mitsubishi 19" CRT VGA Monitor Model FE991SB-BK an 18" viewable monitor, great monitor.

- Ideazon Zboard Interchangable Keyboard, unique keyboard that lets you to change its buttons - you can buy the button sets later for programs such as Adobe Photoshop. The standard keayboard includes a keayboard with buttons for Microsoft Word and Internet Explorer. When I say buttons I mean the buttons that have shortcuts and commands written on then for a specific application.

- Logitech MX 310 Mouse, excellent and cheap mouse.

- Creative I-Trigue 2.1 3300 3-Piece Speaker, extreme speaker set that has extreme sound quality and doesnt takes a lot of space.

$750 is for neccessary components
$409 is for the optional stuff
$1159 is total price for both neccessary and optional component.

To put this stuff together and make it work all you need is a screwdriver, an operating system on a cd (Win 98 or Win XP, for any other OS than Win XP you need a floppy drive to startup). It will take you 3 hours the most to put it all to work.

I think that this choice is the best one because Dell/Gateway/Compaq/HP will definatly ask you to pay more than $1800 for similar kind of setting and they will put the most cheapest components that they can put into the computer. I just ordered $2,700 worth of components at NewEgg, I never assembled a computer before in my life but I am more than confident.

Juster
Member

67 Posts
3/03
Posted - Sep 30 2003 : 3:26PM
I hadn't even considered this idea. I guess I am still prejudiced from the days when laptops were just for salesmen.

A look at the Inspirion 8500 series, configured very well, is at the same price point.

Thanks for pointing this out!

Juster
Member

67 Posts
3/03
Posted - Sep 30 2003 : 3:35PM
Thanks for taking the time to write this out! I have built PCs in the past (a 286 that I later upgraded to a 486) when it wasn't completely critical that the machine is up and running continually.

And then there are those infuriating waits on long distance, only to get a tech who can't help. :)

 
GaySatyr
Senior Member

Half dirty ol' man; half horny ol' goat!
1684 Posts
10/00
Posted - Sep 30 2003 : 5:06PM
The truth of the matter is that, given the quality of components available, and given the lack of competent tech support - even from major vendors, building your own makes sense if you have even a modicum of technical skills and computer savvy.

Check out this thread: <iDream System </i

It's really easy, and, by having gone through the entire process, you become your own tech support - generally at a much higher competence level that you can find elsewhere.

In terms of purchasing off the rack - Micron and Dell are probably two of the better choices. Gateway has been using less well-specked parts (read: cheap) for a while now. Compaq/HP is fine for a buy-it/throw-it-away unit - no room for expansion or upgrade and a guarantee that you will shred your hands & fingers trying.

Sony has been putting together some really well-equipped multi-media boxes lately: Their DVD-burner inclusive boxes are worth a look.

~ GaySatyr

Anteros
Member

117 Posts
4/03
Posted - Sep 30 2003 : 10:06PM
Unless you need the mobility I wouldnt go with a laptop. Generally you can get a desktop with the same specs as a laptop for half the price.

Alex, good luck putting your box together, it was nerver wracking my first time, but after that its much easier and I wonder how I ever could have bought a premade machine before. Post your OC'ing result, and what methods you used. I'd be interested to read it.

Saki
At-Large

2087 Posts
11/99
Posted - Oct 1 2003 : 1:15AM
I would agree with that unless you really wanted a flat TFT monitor or a widescreen TFT monitor, since those will run you probably $400-600 additional. When you tack on that expense, you are in the price range of a nice laptop.

- Saki [faqs]




Jump To: