New Pornstar Interviews - [more]
Hazel Heart Interview

"I LOVE the taste of myself actually. I love the smell and the taste and playing with myself afterwards! It’s fun."
All Forums > The Porn Pool > The Porn Pool Forum Page 511 > Should "extreme" content be flagged?
AuthorPost
MDJames
Member


21 Posts
6/04
Posted - May 12 2007 : 12:58PM
I have an interesting question for the group, including the mods...

Should "extreme" content be flagged in ADT as a separate content description?

By "extreme" I mean violent content such as slapping, spitting, choking, gagging, fish-hooking, stepping, breast-slapping, and eating of (non-edible) panties. The occasional ass-slap in a scene wouldn't qualify as "extreme", but excessive ass-slapping to where you clearly see red marks would.

The reason why I ask is that there have been several videos that have delved into this area and it probably would be helpful for the consumers (yes we are all pretty much consumers here) if this kind of content were to be flagged. Those who would eagerly look for this stuff would know what to look for, and those would not care for this stuff would also know to stay away from it.

I've been looking up previous threads on this subject and the one line I constantly hear is "this stuff sells". I happen to disagree with that argument because there is no way for us to know whether or not it really sells if we don't differentiate it from the videos that don't have that content. Just SAYING that it sells is a meaningless cop-out. You have to have something to back it up. So I suggest we go ahead and put it to the test.

What do you think?

* MD James

Edited by - mdjames on May 12 2007

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14594 Posts
3/02
Posted - May 12 2007 : 1:34PM
If, by content description, you are referring to the categories listed in the movie search, then it might be problematic. The categories are not inclusive of all sex acts, they simply attempt to convey the theme of the movie. Thus, if a movie only has one scene with some excessive slapping, extreme doesn't qualify as the theme.

Furthermore, steph and drew don't sit down and view every movie before categorizing it, nor would they have time to do so. How, then, would this categorization be accomplished?

Finally, regarding your argument about whether or not it sells - seen any bisexual content in your 'straight' porn lately? I thought not. Companies may take a flier into uncharted territory but they aren't going to keep pushing unwanted content on the market - at least, not profitably.

Porn Scout
Deactivated User

3735 Posts
10/02
Posted - May 12 2007 : 4:40PM
Yeah, I agree with Hardware. The sheer logistics of having to view and categorize so many titles makes this a near impossible task. Plus, it opens up a whole line of controversy with people disagreeing on how stuff should be tagged. Also, I think the studios themselves do a pretty good job marketing their most extreme titles.
MDJames
Member

21 Posts
6/04
Posted - May 12 2007 : 4:50PM
You raise some good technical points, Hardware, and I understand how difficult it would be to flag it from Drew and Steph's perspective.

Maybe, then, this is something the reviewers can help out in. Obviously we're watching these videos, we're noticing the content, maybe there can be an extra text box for any additional categories that should be included. I would also suggest adding an area in the forum as sort of an "appeal" if someone feels the wrong category was listed. If someone feels that a video was given the wrong category, they plead their case there.

As for your other question, it's hard to say whether bisexual scenes were eliminated because of the marketplace or because the directors and talent decided on their own not to dabble further with it. I doubt too many adult studios engage in market research or have some kind of "Nielsen" system set up. I'm sure that most of us go by who's on the box cover and what the descriptions give.

* MD James

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14594 Posts
3/02
Posted - May 12 2007 : 6:40PM
I agree that porn companies probably don't do market research, but they still have somebody dictating what they sell - the distributors. The distributors listen to the buyers, who say what they want more of. If that bisexual title is languishing on the shelf while Ass Whores From Planet Gape is impossible to keep in stock then the result is clearly going to be less bisexual porn and more AWFPG.
 
loz
Member

UK
134 Posts
1/05
Posted - May 12 2007 : 8:58PM
Eating of non-edible panties? What the hell films have that in?
the unknown pervert
Deactivated User

I'd like to stay but I've got a plane to catch.
3243 Posts
5/06
Posted - May 13 2007 : 6:31AM
I'm guessing the ones Ron Jeremy is in where the catering is late arriving to the set.
RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - May 14 2007 : 1:35AM
Which country's flag would you like to put on it?



Jump To: