Featured New Release
Box cover for Elegant Beauty Needs Passionate Sex
Elegant Beauty Needs Passionate Sex
Studio: Vixen
Release date: 7/26/2026


all new releases
All Forums > The Porn Pool > The Porn Pool Forum Page 668 > Substituting fisting?
AuthorPost
shayhiri
Member

Sofia, Bulgaria
15 Posts
9/04
Posted - Oct 26 2004 : 2:49PM
Hi, people! I'm new to the American market and thus find some matters extremely confusing. I'd greatly appreciate any insight from a producer or a customer's opinion.

The question : What exactly is forbidden in the DVD US porn - and to what EXTENT? I'm mainly interested in fisting and pissing. They seem hard to find, yet not at all non-existent! (Is this by any chance a matter of conflicting laws in different states?) Where do we draw the line?

I could easily assume that if fisting was not forbidden, DAP would be far less popular - fisting just looks a whole lot better IMO. (Same with pissing/ATM.) Please correct me if I'm wrong.

I've been shooting a movie for the European market and I was wondering how to "translate" certain scenes for a US distribution - instead of just editing them out. For example, would dildo&cock DAP be a fair substitute for anal fisting? Please shed some light, I'm just trying to provide only the best product and as much as I detest restrictions, I'd rather find a way to deal with them - efficiently.

ShiWarrior
Senior Member

1170 Posts
8/01
Posted - Oct 26 2004 : 4:32PM
Hi

fisting is a market, i mean, there is a market for that sort of thing..

i do not know about US laws, as i live in the UK

the UK law specifically says "no fisting" , "no pissing" "no beastiality"

i know beastiality isnt allowd in the US, not sure about fist and that though, hopefully some one will comment.
but it is out there, just got to know where to look i guess ?

Regards & Thanks, ShiWarrior - - BIG Breast Fan - -

shayhiri
Member

Sofia, Bulgaria
15 Posts
9/04
Posted - Oct 26 2004 : 5:47PM
Sure there are online (and regular?) shops like xxx-imports that sell all that beautiful stuff. So if it CAN be done, why so few people do it?

Another question : I've seen a lot of fisting and pissing by Max Hardcore? Have I been watching Euro-releases? Most probably.

Please help sort this out! Or just say what you would like to see in a movie - it would help both sides. Thanks!

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14594 Posts
3/02
Posted - Oct 26 2004 : 6:30PM
There is no federal law banning fisting or pissing. The federal law leaves the definition of obscene material up to individual communities. While the reasoning behind this ruling is that New York shouldn't have to live by the standards of Peoria, nor vice-versa, the upshot is that there is no comprehensive list of acceptable sex acts versus prosecutable acts. It also means that successfully defending yourself in one community does nothing to prevent prosecutors from taking you to court somewhere else. That can get expensive, even if you win every time. Most companies would rather avoid the hassle and just put out what everybody else is putting out so as not to come to the attention of the authorities.

If you want to include pissing and fisting in your US releases, I suggest that you start by talking to your distributors. If you can't get them to distribute such movies then what the public might consider acceptable is a moot point.

PS - Yes, Max Hardcore releases different versions for the European market.

Mr. Peter
Member

423 Posts
11/03
Posted - Oct 27 2004 : 10:24AM
Well I have been thinking about it too.

For me as anal fan the idea should be somewhere around
dildos substitutes. Speaking of anal fisting what about
a hand styled dildo? Some poster from bussiness, i cant remember exactly who, mentioned that they are going to use
four fingers from each hand = 8 fingers up the hole.

For me a well designed dildo with a shape close to a fist (but not nessesary hand model) will do the thing. U know it has to be big enough, I mean wider at the bottom (end) with some kind of bulb at the end u know because sharply shaped one exactly matching a hand would probably harm someones ass or simply wont feel good and uncomfortable.

Mr. Peter

 
Scott Kinney
xxximports.com

New Jersey
369 Posts
5/02
Posted - Oct 27 2004 : 7:49PM
This won't seem terribly surprising...I don't think there are substitutes for fisting or pissing per se... They are acts that are either part of the sexual choreography, or they're not. A fisting fan becomes pretty grumpy when a scene looks like it's leading up to fisting and then nothing happens. So, it might be better to script the scene differently if you aren't going to shoot fisting content.

Also, I don't think the hand-shaped dildo is a substitute.

Just a note to Hardware: The vagueness of the federal statutes could also be interpreted to mean that *any* sexual content is prosecutable. Even if you look over Federal, State and local obscenity prosecutions over the last 7 years or so you'll find 2 or 3 that involve fisting or pissing. The others involve pretty much mainstream material.

Scott Kinney
Diversified Video Associates
www.xxx-imports.com

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14594 Posts
3/02
Posted - Oct 27 2004 : 9:01PM
I agree. My point was simply that producers seek safety in numbers. Being in the herd doesn't eliminate risk, but leaving the herd is likely to increase it.
Scott Kinney
xxximports.com

New Jersey
369 Posts
5/02
Posted - Oct 27 2004 : 9:21PM
This isn't really supported by prosecutorial record. I don't think that Elyse Metcalf, for example, felt she stood out from 'the herd'.


Scott Kinney
Diversified Video Associates
www.xxx-imports.com

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14594 Posts
3/02
Posted - Oct 27 2004 : 9:31PM
The prosecutorial record doesn't come into it because I didn't say they FIND safety in numbers, I said they SEEK it.
Joey Starr
Senior Member

Still wanking after all these years.
8082 Posts
10/00
Posted - Oct 27 2004 : 10:16PM
Actually pissing is OK as long as it's solo. I've seen R18 pissing DVDs ("Pissing in Nature" and the like) in London sex shops.

Watersports on the other hand is not something that is permitted by British censors.

Joey Starr
Senior Member

Still wanking after all these years.
8082 Posts
10/00
Posted - Oct 27 2004 : 10:17PM
Just to clarify, watersports is people pissing on other people.
ShiWarrior
Senior Member

1170 Posts
8/01
Posted - Oct 28 2004 : 9:00AM
actually no, R18's are actually US XXX, penetration are shown on R18 but it is ilegal to sell in this country
thats the way i see it, Joey u may be right

Regards & Thanks, ShiWarrior - - BIG Breast Fan - -

shayhiri
Member

Sofia, Bulgaria
15 Posts
9/04
Posted - Oct 30 2004 : 8:50AM
A big thanks to Hardware and Scott Kinney for providing the two sides to a story! Now I can make a much better informed decision.

And, Scott, you rock! You'll be hearing from me.

Skeeter Kerkove
Member

967 Posts
2/03
Posted - Nov 6 2004 : 2:06AM
Fisting is a love story. There are over 6 thousand Sodomy Law of the Land VHS and DVD wandering around the United States. It has vaginal and anal fisting in it. I am really proud as a peacock about it. Hopefully since I so bluntly put it out there, other outlaws will follow suit. God Bless America! Freedom, sweet Libery.
If you want sex that is just so hardcore it is wrong. Check out Sodomy Law of the Land. Us Americans kick ass, with a love and care you don't find too often.
I love fisting so much, we put it on the tour page of Bridgettes website. Demanding double anal since January 1999, God Bless you Bridgette Kerkove.
Skeeter Kerkove "King of Sodom" Rock N Roll all night and film women getting sodomized everyday! Porn producer, director, performer. I am a huge fan of hardcore porn and I love
p_ramezap
Senior Member

1549 Posts
5/03
Posted - Nov 6 2004 : 11:24AM
And God bless anyone who has the balls to put out fisting scenes. But what I don't understand is if it's illegal to have fisting in your film, then how can some people get away with it. Then you have easter eggs issue, which might have something like fisting or puking in it. I don't think there is a clear definition of what is illegal and what is not.
 
Sir Noel Plum
Senior Studmuffin

1001 Posts
2/03
Posted - Nov 6 2004 : 12:32PM
That's not quite correct. The UK law is as vague as it has always been and there is no specific guidance just a general ground for prosecution on material that 'has a tendency to deprave and corrupt'.
What you are maybe confusing with the law is the current guidelines for R18 as decided by the BBFC which is a body supposedly independent of the govt. To sell a video in the UK it must have a BBFC certificate but this does not apply to material from abroad. Any material from abroad is exempt from BBFC classification on grounds of fair trade but customs tend to follow the BBFC nowadays so that broadly speaking anything that would be granted a BBFC classification should get through customs.
Bear in mind the BBFC guidelines can be reviewed at any time and the changes the last few years were as a result of a huge public consultation convincing the BBFC that attitudes had changed. Also bear in mind that the BBFC has a great deal of leeway and so could decide to allow a fisting scene in a lesbian sex educational film in just the same way as years ago it allowed scenes of intercourse to be shown in 'The Lovers Guide' at a time when it censored all such scenes from any other movie.

SNP.

Scott Kinney
xxximports.com

New Jersey
369 Posts
5/02
Posted - Nov 6 2004 : 1:53PM
Peter,

It isn't illegal, at least not at the Federal or state level. Full stop, end of sentence.

Scott Kinney
Diversified Video Associates
www.xxx-imports.com




Jump To: