more performer info on...

Broken Heart

All Forums > Gay DVD Talk > Gay DVD Talk Forum Page 22 > The Broken Hearts Club
AuthorPost
joeblow69
Member


946 Posts
2/00
Posted - Mar 17 2001 : 12:21AM
Well, I finally got around to seeing this one, and I have to say I was disappointed.

There was no nudity, and when Dean Cain did kiss another guy, they shot it from the back of Dean's head, so they could have been faking it. Bummer

As far as the story goes, it was funny at times and sad at times, and a little bit too melodramatic here and there. To be honest, it seemed like a really watered down version of Queer as Folk. Some of the plot lines really reminded me of QAF.

Overall, it was entertaining, but I don't know if I would ever want to watch it again.

raytrade
Member

Los Angeles, CA
15 Posts
6/00
Posted - Mar 18 2001 : 11:17PM
I just watched the DVD last night, and I totally thought it reminded me of QAF too! I think I liked it quite a bit more than joeblow69- it was really touching and made me appreciate my circle of gay friends that much more. I consider it one of the best gay-themed movies I've ever seen.
joeblow69
Member

946 Posts
2/00
Posted - Mar 18 2001 : 11:49PM
I don't know, maybe I was being a little too hard on the flick. It just wasn't what I expected. They call it a romantic comedy, but there's only a little romance, and while it is funny in spots, it sure as hell isn't a comedy.

I'm also not sure why it even got an R rating. Sure there was some drug use, and some swearing, but no nudity at all, and not even much suggested sex. (and I REALLY was hoping to see Dean Cain's butt, too!)

I'll admit to not having seen too many of these "gay themed" movies so maybe I was expecting too much. The best I can do is compare it to my fav gay movie, Trick.

I can watch Trick over and over, and love every minute of it (especially the drag queen in the bathroom!) Every time I watch Trick, it makes me just feel happy to be gay.

The Broken Hearts Club, however, didn't really do anything for me. The characters seemed pretty one dimensional, and it didn't really even bother me when the really bad thing happened to that person. (maybe I'm too coldhearted!) They didn't flesh out the characters enough, and I kept thinking, "How the hell can the star afford such a nice house and car when he works as a waiter at a restuarant??"

netguy
Member

687 Posts
12/99
Posted - Mar 19 2001 : 8:50PM

Sorry, but I have to be Ebert on this one...A BIG THUMBS UP!

This was a touching and heartwarming story with an enjoyable cast. I wasn't expecting a whole lot of nudity or sex but just a nice story, and that's what they deliver.
I especially found the storyline between Marshall and Howie quite touching and Howies speach on the porch really choked me up! The other storylines were cute and nice and maybe the weak part of the movie is there were too many that just skimmed the surface. But overall I liked it.

Trick is one of my all time favorites too and this comes in a close second! Maybe I'm just a big sap but I highly recommend it and see it as a nice departure from the graphic, "let's see how far we can push the envelope this week" on Queer as Folk.

Edited by - netguy on Mar 29 2001

Edited by - netguy on Mar 30 2001

netguy
Member

687 Posts
12/99
Posted - Mar 30 2001 : 12:00AM
For those of you who are into Napstering....

Soundtrack...I really liked "Young Hearts Run Free", anyway here's the list in case you want to grab some mp3's

Tracks :
1. The Miricles "Love Machine"
2. Giorgio Moroder vs. Danny Tenglia "From Here To Eternity" (radio edit)
3. Shannon "Let The Music Play" (Junior Vasquez Mix)
4. Barry Harris "Beg For It" (Mad Tizzy Mix)
5. Kim English "Time for Love"
6. G.T.S. feat. Loleatta Hollaway "Share My Joy"
7. Kim English "Learn 2 Love"
8. Kim Mazelle "Young Hearts Run Free"
9. Mary Beth Maziarz "Close To You"
10. Mary Beth Maziarz "We've Only Just Begun"


Edited by - netguy on Mar 30 2001




Jump To: