New Pornstar Interviews - [more]
Introducing Natasha Carter

"Dirty talk is a really big thing for me."
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 62 > Unusually authored DVD - Gangbangs of NY
AuthorPost
VideoSan All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

168 Posts
6/03
Posted - Oct 11 2003 : 11:00PM
I recently received Gangbangs of New York (from Avalon Enterprises) as a rental DVD from xrentdvd. This DVD is an unusually authored DVD. Perhaps the DVD experts
here could comment on my description below.

This DVD will not play at all in my GoVideo deck. (I get the Unable to Read Disc message)

The DVD will play in my DVD drive on my laptop, using WMP.
WMP says there's one title, with 11 chapters. It says the title estimated time is 25 seconds. I can doubleclick for a given chapter and it always thinks the total time for the chapter is 25 seconds (the length of the first chapter). When each chapter starts, the elapsed time goes back to 0:00. The chapters lengths are approximately: 1) :25 2) :37 3) 21:30 4) 12:00 5) 13:00 6) 9:30 7) 17:00 8) 10:00 (for a total movie time of around 82 minutes).
Chapter 9 is the main menu, Chapter 10 is the scene selection menu, and Chapter 11 is the photo gallery.

For almost all DVDs I encounter, and play on the laptop, I get the complete time for a title when it's highlighted on the bar on the right-hand display. Not the case with this DVD, which seems to be confusing the DVD player's timing mechanism. (Perhaps that's why it won't play on the GoVideo deck?)

I have one more DVD deck - a Toshiba - I tried the disc and it didn't play on that machine either.

Edited by - videosan on Oct 12 2003

Flash All-Star Supporter
Golden Age Classic

11018 Posts
5/01
Posted - Oct 12 2003 : 10:53PM
Are you sure that those are all chapters. It sounds more like they are titles, which would fit the scenario that you described. As the photo gallery would be it's own title, main menu and scene selection menu as well. If each section of the film was on it's own title with it's own time code, that would cause the counter to restart for each one. It would also account for the short titles in the beginning if one was say the company logo and the opening of the film. Several companies have used this format in the past (Caballero and VCX are the first examples that come to mind) but never quite to this extent that I have seen. However, if each chapter really is a chapter, that's slightly more odd, and nothing that I have ever encountered before.
VideoSan All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

168 Posts
6/03
Posted - Oct 13 2003 : 4:56PM
Yes, they are all Chapters, under one Title. I popped in another DVD (Who's Your Daddy 3) and in contrast it had 7 Titles, each with some chapters. It seems to me that Avalon has authored this DVD strangely, being that 2 other DVD decks I have cannot read this disc, and they have rarely not been able to handle discs.
Flash All-Star Supporter
Golden Age Classic

11018 Posts
5/01
Posted - Oct 13 2003 : 11:15PM
That's an odd DVD then, I've never seen one done like that.



Jump To: