Featured New Release
Box cover for Chloe Cherry Is Euphoric
Chloe Cherry Is Euphoric
Studio: Team Skeet
Release date: 7/28/2026


all new releases
All Forums > Tech Talk > Tech Talk Forum Page 56 > VHS to DVD transfer
AuthorPost
Mojo
Deactivated User

1223 Posts
9/03
Posted - Jun 26 2004 : 10:22AM
What would it take for me to transfer VHS to DVD? Can I use a PC DVD-RW in conjunction with a video recorder in some way?

I ask because I would like to transfer a load of my old VHS titles to DVD.

Saki
At-Large

2087 Posts
11/99
Posted - Jun 26 2004 : 10:35AM
There are a few ways to do this, but in order to use a DVD-RW burner on your PC, you'll need some sort of video capture hardware--usually a video capture card or an external USB/Firewire equivalent. Then you'll need to have software that captures, edits, and burns the transferred footage to DVD. That software may or may not come with the video capture hardware.

An alternative would be to get a standalone DVD recorder that would hook up to your TV and VCR.

- Saki [faqs]

Mojo
Deactivated User

1223 Posts
9/03
Posted - Jun 26 2004 : 1:31PM
Will Nero 6 do the trick?

You say that I need some added hardware in the form of a motion capture card. But I thought that the motion capture card would come with the DVD-RW?

Saki
At-Large

2087 Posts
11/99
Posted - Jun 26 2004 : 1:57PM
No, unfortunately it doesn't work that way. How are you going to plug your VCR into your PC? DVD drives don't come with composite or S-Video inputs, and they don't have the chips and software to actually capture the *incoming* video. DVD drives can *write* the video to a DVD once it has been captured, but something else needs to do the capturing.

You're looking for something in this category. Note that not all of the listings allow you to capture from a video input--you'll have to make sure that it says you can do what you're trying to do.

- Saki [faqs]

Kperv
The Cuddler

*struck
(She slipped)

1818 Posts
1/04
Posted - Jun 26 2004 : 2:20PM
How much are you willing to spend?

I've got a Pioneer HDD+DVD recorder.
It works perfect out of the box. Great picture quality.
But it'll set you back somewhere between $700-$1000.

To get a similar picture quality with a PC you'll need a pretty decent capture card, and unless you're a bit of a geek (I admit to being one myself :-) you should probably count on spending quite some time setting up the system and configuring the software.

 
VideoSan All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

168 Posts
6/03
Posted - Jun 26 2004 : 7:54PM
The Panasonic DMR-E75V is a combination VHS and DVD Recorder unit. It's currently available at Sam's Club for just under $400, and it comes with 10 DVD-RAMs to boot. It will create DVDs using DVD-RAM or DVD-R. (Not DVD+R,
DVD+RW or DVD-RW). Note that the DVD-R can be recorded
at a 2-hour density, a 6-hour density, or an 8-hour
density. As expected, picture quality diminishes. Consider it the same as VHS from SP to LP to EP. Once the DVD-R is
"finalized" you can play it on most any DVD player.
Here is a link to the manual.

Edited by - VideoSan on 6/26/2004 7:57:32 PM

neondon
Member

134 Posts
5/04
Posted - Jun 26 2004 : 8:13PM
Do these things:

1) Buy a panasonic DRM -E50 from Amazon.com or Circuitcity.com (having a sale)

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00008IP5L/qid=1088294765/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1_etk-electronics/102-9796852-4322562?v=glance&s=electronics&n=172282

2)Connect it to your VCR and TV.

3) Buy this DVD-R which is recommended for this Panasonic. It is the best blank and has the best price.

http://shop.store.yahoo.com/supermediastore/prodisc-4x-dvd-r-silver-47gb.html

You might like this setup so much like I did and get 2 more.

jamesn
Senior Member

Cambridge, MA
750 Posts
1/04
Posted - Jun 26 2004 : 8:31PM
...paging tony c..
if you're willing to invest some time and money, i'd catch him when he's got a free moment.

if the imperative is just to get your tapes and home movies onto disc, there's no shortage of capture devices under 100-dollars. if you've got a desktop, the cheapest way to do it is a tv tuner card from ati, asus, hauppage, etc. they start around 40 dollars and make up for fancy software by letting you watch animal planet on your pc.

if you've got a laptop or don't want to take apart your box, pinnacle, avermedia, and a million others make usb 2.0 boxes that probably come with somewhat more substantial of a software package.

for my ridiculously ghetto filmaking skills, i've had good luck with plextor's usb box i picked up scratch and dent at microcenter. it's amazingly functional for what it does-take audio and video signals and convert them into divx. it's admittedly limited, but it works-hook it up to a vcr or dvcam, and it'll get you something to put on disc for around 60-90 dollars new.

the best deal out there right now is the nec-2510 for 80 bucks on newegg. it's the dual layer version of one of the best writers on the market and while it's average for c2 accuracy and the reading end, you're interested in writing from your hd and it's better than almost anything out there at any price for write quality. stay away from liteons and sonys(usually liteons) if you're looking at dvd-recorders, they've yet to put out one that doesn't burn coasters on media it doesn't like.

Mojo
Deactivated User

1223 Posts
9/03
Posted - Jun 27 2004 : 6:20AM
Thanks for all the advise and suggestions so far. I think my best bets so far are VidScan's Panasonic DVD recorder, or jamesboston's suggestion of the nec-2510.
Saki
At-Large

2087 Posts
11/99
Posted - Jun 27 2004 : 10:57AM
The NEC-2510 is a DVD burner. You'll still need something to capture the video on your PC hard drive (like james' recommendations for external capture boxes).

I'm really, really weary of Panasonic DVD players, especially early technology models. I went through a nightmare of bad optical pickup units when my then-new player wouldn't play 20% of the discs. When I took it in--directly to the factory--near the end of the warranty, they tried to charge me $200 when I picked it up because it was then out of warranty. When I pointed out that they had it for a month and that's when the warranty expired, they asked me, "Why didn't you bring it in earlier?" I had to argue with the service center manager to have them waive the charge.

The other thing to keep in mind with DVD recorders is that when you record with LP or SLP/EP (to record 4 or 6 hours on a disc), the quality is much less satisfying than the same quality settings on VHS. Basically, the higher the compression, the more pixellated or "blocky" the picture becomes. With VHS, the picture just gets more fuzzy, but it's not that distracting compared to compression artifacts on DVD. At the 2 hour setting, though, it's great.

- Saki [faqs]




Jump To: