Reviewers Recommend
Dirty Cop (All Her Luv)Dirty Cop (All Her Luv) - review by Danielmayu33216
Starring: Alison Rey, Isa Bella. Read review
All Forums > The Feature Side > The Feature Side Forum Page 63 > Dubbing in films
AuthorPost
Gambio
Member


35 Posts
7/03
Posted - Aug 5 2003 : 1:03PM
Seems to me that there are four sound categories of the sex scenes in films today:

1. The sound of the performers are included, no dubbing occures.

2. The sound of the performers are included, but due to slow motion effects, the sound is dubbed. It is, however, the actual sounds from the sex scene that is laid over the slow motion segments, and if it werent for the slow-motion effects you wouldn't notice the dubbing at all.

3. As no.2 but the sound seems to be recorded afterwards in a studio and doesnt sync with the action at all. The sound (i.e. the girls moaning) is often a bit over the top and/or obviously faked.

4. No sound at all, music only.

This has turned out to be a problem for me and my girl chosing films, since her main criterias are:
1. She wants to hear the performers natural sex sounds, without it being over the top or faked.
2. She wants scenes or films that start out slow, with kissing, fondling, passionate sex, and perhaps less explicit. She doesnt necessarily want it to be in slow motion, but this is often the case with these types of films/scenes.

This leaves us with films from category no.2(since the slower paced films often contains category no. 3 or 4 sound), but these are rare to find, ... Astroknight's reviews has really helped us a lot here, but we still would need some more help.

Is it possible to apply the categories above to certain directors? From Astroknights reviews we can tell that f.e. Nick Orleans and Nicholas Steele use quite some dubbing in their films, but is it the dubbing from category no. 2 or 3?

Or does anyone have suggestions for films with the sex described above, and with sound as in category no.1?

Last, I've got questions about the sound in the following films, which category do they apply to?
Dinner Party
Rocky Road's Wet Dreams
Scent of Passion
Heart and Soul
Wildlower
and Zazel

TonyC
Comstock Films

2523 Posts
8/03
Posted - Aug 5 2003 : 5:15PM
At the risk of sounding like I'm tooting my own horn, I'm going to offer that "Marie and Jack: A Love Story" fits the above criteria almost perfectly.

All of the action is shoot and presented with good quality syncronous sound. The sex scene is based on a relationship between the performers (husband and wife), starts slowly with lots of very sensuous kissing and petting, and features not one, but two female orgasms (this is where shooting syncronous sound really pays off!)

What's the catch? "Marie and Jack" is short. The film is 28 minutes long, and the DVD extra is a 16 minute interactive version of their sex scene. That said, there are probably more (beautifully timed) edits in the 28 minutes of "Marie and Jack" than there are in 280 of "standard porn".

Since I've already steered you wrong with the gay porn idea, I'll make you a deal. Order a copy of "Marie and Jack" off our website:

Comstock Films

And if you don't like it, return it and I'll refund your money. What's the catch? If you do like it, post a rave review on here! Sound like a deal?

-T.C.




Jump To: