I'd opt for the laptop. I realize that pocket PCs are getting more powerful and more versatile but they just aren't there yet - at least IMHO. PDAs have a lot of uses as well but are nowhere near being a substitute for the "big iron" - and the remaining option which ought to be high on the list, tablet PCs, are still way over-priced for the power & features offered.
Depends on your college. Some require laptops, at others, class policies may prohibit laptops (due to disruption factor of a bunch of people tapping at keyboards, playing games, surfing the web, etc).
With that said, a small laptop is worth a lot more than most PDA's. It's very, very hard to take meaningful notes with a PDA at the speed at which you have to take notes in class, especially without a keyboard input. With a microphone, you could store a whole semester's worth lectures on the hard drive without worrying about sound quality or storage capacity. If you have to carry it with you all day, you definitely don't want a laptop over 5 pounds.
If your college or library (or even the local Starbucks) has wireless access or network ports, a laptop is much handier since it's murder to surf the web on a PDA.
I like the recording idea. I stink at note taking. If I take notes, I miss half of what's being said. If I just listen I absorb a lot more information. But then with no notes, I would have nothing to go back to. Recording a class (or meeting, in my case) would be best for me. Taking written notes from the recording would be the perfect way of reinforcing the class (or meeting).
You gotta be minted. When I was studying I had to pinch half used note books out of the other punter's satchels. That, or rely on the free management science degree dispenser in the gents :-o (The old ones are the best aren't they ?!).
Seriously though, I'd go for the lap top so you can use it on the hoof and not get eye strained from over use of anything smaller back at your digs when you write the papers later.
The key is to edit down the lectures fairly quickly. So, although I agree the key is also reinforcement, I think the audio idea is going to require you to sit through all the the lectures in more or less real time an dto my mind if you've still got to do notes from it you might as well do it in the actual lecture.
Good luck.
Z.
[Link]
AlexPanzer Deactivated User
1593 Posts 6/03
Posted - Nov 17 2003 : 6:31PM
I decided to settle down on the Toshiba e750 Pocket PC. A lot of places sell it for $400-$500 but I found good place that sells it for $325. For $325 I think that it is a bargain - processors is 400MHZ, and thats great. I thought about laptop, I have one, a shitty one at 300Mhz Pentium 2. I have Windows XP on it and it is sllllllllloooooooowwwwwwww, intolerably slow, and its lcd is kinda leaking out bluish colors. Pocket PC is great i think.
[Link]
BillyTalent Deactivated User
14 Posts 11/03
Posted - Nov 20 2003 : 12:13AM
one of the bad things about recording lectures, is you'll never listen to it all. A notebook and pen works the best I've found. That and going to class EVERYday.
Porno movies, sexy videos, xxx. Adult DVD Talk at your service. 6409 Posts 11/99
Posted - Nov 20 2003 : 11:57AM
taking good notes is one of the most important skills you learn in college. no gadgets are a must. you aren't going to sit in a business meeting with a laptop taking notes. you'll have a pen and paper to jot down what you need to remember/do.
the most important things i learned in college... note taking, summarizing, researching, indoor gardening... wait scratch that last one.
If you take notes it compels your mind to focus on the important stuff. I would find it too annoying to have to type in a classroom in one of those crummy seats. As gadgets, Pocket PCs are cool, but I don't know how you're gonna take notes with one. I was accustomed to seeing people show up for tape recorders, but sitting through a class ONCE is bad enough without going back to relive it. Unless the lecturer is brilliant or something, but most of the time you're just gonna have a graduate assistant minion dishing out the pre-fab knowhow.
On the other hand, I'm fascinated b the idea of recording interviews as MP3 files and loading into the Mac. That could make transcription easier for me.
[Link]
AlexPanzer Deactivated User
1593 Posts 6/03
Posted - Nov 20 2003 : 2:05PM
Well, you can even take notes with pocket pc. Theres a program that lets you write notes on a pocket pc and other program that transfers the notes to text. You can even watch movies in Mpeg, and DivX formats on pocket pc.
There's a Pocket PC that can decipher MY handwriting?
Technology has come a long way!
[Link]
AlexPanzer Deactivated User
1593 Posts 6/03
Posted - Nov 21 2003 : 2:14PM
I bet
[Link]
conquistador Deactivated User
Hellhamster. 2947 Posts 10/03
Posted - Nov 26 2003 : 6:31AM
Hello Alex
I'm a university student currently and I am getting by fine with a pen, notebook(thepaper kind), and my desktop. Gadgets will never take the place of going to class, taking notes and studying. I see some kids in my classes who bring laptops etc. and they are doing no better then the kids who just go to class and put in genuine effort.
You'll do fine if you just attend class Alex, I'm sure.
Good luck and do not ever let school get in the way of your education
ned
[Link]
AlexPanzer Deactivated User
1593 Posts 6/03
Posted - Nov 26 2003 : 1:09PM
Thanks, I thought about the laptop too, and I came with conclusion that it wil be a hassle for me. I plan to purchase a messanger-type bag, a notebook and a pair of a mechanical paper and ballpoint pen.
From experience, it's very hard to take notes at speed with a PDA, even if you're very good with the shortcut handwriting input. The frequency of errors makes it hard to take accurate notes and concentrate on what's being said. PDA's make good organizers and reference devices but are not practical for serious purposes due to slower processors and small screen size.
From a business standpoint, I'd agree with Steph, although the number of laptops that are appearing in meetings and people taking notes on them has dramatically increased over the past couple of years.
Recording lectures is never a good replacement for taking notes, but they do help if you need clarification on cryptic handwriting or if you're unclear about a concept. My college offered videotaped replays of selected classes on the cable network, which really helped out if I was lucky enough to be a distance-learning enabled class, especially if the prof liked to use the whiteboard a lot.
On my Pocket PC writing is easy for me. Not really easy but easy, I have no problems with it. I have to poke the screen to write something but I am thinking about getting hardware keyboard for it.