New Pornstar Interviews - [more]
Little Puck Interview

"I’m a woman of varied tastes. I can get off to a lot of different things. I enjoy switching it up."
All Forums > The Porn Pool > The Porn Pool Forum Page 547 > Is "gonzo" porn really gay porn in disguise?
Page 1 of 3 2 > Last
AuthorPost
Midtown
Deactivated User

299 Posts
7/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 3:15PM
I think this is a legitimate question. So many "gonzo" scenes have multiple guys. The screen is filled more with shots of their butts and penises than with images of the woman, who many times seems to have been included almost as an afterthought. I ask this question also because of the degree of physical contact between the men in the scenes. In many cases, their genitalia are touching or they are going down on a girl after another guy has been inside her. It just seems like the girl is a conduit for intimate sexual contact between two or more men. Add to this the more recent fascination with including strap-ons and even transvestites in scenes, and I'm wondering what is really going on here.

Edited by - Midtown on Oct 12 2006

Eric381
Deactivated User

What are you looking at? It
2452 Posts
3/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 3:18PM
Ahhh, yet another over-analyzed, intellectual "is this considered homosexual?" thread...

(Sigh)

Twiki
Member

bidibidibidibidi
99 Posts
5/06
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 3:19PM
It obviously is to you.
Midtown
Deactivated User

299 Posts
7/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 3:29PM
This following link is worth reading:

[invalid URL removed]How Internet porn is changing your sex life

"In his essay 'Big Red Son', American writer, David Foster Wallace, says: "In-your-face vileness is part of the schizoid direction porn's been moving in all decade. For just as adult entertainment has become more 'mainstream' ... it has also become more extreme and not just on the Bizarro margins."

"In nearly all hetero porn now, there is an emphasis on anal sex, painful penetrations, degrading tableaux, and the (at least) psychological abuse of women."

"In certain respects this extremism may simply be porn's tracing Hollywood's own entertainment arc: It's hardly news that TV and legit film have also gotten more violent and explicit and raw," says Wallace.

It's a sobering thought that many young men may now consider these sort of extreme sexual acts as "normal" and young women, exposed to the demands of these men, consider compliance with them reasonable.

Edited by - Midtown on 10/12/2006 3:34:23 PM

Eric381
Deactivated User

What are you looking at? It
2452 Posts
3/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 3:50PM
Well, let's put it this way, using myself as one example. I watch plenty of gonzo porn...and I don't EVER feel the need, tendacy or the likeness to play the skinflute, or penetrate another man's asshole.

Whether I'm in the majority or minority, I don't give a fuck.

Is that simple enough for you, or would you prefer a more complex, over-analyzed answer??

 
Twiki
Member

bidibidibidibidi
99 Posts
5/06
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 3:55PM
Maybe, but it has little to do with the topic of this thread.
Robbie
Member

884 Posts
1/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 4:01PM
Probably not, but it is a 5* link
Gunzo
Senior Member

1377 Posts
2/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 5:15PM
If you're a gay male, you're turned on by hot male models displaying boxer shorts... if not, you're probably mainly straight. This doesn't necessarily mean that you wouldn't enjoy gay sex...
Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14596 Posts
3/02
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 5:35PM
I assume that gay actually means male-homosexual to you, since you gave all that girl-on-girl action a pass.

If gonzo was gay porn in disguise I doubt gay men would be paying the outrageous prices commanded by actual gay porn. The fact that gay men buy gay porn, not straight gonzo porn, is a pretty clear indicator that it doesn't float their boat. If you can convince me how it can be 'gay' when gays aren't into it then you might have a valid point. However, I'm unmoved by anything you've advanced so far.

Regarding the multiple-guys-per-girl phenomenon, I subscribe to the 'frat boys' theory, which says that all those guys in straight porn create a frat house 'party' atmosphere, which says more about the attitude of the producers than it does about the consumers. As for your other criteria, I'm watching plenty of porn and not seeing all this genital-touching or post-cum muff diving. I also don't see that strap-on sex equates to homosexual interest, any more than sticking a finger up my own ass makes me a homosexual. As for she-males, I don't get it, but I don't judge it, either.

I do agree that having circus-sex porn be the first exposure to sex that youngsters have can be problematic. On the other hand, my personal sex life was at least as wild-and-crazy as most porn before I ever saw an X-rated movie. We should bear in mind that inhibitions are societal creations, not natural phenomena. Social arbiters may complain when porn thumbs it's nose at said inhibitions but they err when claiming it perverts 'real' sex.

If parents don't like the idea of their kids learning from porn then they should pull their heads out of the sand and get in there with their own lessons first.

DancesWithPorn
Member

Why say no, when it feels so good to say yes.
117 Posts
10/06
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 5:57PM
Honestly I can see how porn can lead to more perverse things and possibly homosexuality. A good example is the Rogue series. I'm sure there are a lot of straight guys who have checked out that series or have considered checking it out who started with some really light softcore boy/girl titles before moving on to it.

Edited by - danceswithporn on 10/12/2006 6:10:41 PM

Steve Holmes
Senior Member

1235 Posts
12/02
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 6:22PM
I personally like DPs. It's a good feeling but it's more the idea of a girl being a total slut to have two guys fucking her. I like it in porn and in my private live.

I don't like Gangbangs, but I do it because I'm getting paid for it.

Does any of this makes me gay? I don't give a fuck.

Steve Holmes

Edited by - Steve Holmes on 10/12/2006 6:25:42 PM

phatbasey
Senior Member

1390 Posts
1/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 6:23PM
TonyC
Comstock Films

2523 Posts
8/03
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 6:38PM
He's an interesting fact: about half the guys who have sucked cock in the last 12 month consider themselves straight. What sort of porn do you suppose they're buying?
Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14596 Posts
3/02
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 6:49PM
I'm afraid your fact doesn't give me any idea what type of porn they buy. Do you have a fact to advance, or a proposition, or are you just playing devil's advocate?
Outlaw Biker
Member

New York State
13 Posts
5/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 7:13PM
Hmmm! Think it is called; "Double Penetration" and "Gangbang"! Huh?.."Gonzo" is now HOMOSEXUAL?..Most HETEROSEXUAL MEN would be enjoying the FEMALE'S enjoyment of several MALES satisfying her needs!...Obviously you have never been to STURGIS, DAYTONA, MYRTLE BEACH and seen the hotel and motel mattresses piled on the curbs for pick-up after a BIKE RUN!..Called; "ADULT FUN"! If "Gonzo" is "HOMO"; then Rip Taylor and Richard Simmons fathered every 1% biker and are my PROUD PARENTS!

Paul Martin

 
TonyC
Comstock Films

2523 Posts
8/03
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 7:21PM
Emo.
Tinaka
Member

953 Posts
8/03
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 7:37PM
Just like whatever you like, and be happy (and stay out of trouble). Unless men (not shemales) are having sex, it's not gay.
skronker
Notable Legendary Icon

Scopophiliac
9780 Posts
9/02
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 7:55PM
That's quite a different tune than you sang back in Vegas, loverboy.

It's no gayer, or straighter, than anything else. As far as porn goes, to me "parts is parts." I think, whether it's a Field Day for the Mope Squad or a Three Girl Rhumba, we're dealing with a "hive mind" when gonzo's the game.

As for David Foster Wallace, he makes some good points though bear in mind he spent a lot of time hanging out with Max Hardcore in that story.


Edited by - skronker on 10/12/2006 7:59:57 PM

RandomPrecision
Senior Member

Enjoy!
8175 Posts
3/06
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 8:02PM
Human sexuality is complex. I don't think gonzo is necessarily "gay porn in disguise".

For one thing, society has come to accept homosexuality at least to the point to where gay people don't have to spend their whole lives hiding in the closet if they don't want to. They likely won't be disowned by their families or fired from their jobs if they "come out". There's still quite a bit of stigma there but not nearly as bad as it once was.

My guess is that most people who are entirely gay eventually just say so. With the (relative) anonymity of the internet, why would an entirely gay man want to watch women get fucked? He can look at as much gay porn as he wants to on the net and nobody will be the wiser. No reason to pretend when he's alone with his computer.

What I DO think is that we (humans) may be getting to the point to where we are starting to realize that there are many more people with bisexual tendencies than was once thought. The attitude about it has become quite a bit more relaxed so people don't beat themselves up about it so much if they pop a boner on some shemale content or (gasp) actually see an exposed cock (other than their own) and feel just a bit aroused by it.

In the end, I say.....so what if it is gay porn in disguise? I don't really think it is. As I said, I think it DOES have some (male as well as female) bisexual elements but for me, personally - If I wanted to see gay porn, I'd watch gay porn. I like women (I have had bisexual fantasies like probably pretty much everyone else on the planet) so I watch women.

Outlaw Biker
Member

New York State
13 Posts
5/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 8:05PM
LIVE and LET LIVE"!..some of the most beautiful TRANSGENDERED people from all over the world come to AMERICA to visit the world's best bike rallies!..LADIES ALL! and some are AMAZINGLY beautiful! Many meet bikers who appreciate them. Once again; it is called; "FUN" and "LIVING LIFE TO THE FULLEST"!..This site is "ALL ABOUT PORN"!..supposedly about ENTERTAINMENT and ADULTS who have a choice in this GREAT COUNTRY to choose what appeals to them sexually.."LIGHTEN-UP"!!!..Be GOOD people and STOP the inane postings..ENJOY LIFE and all the INDUSTRY provides us!..Sincerely, Paul Martin

Paul Martin

threesomebody
Official BlowBang Judge

Would you like my autograph?
2491 Posts
12/04
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 8:45PM
What's really going on Midtown, is that porn is being made for people other than just you. Like Mr. Holmes, I love DPs in DVDs as well as in my private life. So maybe gonzo is being made for me? Sure seems like it.
TonyC
Comstock Films

2523 Posts
8/03
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 8:50PM
Maybe you're a gay man trapped in a hot chick's body?
TonyC
Comstock Films

2523 Posts
8/03
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 8:51PM
I have proof Loraine is.
nietzsche
Deactivated User

5470 Posts
8/03
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 8:52PM
I just jerked off to this.
Eric381
Deactivated User

What are you looking at? It
2452 Posts
3/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 8:52PM
+ fucking 1,000!!
Was that while I was stupid drunk, or on the show floor...and just hungover?

Did I cop a feel? Damn...self incrimination!

Edited by - Eric381 on 10/12/2006 8:56:36 PM
 
nietzsche
Deactivated User

5470 Posts
8/03
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 8:53PM
**explodes**
john thomas
Deactivated User

1168 Posts
6/06
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 9:16PM
I'd like to be trapped in threesomebody's body. Does that make me gay?
Eric381
Deactivated User

What are you looking at? It
2452 Posts
3/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 9:24PM
Would intercourse qualify as being "inside"?

Sorry 3SB, had to do it hun

nietzsche
Deactivated User

5470 Posts
8/03
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 9:31PM
This thread has spun wonderfully out of control.
john thomas
Deactivated User

1168 Posts
6/06
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 9:43PM
Yeah, that was the joke. No need to beat it to death. (I know it is tempting to beat it to death when 3sb is around, but still...)
john thomas
Deactivated User

1168 Posts
6/06
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 9:44PM
Well the thread title only needs a two letter reply (though you can choose between 'N'&'O' or 'F'&'U' according to personal preference) so we might as well just have fun with it now.
Twizted6
Senior Member

Good & Evil is merely a matter of perspective, I perfer to call myself... Determined
1229 Posts
7/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 10:04PM
If I ask 3SB to fuck me with her strap-on, would that make me gay?
skronker
Notable Legendary Icon

Scopophiliac
9780 Posts
9/02
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 10:10PM
3SB doesn't even have a MySpace page.

I think Outlaw Biker and Steve Holmes ought to meet me and 3SB at that pig bar in Hell's Kitchen in a couple of hours and we'll figure out what's gay or not.

Eric, don't you remember when we fought over Noahped like a BBQ chicken wing?

(joke, I know you were all up in Tiana's ribcage)

melpster
Member

582 Posts
5/05
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 10:50PM
Does me wanting to be there to watch this make me gay? Or just a bad slash fanfic writer?
skronker
Notable Legendary Icon

Scopophiliac
9780 Posts
9/02
Posted - Oct 12 2006 : 11:44PM
No, that means you want me and Holmesy to fight over you like a chicken wing, while Outlaw Biker shows 3SB the true meaning of love.

Or else we all hold hands and dance around the giant pig!

Edited by - skronker on 10/12/2006 11:45:48 PM

 
Eric381
Deactivated User

What are you looking at? It
2452 Posts
3/05
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 12:48AM
That depends, does being the catcher ONLY count as gay? Or just being the pitcher? Or both? Midtown, we need your expertise on this matter, please assist!
Is that what that was??
But 3SB said she wanted to be DP'ed...no? Are you & Holmesy fighting over who gets dibs on the other hole (first)?
Edited by - Eric381 on 10/13/2006 12:52:14 AM
Loraine
Senior Member

1559 Posts
3/04
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 2:15AM
This could well turn out to be the hottest porn we've seen in a long time, so Melpster I'd be grateful if you took along a camera for the benefit of us out of towners. And yes of course it makes you gay, we're all gay. And the answer to Midtown's question is yes too - it is a conspiracy.
Midtown
Deactivated User

299 Posts
7/05
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 2:54AM
I find it interesting that there is so much resistance to even discussing this matter. I found another fairly recent thread where folks berated the thread starter for simply raising the issue of male to male genital contact in films:

[invalid URL removed]Thread

It is entirely valid to ask what porn producers intend with the material they are putting out these days. All are agreed that porn has changed dramatically in the last few years, with far more debatably gay/bisexual themes and images in "mainstream" porn. Why this change all of a sudden? What was so wrong with that tried and true formula of an attractive heterosexual couple having sex on terms that were neither illegal, abusive, unhealthy or downright dangerous? Is this really an issue of sexual addiction, whereby some folks are now so desensitized that "normal" sex does not satisfy them? My gut tells me that porn is now pandering to either closet homosexuals or potentially dangerous sex addicts. Either way, I think it's an unfortunate state of affairs for both the porn industry and the individuals viewing these more graphically extreme videos.

Edited by - Midtown on 10/13/2006 3:01:44 AM

Dean Wormer
Senior Member

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life, son.
1048 Posts
7/04
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 3:31AM
It's gay if the only girl getting banged is actually a guy. But then again it would be obvious that it was a gay porno.

"The time has come for someone to put his foot down....and that foot is me."

Hardware All-Star Supporter
All-Star Member

Your other left
14596 Posts
3/02
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 5:30AM
We are? Certainly it has in some ways - trannies, for example, but in terms of the sex acts being depicted it really hasn't changed much at all.

I will agree that it seems more posters are concerned about images they deem to be gay/bisexual showing up in 'their' porn than they were a few years ago, but perception isn't always reality. Considering that far more porn is made nowadays, I'm not sure that the material you cite represents a larger percentage than it ever did. In fact, I can't remember seeing a guy sucking cock in a 'straight' movie in a long time, so my perception is that there's less than there used to be.

Texan
Member

167 Posts
3/04
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 8:45AM
Watching a bunch of guys wank their dicks is of no interest to me. But watching the same scene w/ a girl in the middle changes everything. I like blow bangs and gang bangs because it conveys the sense that the girl is horny as hell and hot for dick and cum. My kind of girl!
threesomebody
Official BlowBang Judge

Would you like my autograph?
2491 Posts
12/04
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 9:45AM
No. I said I love doing DP's in my private life. And I was asking Mr. Holmes and Mr. Malone to help me out with my next one. Well, maybe I forgot to type that last part.
melpster
Member

582 Posts
5/05
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 11:28AM
Suddenly very interested in this giant pig scenario. Sounds decidedly pagan. Mama likes, mama likes!

But you and Holmes feel free to pull me in you're ready for a little meat in that man sammich. Somebody else is going to have to hold the video camera, though.

Midtown
Deactivated User

299 Posts
7/05
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 3:49PM
"man sammich"...Is that what this is all about?
skronker
Notable Legendary Icon

Scopophiliac
9780 Posts
9/02
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 4:31PM
Nothing at all. Which is why you can rent thousands of DVDs this second that feature exactly this.

I somehow get the feeling you are going out of your way to rent material that offends your taste so you can have the pleasure of complaining about it.

I watch giant bubbling assloads of smut morning, noon and night -- much of it, believe it or not, for purely scientific reasons -- and even amid all the gonzo fare, most of it is pretty straightforward stuff. There is a lot of porn you can find with a harder edge, blowjobs especially are more intense these days, and anal seems mandatory, but also it is easier than ever to find titles that cater to your exact whim and fancy. That's what the Internet is handy for.

I am sure there is a law of diminishing returns with some of the porn audience. The "Hardened End User" of urban lore and legend, whose drool puddles on his semen-caked floor, next to the two-week's supply of half-eaten pizza cold in its cardboard delivery boxes, crushed beer cans piled in a corner like a totem to the Burp God.

Oh wait, that's my apartment!

Honestly, I've watched every scrap of miscreant misanthropic mayhem you can even begin to imagine, and I still get off, about 90% of the time, during either the intro/tease segments (before anyone's punctured an orifice or punched any hapless teenage meth addicts in the face) or in the instances of what I believe is termed "hot sex," typically a one-on-one scene. The hottest moment in your beloved Fuck Slaves is Ardianna Nicole addressing Manuel Ferrara, just spitting out her nasty fantasies. He's fucking the shit out of her and knocking her around, but what's hot is her sharp gasps of breath, the way her lips pucker and vibrate, the intense look on his face and the hair that hangs in his eyes, the way the muscles move under their skin. You can see they are fucking, but you really only see their heads and shoulders. That's the fucking hottest minute of videotaped professional sex I've seen this year. So, I dunno ... take it where you can find it, I guess. In my experience, you can only have specific types of sex with people who enjoy those flavors, consenting adults and all that, so I don't see how it's anyone's business except for the people fucking.

Edited by - skronker on 10/13/2006 4:33:50 PM

skronker
Notable Legendary Icon

Scopophiliac
9780 Posts
9/02
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 4:42PM
A lot of gonzo DOES confuse rough sex with passionate sex, I'll give you that. And it misses the point as far as what's really erotic and what's just stupid and thuggish. However, my intepretation of that may likely be very different from your interpretation.

However, I'm not sure why I should be concerned if straight porn is catering to closet homosexuals. I think a fair amount of it caters to regular homosexuals who enjoy watching male cock and ass. Um ... so what? I, personally, do not enjoy watching scenes where girls have to eat out dude's assholes. I fast forward through those scenes. I don't like the "head upside down pistoning" BJ position, so popular these days. I FF thru that. I make a note of it in reviews, so producers know what one fan likes or dislikes, for further reference. But I have a good handle on which directors make stuff I am pretty sure to enjoy, and that's what I watch. And, for me, the less porn is overly defined by "straight" or "gay," the better.

It's like Baskin Robbins. You want Rocky Road or Peppermint Pistachio, you can get as many scoops as you like!

Midtown
Deactivated User

299 Posts
7/05
Posted - Oct 13 2006 : 9:44PM
If porn isn't becoming totally gay male oriented, then why are girl/girl scenes totally derided? Is it that the female anatomy isn't enough? Is the image of a hot woman not in itself arousing? And, if so, then HELLO! you gotta wake up and smell the coffee. That's all I'm saying.
skronker
Notable Legendary Icon

Scopophiliac
9780 Posts
9/02
Posted - Oct 14 2006 : 1:29AM
You're having a conversation with yourself, dude.
Loraine
Senior Member

1559 Posts
3/04
Posted - Oct 14 2006 : 1:51AM
The gay male in me responds to the males in a movie, especially if the male is someone I find attractive or appealing. I just regret I don't see their faces a bit more often.

There's lots that's not so great in gonzo porn, but I think your conspiracy theory is erroneous and even if it were true or correct, would it be so very bad? I'm having trouble understanding your concern.

I guess one way to think about it might be to imagine yourself in the scene, how would you handle the interaction? Would you turn to your fuck fellow and say, "No way I'm going near that pussy now you've been in there! Good god man, what were you thinking!"

I've said it before on this forum, if two men I cared for were fucking me and they enjoyed each other as well, I'd be completely delighted. If the girl on screen were to be getting pleasure from her two partners interacting would that make gonzo porn okay for you Midtown?

skronker
Notable Legendary Icon

Scopophiliac
9780 Posts
9/02
Posted - Oct 14 2006 : 1:57AM
Loraine, when you need an "extra hand," know you can always call ... I'll swim to Australia, with TonyC, if need be.
eshine
Member

9 Posts
6/05
Posted - Oct 14 2006 : 2:21AM
Uhm, yeah - Gonzo film directors are spending thousands of dollars producing and marketing films to straight audiences under the guise that these are straight films - when, actually - they are gay films targeted towards who? Closeted gay men afraid to pick up the latest copy of Bareback mountain?

Cmon, man.

Listen, as a gay guy I can tell you that we have zero interest in watching a dirl get a DAP, vomit or get choked to a point of almost passing out - kay? We have plenty of nasty gay product to refer to. As far as the whole transvestite and strap-on thang - Gay men don't particularly go for trannies, and if a guy is getting fucked hard up the ass - we usually prefer it's done by another guy.

That's not to say that there isn't a grey area and I see nothing gay about a straight guy who is into this sort of thing, just as I see nothing straight about a gay guy who likes to watch a girl eat a plate full of cum from a room full of dudes.

For example, I am a major fan of Brandon Iron's GSOI series and his site, spermcocktail. For one thing, Brandon is a class act and treats his girls like human beings - and Personally, I LOVE watching a willing girl happily consume copiuous amounts of cum shot directly into her mouth from a roomful of grunting, masculine straight men. Ther is no bigger turn on than watching the cum slowly collected into a glass or bowl and then gobbled up - this is rarely seem in gay porn. My only complaint is that the guys faces aren't shown enough.

So trust me, the average gay man likes to watch other gay men having sex and aren't interested in straight gonzo porn. I am an exception because I love cum so much, but trust me - I'm a commodity. The minute a chick is even brought into the picture, most of my gay freinds wince like bitches.

So, Midtown - if any of my likes or dislikes make you feel gay or uncomfortable, then that's between you and your therapist - but my simple suggestion would be to rent out the type of porn you like and quite with the "gonzo as gay" conspiracy theroies - there is plenty of smut to go around.

All Forums > The Porn Pool > The Porn Pool Forum Page 547Is "gonzo" porn really gay porn in disguise?

Previous topic: Private Castings
Next topic: does porn actors used steroids?
Page 1 of 3 2 > Last



Jump To: